| Santa Teresa record vs | rec/yr | location |
| Alamogordo | 3-17 | |
| Alamogordo 65 Santa Teresa 51 | 2005-06 | Alamogordo |
| Alamogordo 73 Santa Teresa 53 | 2008-09 | H |
| Alamogordo 44 Santa Teresa 38 | 2009-10 | T |
| Santa Teresa 47 Alamogordo 29 | 2010-11 | H |
| Alamogordo 46 Santa Teresa 44 | 2011-12 | T |
| Alamogordo 34 Santa Teresa 28 | 2012-13 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 52 Alamogordo 42 | 2012-13 | H |
| Alamogordo 41 Santa Teresa 28 | 2013-14 | T |
| Alamogordo 38 Santa Teresa 34 | 2014-15 | H |
| Alamogordo 46 Santa Teresa 25 | 2014-15 | T |
| Alamogordo 60 Santa Teresa 33 | 2015-16 | T |
| Alamogordo 46 Santa Teresa 43 | 2015-16 | H |
| Alamogordo 59 Santa Teresa 10 | 2016-17 | H |
| Alamogordo 80 Santa Teresa 49 | 2016-17 | T |
| Alamogordo 75 Santa Teresa 64 | 2017-18 | Los Lunas |
| Alamogordo 67 Santa Teresa 38 | 2017-18 | T |
| Alamogordo 67 Santa Teresa 58 | 2017-18 | H |
| Santa Teresa 72 Alamogordo 71 | 2018-19 | H |
| Alamogordo 68 Santa Teresa 39 | 2019-20 | T |
| Alamogordo 81 Santa Teresa 41 | 2021-22 | T |
| Albuquerque Atrisco Heritage | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 46 Atrisco Heritage 32 | 2011-12 | S-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Cibola | 0-1 | |
| Cibola 60 Santa Teresa 44 | 2019-20 | Las Cruces |
| Albuquerque Del Norte | 0-2 | |
| Del Norte 84 Santa Teresa 55 | 2005-06 | S-T |
| Del Norte 55 Santa Teresa 50 | 2013-14 | Rio Rancho |
| Albuquerque Highland | 0-2 | |
| Highland 70 Santa Teresa 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Highland 73 Santa Teresa 50 | 2019-20 | T |
| Albuquerque La Cueva | 0-1 | |
| La Cueva 76 Santa Teresa 25 | 2022-23 | Las Cruces |
| Albuquerque Manzano | 0-2 | |
| Manzano 46 Santa Teresa 37 | 2012-13 | Rio Rancho |
| Manzano 69 Santa Teresa 57 | 2021-22 | Las Cruces |
| Albuquerque Sandia | 0-1 | |
| Sandia 75 Santa Teresa 54 | 2007-08 | Alamogordo |
| Albuquerque Sandia Prep | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 45 Sandia Prep 34 | 2014-15 | Alamogordo |
| Albuquerque St Pius X | 0-3 | |
| St Pius X 73 Santa Teresa 63 | 2006-07 | S-H |
| St Pius X 79 Santa Teresa 77 | 2010-11 | S-Albuquerque |
| St Pius X 51 Santa Teresa 43 | 2012-13 | S-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Valley | 0-4 | |
| Valley 49 Santa Teresa 33 | 2006-07 | Alamogordo |
| Valley 56 Santa Teresa 41 | 2018-19 | H |
| Valley 74 Santa Teresa 56 | 2019-20 | T |
| Valley 76 Santa Teresa 40 | 2019-20 | S-T |
| Albuquerque West Mesa | 0-2 | |
| West Mesa 37 Santa Teresa 34 | 2008-09 | Alamogordo |
| West Mesa 67 Santa Teresa 60 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Animas | 0-1 | |
| Animas 57 Santa Teresa 50 | 2004-05 | Lordsburg |
| Anthony (TX) | 5-3 | |
| Santa Teresa 52 Anthony 47 | 2003-04 | T |
| Santa Teresa 67 Anthony 38 | 2005-06 | T |
| Anthony 46 Santa Teresa 43 | 2005-06 | H |
| Santa Teresa 57 Anthony 42 | 2017-18 | Fabens |
| Anthony 56 Santa Teresa 50 | 2021-22 | H |
| Santa Teresa 59 Anthony 46 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 67 Anthony 45 | 2022-23 | Anthony |
| Anthony 51 Santa Teresa 37 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| Anthony Gadsden | 6-18 | |
| Gadsden 87 Santa Teresa 71 | 1995-96 | H |
| Gadsden 80 Santa Teresa 55 | 1995-96 | T |
| Gadsden 70 Santa Teresa 60 | 1996-97 | H |
| Santa Teresa 62 Gadsden 56 | 1997-98 | H |
| Santa Teresa 67 Gadsden 56 | 1998-99 | T |
| Gadsden 72 Santa Teresa 69 | 99-2000 | T |
| Gadsden 45 Santa Teresa 26 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gadsden 34 Santa Teresa 23 | 2002-03 | H |
| Gadsden 63 Santa Teresa 47 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gadsden 53 Santa Teresa 47 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gadsden 59 Santa Teresa 44 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gadsden 43 Santa Teresa 38 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 41 Gadsden 38 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gadsden 46 Santa Teresa 40 | 2009-10 | H |
| Gadsden 53 Santa Teresa 51 | 2010-11 | T |
| Santa Teresa 41 Gadsden 27 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 43 Gadsden 34 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gadsden 48 Santa Teresa 36 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gadsden 54 Santa Teresa 20 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gadsden 59 Santa Teresa 35 | 2015-16 | H |
| Gadsden 69 Santa Teresa 57 | 2017-18 | Los Lunas |
| Gadsden 74 Santa Teresa 62 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gadsden 74 Santa Teresa 37 | 2019-20 | T |
| Santa Teresa 71 Gadsden 61 | 2023-24 | H |
| Artesia | 4-9 | |
| Santa Teresa 49 Artesia 47 | 2008-09 | T |
| Santa Teresa 46 Artesia 42 | 2009-10 | H |
| Santa Teresa 52 Artesia 50 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 65 Artesia 62 | 2011-12 | H |
| Artesia 50 Santa Teresa 45 | 2012-13 | T |
| Artesia 58 Santa Teresa 45 | 2013-14 | H |
| Artesia 54 Santa Teresa 30 | 2016-17 | T |
| Artesia 46 Santa Teresa 29 | 2017-18 | H |
| Artesia 69 Santa Teresa 57 | 2018-19 | T |
| Artesia 67 Santa Teresa 47 | 2019-20 | H |
| Artesia 75 Santa Teresa 46 | 2021-22 | H |
| Artesia 64 Santa Teresa 28 | 2022-23 | T |
| Artesia 81 Santa Teresa 59 | 2023-24 | H |
| Aztec | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 56 Aztec 52 | 2001-02 | Silver City |
| Bayard Cobre | 9-15 | |
| Cobre defeated Santa Teresa | 1994-95 | H |
