| Rio Rancho Cleveland record vs | rec/yr | location |
| Alamogordo | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 68 Alamogordo 53 | 2016-17 | T |
| Albuquerque | 4-0 | |
| Cleveland 81 Albuquerque 60 | 2014-15 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 103 Albuquerque 72 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 79 Albuquerque 60 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 63 Albuquerque 47 | 2021-22 | T |
| Albuquerque Atrisco Heritage | 12-12 | |
| Atrisco Heritage 73 Cleveland 66 | 2013-14 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 80 Atrisco Heritage 61 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 60 Atrisco Heritage 45 | 2014-15 | S-H |
| Atrisco Heritage 67 Cleveland 58 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Atrisco Heritage 53 Cleveland 49 | 2017-18 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 77 Atrisco Heritage 75 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| Atrisco Heritage 89 Cleveland 84 | 2018-19 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 63 Cleveland 61 | 2018-19 | T |
| Cleveland 65 Atrisco Heritage 52 | 2018-19 | DT-T |
| Atrisco Heritage 62 Cleveland 59 | 2018-19 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Atrisco Heritage 70 Cleveland 68 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 73 Atrisco Heritage 53 | 2019-20 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 62 Cleveland 49 | 2019-20 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 72 Atrisco Heritage 65 | 2020-21 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 59 Cleveland 57 | 2020-21 | T |
| Cleveland 58 Atrisco Heritage 51 | 2020-21 | S-H |
| Atrisco Heritage 64 Cleveland 49 | 2021-22 | T |
| Cleveland 54 Atrisco Heritage 43 | 2021-22 | H |
| Cleveland 80 Atrisco Heritage 62 | 2022-23 | H |
| Cleveland 50 Atrisco Heritage 48 | 2022-23 | T |
| Cleveland 78 Atrisco Heritage 62 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Atrisco Heritage 102 Cleveland 98 | 2023-24 | T |
| Cleveland 95 Atrisco Heritage 91 | 2023-24 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 99 Cleveland 71 | 2023-24 | DT-H |
| Albuquerque Cibola | 27-13 | |
| Cibola 79 Cleveland 54 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cibola 68 Cleveland 59 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cibola 56 Cleveland 53 | 2010-11 | H |
| Cibola 48 Cleveland 43 | 2010-11 | T |
| Cleveland 50 Cibola 46 | 2010-11 | DT-T |
| Cibola 70 Cleveland 53 | 2011-12 | T |
| Cibola 57 Cleveland 55 | 2011-12 | H |
| Cibola 71 Cleveland 54 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cibola 54 Cleveland 40 | 2012-13 | T |
| Cleveland 73 Cibola 61 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 71 Cibola 60 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cleveland 69 Cibola 63 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 60 Cibola 55 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 77 Cibola 58 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 66 Cibola 54 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| Cibola 74 Cleveland 71 | 2015-16 | H |
| Cleveland 66 Cibola 60 | 2015-16 | T |
| Cleveland 65 Cibola 52 | 2015-16 | TB-T |
| Cibola 67 Cleveland 60 | 2015-16 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 75 Cibola 62 | 2016-17 | T |
| Cleveland 85 Cibola 72 | 2016-17 | H |
| Cleveland 74 Cibola 59 | 2016-17 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 82 Cibola 49 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cleveland 68 Cibola 28 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cleveland 69 Cibola 20 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 65 Cibola 25 | 2018-19 | T |
| Cleveland 78 Cibola 39 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 86 Cibola 49 | 2018-19 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 68 Cibola 43 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Cibola 64 Cleveland 60 | 2019-20 | H |
| Cleveland 52 Cibola 35 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 81 Cibola 42 | 2020-21 | T |
| Cleveland 81 Cibola 51 | 2020-21 | H |
| Cibola 64 Cleveland 54 | 2021-22 | H |
| Cibola 65 Cleveland 55 | 2021-22 | T |
| Cleveland 64 Cibola 61 | 2021-22 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 70 Cibola 31 | 2022-23 | T |
| Cleveland 85 Cibola 53 | 2022-23 | H |
| Cleveland 93 Cibola 57 | 2023-24 | H |
| Cleveland 87 Cibola 66 | 2023-24 | T |
| Albuquerque Del Norte | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 74 Del Norte 47 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Eldorado | 5-2 | |
| Cleveland 77 Eldorado 62 | 2010-11 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 111 Eldorado 109 | 2016-17 | T |
| Eldorado 80 Cleveland 71 | 2017-18 | Hobbs |
| Eldorado 72 Cleveland 65 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 70 Eldorado 68 | 2017-18 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 56 Eldorado 51 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 60 Eldorado 50 | 2022-23 | S-H |
| Albuquerque Highland | 10-3 | |
| Cleveland 65 Highland 60 | 2010-11 | T |
| Highland 68 Cleveland 48 | 2011-12 | H |