| Cobre 91 Santa Teresa 66 | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Teresa 73 Cobre 56 | 1995-96 | |
| Cobre defeated Santa Teresa | 1995-96 | |
| Santa Teresa 67 Cobre 56 | 1996-97 | H |
| Santa Teresa 75 Cobre 63 | 1996-97 | T |
| Cobre 50 Santa Teresa 46 | 1996-97 | DT-H |
| Cobre 72 Santa Teresa 57 | 1997-98 | H |
| Cobre 79 Santa Teresa 70 | 1997-98 | T |
| Cobre 71 Santa Teresa 61 | 1997-98 | DT-T |
| Cobre 75 Santa Teresa 57 | 1998-99 | H |
| Cobre 94 Santa Teresa 79 | 1998-99 | T |
| Santa Teresa 79 Cobre 76 | 1998-99 | DT-T |
| Cobre 68 Santa Teresa 59 | 99-2000 | T |
| Cobre 59 Santa Teresa 55 | 99-2000 | H |
| Cobre 89 Santa Teresa 74 | 99-2000 | DT-T |
| Santa Teresa 69 Cobre 45 | 2016-17 | T |
| Cobre 65 Santa Teresa 64 | 2017-18 | H |
| Santa Teresa 63 Cobre 50 | 2018-19 | T |
| Santa Teresa 72 Cobre 66 | 2019-20 | H |
| Cobre 55 Santa Teresa 47 | 2020-21 | T |
| Cobre 49 Santa Teresa 44 | 2021-22 | T |
| Santa Teresa 64 Cobre 44 | 2022-23 | H |
| Santa Teresa 64 Cobre 54 | 2023-24 | T |
| Belen | 3-17 | |
| Belen 47 Santa Teresa 31 | 2002-03 | H |
| Belen 56 Santa Teresa 38 | 2002-03 | T |
| Belen 63 Santa Teresa 53 | 2003-04 | H |
| Belen 53 Santa Teresa 37 | 2003-04 | T |
| Belen 40 Santa Teresa 33 | 2003-04 | DT-T |
| Belen 41 Santa Teresa 33 | 2004-05 | T |
| Belen 56 Santa Teresa 50 | 2004-05 | H |
| Belen 58 Santa Teresa 43 | 2004-05 | DT-Belen |
| Santa Teresa 63 Belen 26 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 62 Belen 42 | 2011-12 | H |
| Santa Teresa 50 Belen 31 | 2012-13 | H |
| Belen 62 Santa Teresa 47 | 2013-14 | T |
| Belen 45 Santa Teresa 42 | 2014-15 | H |
| Belen 52 Santa Teresa 47 | 2014-15 | T |
| Belen 52 Santa Teresa 46 | 2015-16 | T |
| Belen 58 Santa Teresa 27 | 2015-16 | H |
| Belen 64 Santa Teresa 45 | 2016-17 | H |
| Belen 63 Santa Teresa 46 | 2017-18 | T |
| Belen 68 Santa Teresa 52 | 2018-19 | H |
| Belen 59 Santa Teresa 55 | 2019-20 | T |
| Bloomfield | 2-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 60 Bloomfield 32 | 2003-04 | Socorro |
| Santa Teresa 55 Bloomfield 46 | 2004-05 | Socorro |
| Canutillo (TX) | 3-10 | |
| Canutillo 65 Santa Teresa 64 | 1995-96 | T |
| Santa Teresa 66 Canutillo 58 | 1996-97 | T |
| Canutillo 84 Santa Teresa 49 | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Santa Teresa 43 | 2000-01 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Santa Teresa 51 | 2000-01 | Clint |
| Canutillo 62 Santa Teresa 43 | 2000-01 | T |
| Canutillo 61 Santa Teresa 32 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 41 Santa Teresa 34 | 2001-02 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Santa Teresa 61 | 2005-06 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 56 Santa Teresa 42 | 2006-07 | H |
| Santa Teresa 53 Canutillo 44 | 2007-08 | H |
| Canutillo 44 Santa Teresa 34 | 2008-09 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 41 Canutillo 37 | 2011-12 | Canutillo |
| Canyon Randall (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Randall 69 Santa Teresa 28 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Carlsbad | 3-6 | |
| Santa Teresa 61 Carlsbad 46 | 2008-09 | Alamogordo |
| Carlsbad 50 Santa Teresa 43 | 2009-10 | T |
| Carlsbad 56 Santa Teresa 48 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 71 Carlsbad 56 | 2011-12 | H |
| Santa Teresa 50 Carlsbad 47 | 2012-13 | H |
| Carlsbad 41 Santa Teresa 24 | 2013-14 | T |
| Carlsbad 53 Santa Teresa 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Carlsbad 57 Santa Teresa 49 | 2019-20 | T |
| Carlsbad 86 Santa Teresa 47 | 2021-22 | T |
| Centauri (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Centauri 74 Santa Teresa 59 | 1997-98 | Taos |
| Chaparral | 34-10 | |
| Santa Teresa 71 Chaparral 42 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Chaparral 48 Santa Teresa 44 | 2008-09 | H |
| Chaparral 45 Santa Teresa 38 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 55 Chaparral 47 | 2008-09 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 54 Chaparral 39 | 2009-10 | |
| Santa Teresa 55 Chaparral 47 | 2009-10 | |
| Santa Teresa 56 Chaparral 35 | 2009-10 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 62 Chaparral 27 | 2010-11 | T |
| Santa Teresa 52 Chaparral 23 | 2010-11 | T |
| Santa Teresa 44 Chaparral 29 | 2011-12 | H |
| Santa Teresa 64 Chaparral 50 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 44 Chaparral 33 | 2012-13 | T |
| Santa Teresa 53 Chaparral 26 | 2012-13 | H |
| Santa Teresa 43 Chaparral 40 | 2013-14 | H |
| Santa Teresa 32 Chaparral 30 | 2013-14 | T |
| Santa Teresa 68 Chaparral 25 | 2014-15 | H |
| Santa Teresa 51 Chaparral 16 | 2014-15 | T |
| Santa Teresa 45 Chaparral 34 | 2015-16 | T |
| Santa Teresa 51 Chaparral 45 | 2015-16 | H |
| Santa Teresa 91 Chaparral 54 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 48 Chaparral 43 | 2016-17 | T |
| Chaparral 58 Santa Teresa 50 | 2016-17 | H |
| Santa Teresa 57 Chaparral 48 | 2016-17 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 47 Chaparral 44 | 2017-18 | H |
| Santa Teresa 55 Chaparral 53 | 2017-18 | T |
| Santa Teresa 45 Chaparral 42 | 2017-18 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 53 Chaparral 50 | 2018-19 | H |
| Chaparral 55 Santa Teresa 52 | 2018-19 | T |
| Chaparral 42 Santa Teresa 40 | 2018-19 | DT-H |
| Chaparral 69 Santa Teresa 67 | 2019-20 | T |
| Santa Teresa 70 Chaparral 51 | 2019-20 | H |
| Chaparral 73 Santa Teresa 71 | 2019-20 | TB-Anthony |
| Santa Teresa 72 Chaparral 44 | 2019-20 | DT-T |
| Chaparral 45 Santa Teresa 38 | 2020-21 | H |
| Chaparral 62 Santa Teresa 41 | 2020-21 | T |
| Santa Teresa 70 Chaparral 44 | 2021-22 | T |
| Santa Teresa 48 Chaparral 40 | 2021-22 | H |
| Santa Teresa 56 Chaparral 36 | 2021-22 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 53 Chaparral 30 | 2022-23 | H |
| Santa Teresa 59 Chaparral 49 | 2022-23 | T |
| Santa Teresa 52 Chaparral 45 | 2022-23 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 59 Chaparral 43 | 2023-24 | T |
| Santa Teresa 64 Chaparral 48 | 2023-24 | H |
| Chaparral 50 Santa Teresa 33 | 2023-24 | DT-H |
| Chihuahua Prep (MX) | 0-2 | |
| Prep 70 Santa Teresa 57 | 1994-95 | Deming |
| Prep 85 Santa Teresa 75 | 1995-96 | Deming |
| Ciudad Juarez Academia (MX) | 2-2 | |
| Academia 61 Santa Teresa 50 | 2003-04 | Silver City |
| Santa Teresa 45 Academia 42 | 2003-04 | H |
| Santa Teresa 65 Academia 62 | 2004-05 | H |
| Academia 47 Santa Teresa 45 | 2004-05 | Lordsburg |
| Ciudad Juarez Casa Grandes (MX) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 72 Casa Grandes 56 | 1995-96 | Deming |
| Clint (TX) | 13-9 | |
| Clint 65 Santa Teresa 46 | 1994-95 | H |
| Santa Teresa 62 Clint 48 | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Teresa 70 Clint 68 | 1995-96 | |
| Clint 57 Santa Teresa 46 | 1996-97 | H |
| Clint 64 Santa Teresa 53 | 1996-97 | T |
| Clint 86 Santa Teresa 79 | 1998-99 | H |
| Clint 67 Santa Teresa 44 | 99-2000 | T |
| Clint 59 Santa Teresa 35 | 2000-01 | H |
| Clint 66 Santa Teresa 46 | 2002-03 | H |
| Clint 59 Santa Teresa 48 | 2006-07 | T |
| Santa Teresa 47 Clint 45 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 72 Clint 45 | 2007-08 | H |
| Santa Teresa 62 Clint 48 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 51 Clint 28 | 2009-10 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 56 Clint 34 | 2009-10 | T |
| Santa Teresa 54 Clint 34 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 58 Clint 18 | 2011-12 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 61 Clint 26 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 61 Clint 39 | 2012-13 | H |
| Santa Teresa 34 Clint 26 | 2013-14 | T |
| Santa Teresa 62 Clint 42 | 2021-22 | H |
| Clint 52 Santa Teresa 39 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| Cloudcroft | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 69 Cloudcroft 28 | 2008-09 | Alamogordo |
| Cobach (MX) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 85 Cobach 73 | 1996-97 | Ruidoso |
| Deming | 18-34 | |
| Deming 61 Santa Teresa 54 | 2002-03 | H |
| Deming 58 Santa Teresa 51 | 2002-03 | T |
| Deming 55 Santa Teresa 51 | 2002-03 | DT-T |
| Deming 81 Santa Teresa 40 | 2003-04 | T |
| Deming 89 Santa Teresa 54 | 2003-04 | H |
| Deming 88 Santa Teresa 41 | 2004-05 | T |
| Deming 90 Santa Teresa 48 | 2004-05 | T |
| Santa Teresa 41 Deming 39 | 2005-06 | T |
| Deming 46 Santa Teresa 43 | 2005-06 | H |
| Deming defeated Santa Teresa | 2005-06 | DT-T |
| Deming 75 Santa Teresa 39 | 2006-07 | H |
| Santa Teresa 42 Deming 33 | 2006-07 | T |
| Santa Teresa 61 Deming 58 | 2006-07 | DT-H |
| Deming 70 Santa Teresa 57 | 2007-08 | T |
| Santa Teresa 62 Deming 59 | 2007-08 | H |
| Santa Teresa 65 Deming 45 | 2007-08 | TB- |
| Deming 42 Santa Teresa 40 | 2007-08 | DT-H |
| Deming 55 Santa Teresa 46 | 2008-09 | H |
| Deming 56 Santa Teresa 38 | 2008-09 | T |
| Santa Teresa 60 Deming 24 | 2009-10 | T |
| Santa Teresa 66 Deming 40 | 2009-10 | H |
| Santa Teresa 69 Deming 39 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 78 Deming 49 | 2010-11 | T |
| Santa Teresa 77 Deming 38 | 2010-11 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 37 Deming 31 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 62 Deming 56 | 2011-12 | H |
| Santa Teresa 52 Deming 34 | 2011-12 | DT-H |
| Deming 58 Santa Teresa 57 | 2012-13 | H |
| Santa Teresa 67 Deming 46 | 2012-13 | T |
| Deming 45 Santa Teresa 45 | 2012-13 | DT-H |
| Santa Teresa 53 Deming 52 | 2013-14 | T |
| Santa Teresa 59 Deming 45 | 2013-14 | H |
| Deming 40 Santa Teresa 30 | 2013-14 | DT-H |
| Deming 52 Santa Teresa 51 | 2014-15 | H |
| Deming 52 Santa teresa 44 | 2014-15 | T |
| Deming 69 Santa Teresa 43 | 2015-16 | T |
| Deming 67 Santa Teresa 53 | 2015-16 | H |
| Deming 63 Santa Teresa 50 | 2016-17 | H |
| Deming 84 Santa Teresa 57 | 2016-17 | T |
| Deming 58 Santa Teresa 55 | 2016-17 | DT-T |
| Deming 63 Santa Teresa 62 | 2017-18 | T |
| Deming 59 Santa Teresa 57 | 2017-18 | H |
| Deming 58 Santa Teresa 54 | 2017-18 | DT-T |
| Deming 64 Santa Teresa 40 | 2018-19 | T |
| Deming 78 Santa Teresa 50 | 2019-20 | H |
| Deming 69 Santa Teresa 61 | 2019-20 | Las Cruces |
| Deming 55 Santa Teresa 53 | 2021-22 | H |
| Deming 73 Santa Teresa 48 | 2022-23 | H |
| Deming 45 Santa Teresa 29 | 2022-23 | T |
| Deming 67 Santa Teresa 53 | 2022-23 | DT-T |
| Santa Teresa 60 Deming 43 | 2023-24 | T |
| Santa Teresa 58 Deming 41 | 2023-24 | H |
| Denver Cherry Creek (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Cherry Creek 77 Santa Teresa 26 | 2005-06 | Denver |
| Denver Montebello (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Montebello 86 Santa Teresa 43 | 2005-06 | Denver |
| Denver Regis Jesuit (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Regis Jesuit 69 Santa Teresa 47 | 2005-06 | Denver |
| El Paso (TX) | 3-4 | |
| El Paso defeated Santa Teresa | 1997-98 | El Paso |
| El Paso 72 Santa Teresa 45 | 2001-02 | Clint |