| Cleveland 55 Highland 50 | 2012-13 | T |
| Highland 67 Cleveland 58 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 73 Cleveland 65 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cleveland 72 Highland 52 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 64 Highland 28 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 73 Highland 46 | 2015-16 | H |
| Cleveland 72 Highland 53 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 74 Highland 67 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 80 Highland 58 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 76 Highland 68 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 54 Highland 48 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Hope Christian | 4-1 | |
| Hope Christian 74 Cleveland 61 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 65 Hope Christian 53 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 90 Hope Christian 72 | 2020-21 | H |
| Cleveland 67 Hope Christian 61 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 81 Hope Christian 58 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque La Cueva | 13-5 | |
| La Cueva 59 Cleveland 56 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 64 La Cueva 62 | 2010-11 | H |
| La Cueva 67 Cleveland 51 | 2011-12 | T |
| La Cueva 91 Cleveland 73 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cleveland 66 La Cueva 42 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 66 La Cueva 46 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 71 La Cueva 61 | 2015-16 | S-H |
| Cleveland 62 La Cueva 51 | 2016-17 | T |
| Cleveland 92 La Cueva 52 | 2016-17 | S-H |
| Cleveland 93 La Cueva 81 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cleveland 79 La Cueva 60 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 77 La Cueva 59 | 2018-19 | S-H |
| Cleveland 76 La Cueva 48 | 2019-20 | Rio Rancho |
| La Cueva 69 Cleveland 62 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 74 Cleveland 45 | 2021-22 | T |
| Cleveland 63 La Cueva 60 | 2022-23 | H |
| Cleveland 73 La Cueva 57 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 69 La Cueva 62 | 2023-24 | T |
| Albuquerque Manzano | 6-5 | |
| Manzano 61 Cleveland 53 | 2009-10 | H |
| Manzano 55 Cleveland 34 | 2010-11 | T |
| Manzano 60 Cleveland 56 | 2011-12 | H |
| Manzano 57 Cleveland 53 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| Manzano 61 Cleveland 50 | 2012-13 | T |
| Cleveland 59 Manzano 49 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 58 Manzano 54 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cleveland 75 Manzano 47 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 68 Manzano 51 | 2015-16 | H |
| Cleveland 80 Manzano 70 | 2018-19 | T |
| Cleveland 71 Manzano 59 | 2019-20 | H |
| Albuquerque Menaul | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 71 Menaul 56 | 2019-20 | Rio Rancho |
| Albuquerque Rio Grande | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 59 Rio Grande 48 | 2015-16 | S-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Sandia | 7-8 | |
| Cleveland 63 Sandia 61 | 2010-11 | H |
| Sandia 68 Cleveland 57 | 2011-12 | T |
| Sandia 60 Cleveland 49 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 75 Cleveland 73 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cleveland 73 Sandia 62 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 81 Sandia 77 | 2014-15 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 82 Sandia 61 | 2016-17 | H |
| Cleveland 55 Sandia 51 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cleveland 77 Sandia 71 | 2018-19 | Rio Rancho |
| Sandia 62 Cleveland 55 | 2021-22 | H |
| Sandia 77 Cleveland 57 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 66 Cleveland 59 | 2022-23 | T |
| Sandia 64 Cleveland 62 | 2022-23 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 82 Sandia 64 | 2023-24 | H |
| Sandia 69 Cleveland 61 | 2023-24 | S-H |
| Albuquerque Sandia Prep | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 60 Sandia Prep 55 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Albuquerque Valley | 8-4 | |
| Cleveland 71 Valley 67 | 2010-11 | H |
| Cleveland 71 Valley 65 | 2010-11 | H |
| Valley 73 Cleveland 66 | 2011-12 | T |
| Valley 77 Cleveland 54 | 2012-13 | T |
| Cleveland 73 Valley 62 | 2013-14 | T |
| Valley 68 Cleveland 62 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 74 Valley 47 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 65 Valley 60 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Valley 57 Cleveland 52 | 2015-16 | T |
| Cleveland 58 Valley 39 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 61 Valley 56 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 67 Valley 65 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Volcano Vista | 20-27 | |
| Volcano Vista 50 Cleveland 41 | 2010-11 | T |
| Cleveland 60 Volcano Vista 37 | 2010-11 | H |
| Cleveland 62 Volcano Vista 58 | 2010-11 | DT-T |
| Volcano Vista 61 Cleveland 54 | 2011-12 | T |
| Volcano Vista 63 Cleveland 47 | 2011-12 | H |
| Volcano Vista 64 Cleveland 61 | 2011-12 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 60 Volcano Vista 57 | 2012-13 | T |