| El Paso 53 Santa Teresa 22 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 44 El Paso 35 | 2008-09 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 49 El Paso 34 | 2012-13 | H |
| Santa Teresa 33 El Paso 30 | 2013-14 | T |
| El Paso 56 Santa Teresa 42 | 2013-14 | El Paso |
| El Paso Americas (TX) | 0-2 | |
| Americas 49 Santa Teresa 38 | 2006-07 | H |
| Americas 66 Santa Teresa 24 | 2007-08 | T |
| El Paso Austin (TX) | 2-1 | |
| Santa Teresa 59 Austin 54 | 2005-06 | Canutillo |
| Austin 63 Santa Teresa 54 | 2017-18 | Fabens |
| Santa Teresa 56 Austin 45 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| El Paso Bel Air (TX) | 1-5 | |
| Bel Air 70 Santa Teresa 40 | 2005-06 | H |
| Bel Air 50 Santa Teresa 44 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Bel Air 58 Santa Teresa 55 | 2006-07 | H |
| Bel Air 51 Santa Teresa 45 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Bel Air 37 Santa Teresa 33 | 2007-08 | |
| Santa Teresa 49 Bel Air 46 | 2010-11 | El Paso |
| El Paso Bowie (TX) | 0-3 | |
| Bowie 76 Santa Teresa 64 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Bowie 56 Santa Teresa 41 | 2000-01 | Clint |
| Bowie 56 Santa Teresa 34 | 2014-15 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Burges (TX) | 1-2 | |
| Burges 68 Santa Teresa 22 | 2005-06 | T |
| Santa Teresa 64 Burges 54 | 2007-08 | Alamogordo |
| Santa Teresa 74 Burges 47 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| El Paso Cathedral (TX) | 8-27 | |
| Cathedral 85 Santa Teresa 73 | 1994-95 | H |
| Santa Teresa 74 Cathedral 67 | 1994-95 | T |
| Cathedral 108 Santa Teresa 59 | 1995-96 | |
| Cathedral 99 Santa Teresa 73 | 1996-97 | T |
| Cathedral 88 Santa Teresa 84 | 1997-98 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 81 Cathedral 64 | 1997-98 | T |
| Cathedral 73 Santa Teresa 67 | 1997-98 | H |
| Cathedral 87 Santa Teresa 73 | 1998-99 | T |
| Cathedral 85 Santa Teresa 63 | 99-2000 | T |
| Cathedral 68 Santa Teresa 50 | 99-2000 | H |
| Cathedral 88 Santa Teresa 48 | 2000-01 | H |
| Cathedral 65 Santa Teresa 41 | 2001-02 | T |
| Cathedral 77 Santa Teresa 50 | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| Cathedral 59 Santa Teresa 44 | 2002-03 | T |
| Cathedral 86 Santa Teresa 43 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| Cathedral 77 Santa Teresa 55 | 2004-05 | H |
| Cathedral 94 Santa Teresa 64 | 2004-05 | T |
| Cathedral 78 Santa Teresa 64 | 2005-06 | T |
| Santa Teresa 57 Cathedral 51 | 2005-06 | H |
| Cathedral 89 Santa Teresa 62 | 2006-07 | H |
| Cathedral 53 Santa Teresa 48 | 2006-07 | H |
| Santa Teresa 58 Cathedral 48 | 2007-08 | H |
| Cathedral 44 Santa Teresa 37 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 46 Cathedral 33 | 2009-10 | |
| Santa Teresa 56 Cathedral 42 | 2009-10 | |
| Santa Teresa 55 Cathedral 41 | 2010-11 | H |
| Cathedral 46 Santa Teresa 20 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 55 Cathedral 41 | 2011-12 | T |
| Cathedral 48 Santa Teresa 25 | 2015-16 | Clint |
| Cathedral 50 Santa Teresa 40 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cathedral 63 Santa Teresa 38 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Cathedral 99 Santa Teresa 41 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cathedral 60 Santa Teresa 28 | 2021-22 | T |
| Cathedral 51 Santa Teresa 32 | 2022-23 | T |
| Cathedral 46 Santa Teresa 42 | 2023-24 | H |
| El Paso DaVinci (TX) | 0-4 | |
| DaVinci 64 Santa Teresa 54 | 2022-23 | H |
| DaVinci 80 Santa Teresa 43 | 2022-23 | T |
| DaVinci 68 Santa Teresa 38 | 2023-24 | T |
| DaVinci 74 Santa Teresa 66 | 2023-24 | H |
| El Paso Del Valle (TX) | 0-3 | |
| Del Valle 64 Santa Teresa 46 | 1997-98 | El Paso |
| Del Valle 74 Santa Teresa 43 | 2003-04 | T |
| Del Valle 53 Santa Teresa 37 | 2015-16 | Clint |
| El Paso Eastlake (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Eastlake 65 Santa Teresa 41 | 2013-14 | El Paso |
| El Paso Eastwood (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Eastwood 63 Santa Teresa 30 | 2003-04 | Silver City |
| El Paso El Dorado (TX) | 2-1 | |
| Santa Teresa 73 El Dorado 54 | 2005-06 | Alamogordo |
| Santa Teresa 56 El Dorado 54 | 2006-07 | H |
| El Dorado 63 Santa Teresa 39 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| El Paso Evangel Christian (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 68 Evangel Christian 32 | 2004-05 | Lordsburg |
| El Paso Faith Christian (TX) | 3-1 | |
| Santa Teresa 69 Faith Christian 50 | 99-2000 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 50 Faith Christian 32 | 2008-09 | T |
| Santa Teresa 62 Faith Christian 27 | 2009-10 | H |
| Faith Christian 69 Santa Teresa 42 | 2011-12 | Canutillo |
| El Paso Franklin (TX) | 1-1 | |
| Santa Teresa 72 Franklin 66 | 1995-96 | H |
| Franklin 57 Santa Teresa 26 | 2006-07 | H |
| El Paso Hanks (TX) | 0-2 | |
| Hanks 52 Santa Teresa 47 | 2005-06 | H |
| Hanks 82 Santa Teresa 26 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| El Paso Harmony Science Academy (TX) | 2-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 84 Harmony 33 | 2019-20 | T |
| Santa Teresa 75 Harmony 20 | 2023-24 | Las Cruces |
| El Paso Horizon (TX) | 2-2 | |
| Horizon 58 Santa Teresa 47 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| Horizon 45 Santa Teresa 44 | 2009-10 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 53 Horizon 37 | 2009-10 | Santa Teresa |
| Santa Teresa 65 Horizon 34 | 2012-13 | El Paso |
| El Paso Immanuel Christian (TX) | 2-2 | |
| Santa Teresa 55 Immanuel 41 | 2002-03 | H |
| Immanuel 62 Santa Teresa 55 | 2003-04 | H |
| Santa Teresa 50 Immanuel 33 | 2004-05 | T |
| Immanuel 59 Santa Teresa 53 | 2022-23 | Anthony |
| El Paso Irvin (TX) | 0-2 | |
| Irvin 40 Santa Teresa 31 | 2000-01 | T |
| Irvin 45 Santa Teresa 22 | 2015-26 | Clint |
| El Paso Jefferson (TX) | 2-5 | |
| Jefferson 52 Santa Teresa 46 | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Teresa 68 Jefferson 64 | 1995-96 | H |
| Jefferson 53 Santa Teresa 42 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Jefferson 51 Santa Teresa 33 | 2004-05 | Alamogordo |
| Santa Teresa 53 Jefferson 44 | 2010-11 | H |
| Jefferson 59 Santa Teresa 50 | 2011-12 | H |
| Jefferson 71 Santa Teresa 46 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| El Paso Jesus Chapel (TX) | 3-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 68 Jesus Chapel 19 | 2003-04 | T |
| Santa Teresa 53 Jesus Chapel 32 | 2003-04 | H |
| Santa Teresa 47 Jesus Chapel 40 | 2004-05 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Montwood (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Montwood 63 Santa Teresa 36 | 2006-07 | H |
| El Paso Mountainview (TX) | 8-5 | |
| Mountainview 75 Santa Teresa 63 | 1998-99 | T |
| Mountainview 56 Santa Teresa 54 | 1998-99 | H |
| Mountainview 51 Santa Teresa 39 | 99-2000 | El Paso |
| Mountainview 67 Santa Teresa 38 | 99-2000 | T |
| Mountainview 40 Santa Teresa 26 | 2000-01 | H |
| Santa Teresa 45 Mountainview 40 | 2001-02 | Clint |
| Santa Teresa 55 Mountainview 54 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 48 Mountainview 33 | 2009-10 | Santa Teresa |
| Santa Teresa 54 Mountainview 31 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 54 Mountainview 40 | 2011-12 | H |
| Santa Teresa 52 Mountainview 26 | 2012-13 | T |
| Santa Teresa 40 Mountainview 34 | 2013-14 | T |
| Santa Teresa 64 Mountainview 55 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| El Paso Parkland (TX) | 0-3 | |
| Parkland 59 Santa Teresa 48 | 2006-07 | T |
| Parkland 72 Santa Teresa 45 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Parkland 67 Santa Teresa 22 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| El Paso Lydia Patterson (TX) | 4-1 | |
| Santa Teresa 48 Patterson 47 | 2007-08 | T |
| Patterson 63 Santa Teresa 46 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 66 Patterson 28 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 57 Patterson 47 | 2008-09 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 60 Patterson 18 | 2009-10 | Canutillo |
| El Paso Pebble Hills (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Pebble Hills 90 Santa Teresa 37 | 2017-18 | Fabens |
| El Paso Riverside (TX) | 2-2 | |
| Riverside 97 Santa Teresa 65 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Santa Teresa 56 Riverside 42 | 2005-06 | T |
| Santa Teresa 50 Riverside 44 | 2009-10 | Santa Teresa |
| Riverside 44 Santa Teresa 42 | 2012-13 | El Paso |
| El Paso Socorro (TX) | 0-2 | |
| Santa Teresa 53 Socorro 42 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 60 Socorro 47 | 2009-10 | H |
| Socorro 45 Santa Teresa 42 | 2010-11 | El Paso |
| Socorro 41 Santa Teresa 14 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| El Paso Ysleta (TX) | 0-3 | |
| Ysleta 80 Santa Teresa 30 | 2003-04 | Silver City |
| Ysleta 75 Santa Teresa 59 | 2007-08 | T |
| Ysleta 39 Santa Teresa 34 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Espanola | 0-4 | |
| Espanola 58 Santa Teresa 48 | 2008-09 | S-T |
| Espanola 53 Santa Teresa 42 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Espanola 57 Santa Teresa 40 | 2014-15 | Santa Fe |
| Esapnola 77 Santa Teresa 64 | 2015-16 | Santa Fe |
| Espanola McCurdy | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 49 McCurdy 35 | 2007-08 | Taos |
| Fabens (TX) | 3-2 | |
| Santa Teresa 71 Fabens 56 | 1994-95 | Deming |
| Santa Teresa 86 Fabens 65 | 1995-96 | Deming |
| Fabens 80 Santa Teresa 54 | 2006-07 | H |
| Fabens 49 Santa Teresa 39 | 2007-08 | |
| Santa Teresa 52 Fabens 36 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| Fort Hancock (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 97 Fort Hancock 66 | 1996-97 | T |
| Fort Wingate | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 63 Fort Wingate 59 | 1998-99 | Grants |
| Gallup | 2-2 | |
| Gallup 75 Santa Teresa 67 | 2005-06 | Alamogordo |
| Gallup 63 Santa Teresa 39 | 2007-08 | Alamogordo |
| Santa Teresa 58 Gallup 43 | 2011-12 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Santa Teresa 57 Gallup 53 | 2012-13 | S-H |
| Gallup Miyamura | 0-1 | |
| Miyamura 64 Santa Teresa 48 | 2016-17 | Los Lunas |
| Grants | 0-1 | |
| Grants 55 Santa Teresa 54 | 1998-99 | |
| Hatch | 16-1 | |
| Hatch 72 Santa Teresa 50 | 2000-01 | H |
| Santa Teresa 84 Hatch 70 | 2000-01 | T |
| Santa Teresa 41 Hatch 38 | 2001-02 | H |
| Santa Teresa 55 Hatch 43 | 2001-02 | H |
| Santa Teresa 79 Hatch 44 | 2002-03 | H |
| Santa Teresa defeated Hatch | 2002-03 | T |
| Santa Teresa 60 Hatch 53 | 2007-08 | T |
| Santa Teresa 59 Hatch 34 | 2007-08 | H |
| Santa Teresa 66 Hatch 39 | 2008-09 | T |
| Santa Teresa 71 Hatch 34 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 59 Hatch 38 | 2018-19 | T |
| Santa Teresa 76 Hatch 64 | 2019-20 | H |
| Santa Teresa 53 Hatch 44 | 2020-21 | T |
| Santa Teresa 47 Hatch 44 | 2020-21 | H |
| Santa Teresa 82 Hatch 22 | 2021-22 | H |
| Santa Teresa 53 Hatch 39 | 2022-23 | T |
| Santa Teresa 64 Hatch 19 | 2023-24 | T |
| Hobbs | 0-1 | |
| Hobbs 93 Santa Teresa 58 | 2016-17 | Santa Fe |
| Jemez Valley | 2-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 58 Jemez Valley 28 | 2014-15 | Santa Fe |
| Santa Teresa 69 Jemez Valley 19 | 2015-16 | Santa Fe |
| Las Cruces | 1-12 | |
| Las Cruces 102 Santa Teresa 55 | 99-2000 | T |
| Las Cruces 59 Santa Teresa 49 | 2007-08 | H |
| Las Cruces 64 Santa Teresa 50 | 2008-09 | T |
| Santa Teresa 38 Las Cruces 36 | 2009-10 | H |
| Las Cruces 61 Santa Teresa 38 | 2010-11 | T |
| Las Cruces 55 Santa Teresa 35 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Las Cruces 65 Santa Teresa 32 | 2011-12 | H |
| Las Cruces 67 Santa Teresa 66 | 2012-13 | H |
| Las Cruces 71 Santa Teresa 42 | 2012-13 | Rio Rancho |
| Las Cruces 79 Santa Teresa 44 | 2013-14 | T |
| Las Cruces 56 Santa Teresa 42 | 2014-15 | H |
| Las Cruces 86 Santa Teresa 56 | 2015-16 | T |
| Las Cruces 95 Santa Teresa 37 | 2018-19 | H |
| Las Cruces Centennial | 3-10 | |
| Santa Teresa 48 Centennial 24 | 2012-13 | T |
| Santa Teresa 56 Centennial 31 | 2012-13 | H |
| Centennial 47 Santa Teresa 39 | 2013-14 | H |
| Centennial 50 Santa Teresa 27 | 2013-14 | T |
| Centennial 76 Santa Teresa 44 | 2014-15 | T |
| Centennial 65 Santa Teresa 46 | 2014-15 | H |
| Centennial 72 Santa Teresa 50 | 2014-15 | DT-T |
| Centennial 79 Santa Teresa 55 | 2015-16 | H |
| Centennial 87 Santa Teresa 56 | 2015-16 | T |
| Santa Teresa 84 Centennial 74 | 2016-17 | Los Lunas |
| Centennial 89 Santa Teresa 51 | 2019-20 | H |
| Centennial 64 Santa Teresa 26 | 2019-20 | Las Cruces |
| Centennial 70 Santa Teresa 46 | 2021-22 | Las Cruces |
| Las Cruces Mayfield | 1-7 | |
| Mayfield 68 Santa Teresa 42 | 2006-07 | T |
| Mayfield 60 Santa Teresa 47 | 2009-10 | H |
| Mayfield 42 Santa Teresa 40 | 2010-11 | El Paso |
| Mayfield 67 Santa Teresa 59 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Santa Teresa 48 Mayfield 43 | 2016-17 | H |
| Mayfield 64 Santa Teresa 22 | 2017-18 | T |
| Mayfield 66 Santa Teresa 50 | 2022-23 | Las Cruces |
| Mayfield 64 Santa Teresa 48 | 2023-24 | Las Cruces |
| Las Cruces Onate | 0-13 | |
| Onate 87 Santa Teresa 48 | 1998-99 | T |
| Onate 93 Santa Teresa 51 | 99-2000 | H |
| Onate 62 Santa Teresa 47 | 2002-03 | T |
| Onate 72 Santa Teresa 35 | 2002-03 | H |
| Onate 77 Santa Teresa 35 | 2003-04 | T |
| Onate 73 Santa Teresa 31 | 2003-04 | H |
| Onate 67 Santa Teresa 65 | 2004-05 | H |
| Onate 63 Santa Teresa 49 | 2004-05 | T |
| Onate 77 Santa Teresa 63 | 2005-06 | H |
| Onate 53 Santa Teresa 50 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Onate 44 Santa Teresa 37 | 2013-14 | Rio Rancho |
| Onate 56 Santa Teresa 40 | 2016-17 | H |
| Onate 84 Santa Teresa 34 | 2017-18 | T |
| Las Vegas Robertson | 0-2 | |
| Robertson 51 Santa Teresa 49 | 2003-04 | Socorro |
| Robertson 52 Santa Teresa 50 | 2004-05 | Socorro |
| West Las Vegas | 0-1 | |
| West 62 Santa Teresa 36 | 2002-03 | Socorro |
| Littleton (CO) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 48 Littleton 40 | 2005-06 | Denver |
| Los Lunas | 4-4 | |
| Santa Teresa 61 Los Lunas 44 | 2011-12 | S-H |
| Santa Teresa 59 Los Lunas 51 | 2012-13 | T |
| Los Lunas 44 Santa Teresa 29 | 2013-14 | H |
| Santa Teresa 29 Los Lunas 27 | 2014-15 | Alamogordo |
| Los Lunas 33 Santa Teresa 26 | 2014-15 | T |
| Santa Teresa 33 Los Lunas 31 | 2014-15 | H |
| Los Lunas 57 Santa Teresa 30 | 2015-16 | H |
| Los Lunas 40 Santa Teresa 27 | 2015-16 | T |
| Los Lunas Valencia | 5-6 | |
| Santa Teresa 62 Valencia 53 | 2014-15 | T |
| Santa Teresa 49 Valencia 36 | 2014-15 | H |
| Santa Teresa 56 Valencia 37 | 2014-15 | DT-T |
| Santa Teresa 70 Valencia 69 | 2015-16 | H |
| Valencia 72 Santa Teresa 61 | 2015-16 | T |
| Valencia 67 Santa Teresa 52 | 2015-16 | DT-T |
| Valencia 64 Santa Teresa 45 | 2016-17 | Los Lunas |
| Valencia 71 Santa Teresa 42 | 2017-18 | Los Lunas |
| Santa Teresa 63 Valencia 60 | 2021-22 | Las Cruces |
| Valencia 65 Santa Teresa 44 | 2022-23 | Las Cruces |
| Valencia 68 Santa Teresa 52 | 2023-24 | Las Cruces |
| Lovington | 1-10 | |
| Lovington 73 Santa Teresa 64 | 1996-97 | Ruidoso |
| Lovington 104 Santa teresa 71 | 2000-01 | H |
| Lovington 103 Santa Teresa 66 | 2000-01 | T |
| Lovington 91 Santa Teresa 67 | 2000-01 | DT-T |
| Lovington 44 Santa Teresa 37 | 2001-02 | Silver City |
| Lovington 81 Santa Teresa 71 | 2001-02 | T |
| Lovington defeated Santa Teresa | 2001-02 | H |
| Lovington 51 Santa Teresa 46 | 2018-19 | T |
| Santa Teresa 80 Lovington 76 | 2019-20 | H |
| Lovington 90 Santa Teresa 38 | 2021-22 | T |
| Lovington 75 Santa Teresa 49 | 2022-23 | T |
| Mescalero | 1-1 | |
| Mescalero 51 Santa Teresa 40 | 2021-22 | H |
| Santa Teresa 64 Mescalero 39 | 2022-23 | T |
| Moriarty | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 70 Moriarty 44 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Penasco | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 91 Penasco 61 | 1997-98 | Taos |
| Portales | 1-5 | |
| Portales 71 Santa Teresa 47 | 2000-01 | H |
| Portales 64 Santa Teresa 36 | 2000-01 | T |
| Portales 39 Santa Teresa 26 | 2001-02 | T |
| Santa Teresa 65 Portales 61 | 2001-02 | T |
| Portales 37 Santa Teresa 36 | 2008-09 | T |
| Portales 41 Santa Teresa 34 | 2009-10 | H |
| Presidio (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 73 Presidio 39 | 2005-06 | Canutillo |
| Questa | 2-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 78 Questa 76 | 1996-97 | Taos |
| Santa Teresa 61 Questa 45 | 2004-05 | Socorro |
| Rio Rancho | 1-3 | |
| Rio Rancho 60 Santa Teresa 56 | 2009-10 | H |
| Santa Teresa 55 Rio Rancho 31 | 2010-11 | T |
| Rio Rancho 59 Santa Teresa 54 | 2011-12 | H |
| Rio Rancho 72 Santa Teresa 52 | 2013-14 | Rio Rancho |
| Rio Rancho Cleveland | 2-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 58 Cleveland 45 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Santa Teresa 58 Cleveland 45 | 2012-13 | Rio Rancho |
| Roswell | 3-11 | |
| Roswell 59 Santa Teresa 47 | 2007-08 | Taos |
| Santa Teresa 53 Roswell 48 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 70 Roswell 50 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 65 Roswell 48 | 2011-12 | S-Albuquerque |
| Roswell 48 Santa Teresa 39 | 2012-13 | H |
| Roswell 64 Santa Teresa 38 | 2013-14 | T |
| Roswell 63 Santa Teresa 28 | 2014-15 | H |
| Roswell 78 Santa Teresa 36 | 2015-16 | T |
| Roswell 62 Santa Teresa 35 | 2016-17 | H |
| Roswell 67 Santa Teresa 32 | 2016-17 | T |
| Roswell 91 Santa Teresa 37 | 2017-18 | T |
| Roswell 73 Santa Teresa 49 | 2017-18 | H |
| Roswell 89 Santa Teresa 34 | 2018-19 | T |
| Roswell 75 Santa Teresa 44 | 2019-20 | H |
| Roswell Goddard | 3-12 | |
| Goddard 65 Santa Teresa 62 | 2007-08 | Taos |
| Santa Teresa 51 Goddard 48 | 2010-11 | H |
| Goddard 72 Santa Teresa 43 | 2011-12 | T |
| Santa Teresa 48 Goddard 47 | 2012-13 | H |
| Goddard 51 Santa Teresa 32 | 2013-14 | T |
| Goddard 55 Santa Teresa 41 | 2014-15 | H |
| Goddard 60 Santa Teresa 40 | 2015-16 | Santa Fe |
| Goddard 74 Santa Teresa 64 | 2015-16 | T |
| Goddard 72 Santa Teresa 54 | 2016-17 | H |
| Goddard 73 Santa Teresa 34 | 2017-18 | T |
| Goddard 62 Santa Teresa 49 | 2018-19 | H |
| Goddard 82 Santa Teresa 45 | 2019-20 | T |
| Goddard 78 Santa Teresa 60 | 2021-22 | T |
| Goddard 55 Santa Teresa 42 | 2022-23 | H |
| Santa Teresa 48 Goddard 39 | 2023-24 | T |
| Roswell NMMI | 0-3 | |
| NMMI defeated Santa Teresa | 2000-01 | T |
| NMMI 76 Santa Teresa 47 | 2000-01 | H |
| NMMI 53 Santa Teresa 34 | 2001-02 | H |
| Ruidoso | 12-19 | |
| Ruidoso 86 Santa Teresa 67 | 1994-95 | H |
| Ruidoso defeated Santa Teresa | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Teresa 70 Ruidoso 67 | 1995-96 | T |
| Ruidoso defeated Santa Teresa | 1995-96 | H |
| Santa Teresa defeated Ruidoso | 1996-97 | Ruidoso |
| Ruidoso 89 Santa Teresa 63 | 1996-97 | H |
| Ruidoso 73 Santa Teresa 59 | 1996-97 | T |
| Santa Teresa 60 Ruidoso 52 | 1997-98 | Ruidoso |
| Ruidoso 57 Santa Teresa 45 | 1997-98 | |
| Santa Teresa defeated Ruidoso | 1997-98 | |
| Santa Teresa 63 Ruidoso 54 | 1997-98 | DT-T |
| Ruidoso 77 Santa Teresa 70 | 1998-99 | T |
| Ruidoso 88 Santa Teresa 71 | 1998-99 | H |
| Ruidoso 76 Santa Teresa 66 | 1998-99 | DT-T |
| Ruidoso 81 Santa Teresa 46 | 99-2000 | H |
| Ruidoso 62 Santa Teresa 37 | 99-2000 | T |
| Ruidoso 76 Santa Teresa 64 | 2000-01 | T |
| Ruidoso 76 Santa Teresa 47 | 2000-01 | H |
| Santa Teresa 57 Ruidoso 48 | 2001-02 | T |
| Santa Teresa defeated Ruidoso | 2001-02 | H |
| Ruidoso 52 Santa Teresa 43 | 2001-02 | DT-T |
| Santa Teresa 63 Ruidoso 47 | 2006-07 | Alamogordo |
| Ruidoso 90 Santa Teresa 85 | 2018-19 | T |
| Santa Teresa 63 Ruidoso 54 | 2018-19 | H |
| Santa Teresa 70 Ruidoso 59 | 2019-20 | H |
| Santa Teresa 58 Ruidoso 51 | 2019-20 | T |
| Santa Teresa 73 Ruidoso 60 | 2020-21 | H |
| Ruidoso 85 Santa Teresa 66 | 2020-21 | T |
| Ruidoso 70 Santa Teresa 60 | 2021-22 | H |
| Ruidoso 69 Santa Teresa 38 | 2021-22 | T |
| Ruidoso 60 Santa Teresa 52 | 2021-22 | DT-T |
| San Elizario (TX) | 2-3 | |
| Santa Teresa 44 San Elizario 40 | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Teresa 79 San Elizario 68 | 1994-95 | H |
| San Elizario 35 Santa Teresa 27 | 2013-14 | El Paso |
| San Elizario 52 Santa Teresa 34 | 2022-23 | T |
| San Elizario 49 Santa Teresa 39 | 2022-23 | Anthony |
| Santa Fe | 1-2 | |
| Santa Teresa 73 Santa Fe 37 | 2010-11 | S-H |
| Santa Fe 43 Santa Teresa 42 | 2014-15 | Santa Fe |
| Santa Fe 64 Santa Teresa 40 | 2016-17 | Santa Fe |
| Santa Fe Capital | 0-2 | |
| Capital 66 Santa Teresa 46 | 2007-08 | S-T |
| Capital 52 Santa Teresa 41 | 2009-10 | S-H |
| Santa Fe Desert Academy | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 66 Desert Academy 55 | 2016-17 | Santa Fe |
| Show Low (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 71 Show Low 67 | 1998-99 | Grants |
| Sierra Vista Buena (AZ) | 0-1 | |
| Buena 63 Santa Teresa 42 | 2004-05 | Alamogordo |
| Silver City | 16-40 | |
| Silver City 79 Santa Teresa 49 | 1994-95 | Deming |
| Silver City 86 Santa Teresa 65 | 1994-95 | H |
| Silver City 83 Santa Teresa 65 | 1994-95 | T |
| Silver City 93 Santa Teresa 66 | 1995-96 | T |
| Silver City 85 Santa Teresa 60 | 1995-96 | H |
| Silver City 77 Santa Teresa 60 | 1996-97 | H |
| Silver City 89 Santa Teresa 61 | 1996-97 | T |
| Silver City 78 Santa Teresa 50 | 1997-98 | T |
| Santa Teresa 62 Silver City 51 | 1997-98 | H |
| Silver City 77 Santa Teresa 71 | 1998-99 | T |
| Silver City 86 Santa Teresa 72 | 1998-99 | H |
| Silver City 80 Santa Teresa 63 | 99-2000 | H |
| Silver City 86 Santa Teresa 59 | 99-2000 | T |
| Silver City 61 Santa Teresa 36 | 2001-02 | Silver City |
| Silver City defeated Santa Teresa | 2002-03 | H |
| Silver City 48 Santa Teresa 43 | 2002-03 | T |
| Silver City 69 Santa Teresa 48 | 2003-04 | H |
| Silver City 65 Santa Teresa 38 | 2003-04 | T |
| Silver City 83 Santa Teresa 57 | 2004-05 | T |
| Silver City 83 Santa Teresa 57 | 2004-05 | H |
| Silver City 60 Santa Teresa 38 | 2005-06 | H |
| Silver City 67 Santa Teresa 45 | 2005-06 | T |
| Santa Teresa 68 Silver City 56 | 2006-07 | T |
| Santa Teresa 51 Silver City 46 | 2006-07 | H |
| Santa Teresa 61 Silver City 36 | 2007-08 | H |
| Santa Teresa 50 Silver City 40 | 2007-08 | T |
| Silver City 42 Santa Teresa 35 | 2008-09 | T |
| Santa Teresa 45 Silver City 36 | 2008-09 | H |
| Silver City 47 Santa Teresa 34 | 2008-09 | DT-T |
| Santa Teresa 47 Silver City 30 | 2009-10 | H |
| Santa Teresa 66 Silver City 32 | 2009-10 | T |
| Santa Teresa 68 Silver City 28 | 2010-11 | H |
| Santa Teresa 52 Silver City 38 | 2011-12 | H |
| Silver City 29 Santa Teresa 27 | 2012-13 | T |
| Santa Teresa 27 Silver City 24 | 2013-14 | H |
| Silver City 44 Santa Teresa 31 | 2013-14 | T |
| Santa Teresa 38 Silver City 28 | 2014-15 | H |
| Santa Teresa 41 Silver City 33 | 2014-15 | T |
| Silver City 48 Santa Teresa 42 | 2015-16 | T |
| Silver City 69 Santa Teresa 49 | 2016-17 | T |
| Silver City 63 Santa Teresa 41 | 2016-17 | H |
| Silver City 68 Santa Teresa 37 | 2017-18 | H |
| Silver City 59 Santa Teresa 42 | 2017-18 | T |
| Silver City 73 Santa Teresa 51 | 2018-19 | T |
| Silver City 74 Santa Teresa 68 | 2018-19 | H |
| Santa Teresa 64 Silver City 56 | 2019-20 | H |
| Santa Teresa 72 Silver City 68 | 2019-20 | T |
| Santa Teresa 69 Silver City 65 | 2019-20 | DT-H |
| Silver City 54 Santa Teresa 49 | 2020-21 | H |
| Silver City 63 Santa Teresa 61 | 2020-21 | T |
| Silver City 66 Santa Teresa 33 | 2021-22 | H |
| Silver City 69 Santa Teresa 33 | 2021-22 | T |
| Silver City 63 Santa Teresa 36 | 2022-23 | T |
| Silver City 60 Santa Teresa 35 | 2022-23 | H |
| Silver City 43 Santa Teresa 34 | 2023-24 | H |
| Silver City 64 Santa Teresa 57 | 2023-24 | T |
| Socorro | 2-6 | |
| Socorro 73 Santa Teresa 58 | 1994-95 | |
| Socorro 85 Santa Teresa 72 | 1994-95 | |
| Socorro 71 Santa Teresa 63 | 1995-96 | T |
| Socorro 80 Santa Teresa 50 | 1995-96 | H |
| Socorro 68 Santa Teresa 50 | 1997-98 | Ruidoso |
| Santa Teresa 49 Socorro 45 | 2002-03 | Socorro |
| Santa Teresa 53 Socorro 44 | 2006-07 | T |
| Socorro 71 Santa Teresa 62 | 2007-08 | H |
| Taos | 0-1 | |
| Taos 72 Santa Teresa 65 | 1996-97 | Taos |
| Thoreau | 0-1 | |
| Thoreau 47 Santa Teresa 35 | 2003-04 | Socorro |
| Tornillo (TX) | 1-1 | |
| Santa Teresa 70 Tornillo 61 | 2000-01 | Clint |
| Tornillo 65 Santa Teresa 25 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| Truth or Consquences Hot Springs | 15-19 | |
| Hot Springs 82 Santa Teresa 63 | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Teresa 81 Hot Springs 66 | 1994-95 | H |
| Hot Springs 60 Santa Teresa 48 | 1994-95 | DT-T |
| Hot Springs 83 Santa Teresa 74 | 1995-96 | H |
| Santa Teresa 83 Hot Springs 80 | 1995-96 | T |
| Santa Teresa defeated Hot Springs | 1996-97 | Taos |
| Santa Teresa 64 Hot Springs 61 | 1996-97 | T |
| Hot Springs 61 Santa Teresa 59 | 1996-97 | H |
| Santa Teresa 62 Hot Springs 55 | 1997-98 | H |
| Hot Springs 66 Santa Teresa 57 | 1997-98 | T |
| Santa Teresa 48 Hot Springs 47 | 1997-98 | DT-H |
| Hot Springs 69 Santa Teresa 67 | 1998-99 | H |
| Hot Springs 88 Santa Teresa 79 | 1998-99 | T |
| Hot Springs 68 Santa Teresa 57 | 99-2000 | T |
| Hot Springs 74 Santa Teresa 63 | 99-2000 | H |
| Hot Springs 65 Santa Teresa 54 | 2000-01 | H |
| Hot Springs 55 Santa Teresa 51 | 2001-02 | H |
| Santa Teresa 49 Hot Springs 47 | 2002-03 | H |
| Santa Teresa 44 Hot Springs 30 | 2002-03 | T |
| Hot Springs 74 Santa Teresa 52 | 2003-04 | T |
| Hot Springs 49 Santa Teresa 47 | 2004-05 | H |
| Santa Teresa 41 Hot Springs 40 | 2005-06 | T |
| Santa Teresa 63 Hot Springs 60 | 2005-06 | H |
| Santa Teresa 55 Hot Springs 40 | 2006-07 | H |
| Santa Teresa 73 Hot Springs 53 | 2006-07 | T |
| Santa Teresa 59 Hot Springs 44 | 2008-09 | H |
| Santa Teresa 72 Hot Springs 62 | 2016-17 | T |
| Hot Springs 59 Santa Teresa 48 | 2017-18 | H |
| Hot Springs 56 Santa Teresa 45 | 2018-19 | T |
| Hot Springs 44 Santa Teresa 36 | 2019-20 | H |
| Hot Springs 67 Santa Teresa 42 | 2020-21 | H |
| Hot Springs 43 Santa Teresa 31 | 2021-22 | H |
| Hot Springs 54 Santa Teresa 47 | 2022-23 | T |
| Hot Springs 64 Santa Teresa 45 | 2023-24 | T |
| Tucson Desert Christian (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 64 Desert Christian 56 | 1997-98 | Ruidoso |
| Tucumcari | 0-1 | |
| Tucumcari 65 Santa Teresa 44 | 1997-98 | Taos |
| Victoria Memorial (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Memorial 80 Santa Teresa 45 | 2006-07 | Alamogordo |
| unknown | ||
| unknown win | 1994-95 | |
| unknown loss | 1994-95 | |
| unknown loss | 1994-95 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1995-96 | |
| unknown loss | 1995-96 | |
| unknown win | 1996-97 | |
| unknown win | 1997-98 | |
| unknown win | 1997-98 | |
| unknown loss | 1998-99 | |
| unknown loss | 1998-99 | |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | T |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | Clint |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | Clint |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | Clint |
| unknown win | 99-2000 | |
| unknown loss | 2000-01 | |
| unknown loss | 2000-01 | |
| unknown loss | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 2001-02 | |
| unknown loss | 2001-02 | Clint |
| unknown loss | 2001-02 | |
| unknown loss | 2002-03 | |
| unknown loss | 2002-03 | |
| unknown win | 2002-03 | |
| unknown loss | 2011-12 | |
| unknown opponent | 1-0 | |
| Santa Teresa 61 JV 27 | 2023-24 | H |