| Volcano Vista 77 Cleveland 75 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cleveland 52 Volcano Vista 41 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 49 Cleveland 41 | 2013-14 | H |
| Volcano Vista 60 Cleveland 53 | 2013-14 | T |
| Volcano Vista 57 Cleveland 47 | 2013-14 | TB-T |
| Volcano Vista 60 Cleveland 49 | 2013-14 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 54 Volcano Vista 50 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 56 Volcano Vista 53 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 64 Volcano Vista 46 | 2015-16 | T |
| Cleveland 67 Volcano Vista 46 | 2015-16 | H |
| Volcano Vista 69 Cleveland 60 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 72 Volcano Vista 54 | 2016-17 | T |
| Cleveland 71 Volcano Vista 49 | 2016-17 | H |
| Volcano Vista 82 Cleveland 79 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 74 Volcano Vista 65 | 2017-18 | H |
| Volcano Vista 58 Cleveland 44 | 2017-18 | T |
| Volcano Vista 67 Cleveland 63 | 2017-18 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 53 Volcano Vista 50 | 2017-18 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 71 Volcano Vista 70 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 58 Cleveland 57 | 2018-19 | H |
| Volcano Vista 73 Cleveland 71 | 2018-19 | T |
| Volcano Vista 64 Cleveland 58 | 2018-19 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 48 Volcano Vista 47 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 51 Cleveland 46 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 64 Volcano Vista 60 | 2019-20 | H |
| Cleveland 58 Volcano Vista 55 | 2019-20 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 68 Volcano Vista 67 | 2020-21 | H |
| Cleveland 74 Volcano Vista 67 | 2020-21 | T |
| Volcano Vista 81 Cleveland 70 | 2021-22 | Rio Rancho |
| Volcano Vista 76 Cleveland 56 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 73 Cleveland 45 | 2021-22 | T |
| Volcano Vista 84 Cleveland 59 | 2021-22 | H |
| Cleveland 53 Volcano Vista 50 | 2022-23 | H |
| Volcano Vista 66 Cleveland 55 | 2022-23 | T |
| Volcano Vista 70 Cleveland 42 | 2022-23 | DT-T |
| Volcano Vista 81 Cleveland 62 | 2023-24 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 64 Volcano Vista 60 | 2023-24 | Hobbs |
| Volcano Vista 63 Cleveland 56 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 68 Cleveland 46 | 2023-24 | T |
| Volcano Vista 76 Cleveland 52 | 2023-24 | H |
| Albuquerque West Mesa | 6-2 | |
| Cleveland 59 West Mesa 56 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 52 West Mesa 43 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 74 West Mesa 60 | 2009-10 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 67 West Mesa 59 | 2010-11 | S-H |
| Cleveland 83 West Mesa 54 | 2016-17 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 80 West Mesa 51 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 66 Cleveland 63 | 2022-23 | Rio Rancho |
| West Mesa 76 Cleveland 43 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Amarillo Palo Duro (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Palo Duro 79 Cleveland 46 | 2012-13 | Wolfforth |
| Anthem Boulder Creek (AZ) | 0-1 | |
| Boulder Creek 74 Cleveland 65 | 2010-11 | Chinle |
| Artesia | 3-1 | |
| Cleveland 82 Cleveland 56 | 2009-10 | Artesia |
| Cleveland 85 Artesia 66 | 2019-20 | Hobbs |
| Artesia 62 Cleveland 57 | 2022-23 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 79 Artesia 52 | 2023-24 | Hobbs |
| Blanding San Juan (UT) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 56 San Juan 42 | 2011-12 | Farmington |
| Brentwood Liberty (CA) | 0-1 | |
| Liberty 60 Cleveland 57 | 2015-16 | Mission Viejo |
| Canutillo (TX) | 3-0 | |
| Cleveland 65 Canutillo 32 | 2016-17 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 78 Canutillo 44 | 2017-18 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 53 Canutillo 38 | 2019-20 | Hobbs |
| Canyon Randall (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 66 Randall 65 | 2012-13 | Rio Rancho |
| Carlsbad | 3-0 | |
| Cleveland 72 Carlsbad 66 | 2013-14 | S-H |
| Cleveland 68 Carlsbad 54 | 2016-17 | H |
| Cleveland 85 Carlsbad 42 | 2017-18 | T |
| Clovis | 8-3 | |
| Clovis 65 Cleveland 51 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 62 Clovis 50 | 2010-11 | H |
| Clovis 72 Cleveland 50 | 2011-12 | T |
| Clovis 68 Cleveland 60 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cleveland 58 Clovis 48 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 72 Clovis 56 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 76 Clovis 45 | 2015-16 | T |
| Cleveland 81 Clovis 26 | 2016-17 | H |
| Cleveland 76 Clovis 67 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cleveland 80 Clovis 73 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 60 Clovis 59 | 2019-20 | T |
| Denver Lincoln (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Lincoln 74 Cleveland 67 | 2009-10 | Artesia |
| Durango (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Durango 73 Cleveland 64 | 2015-16 | Farmington |
| El Paso (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 63 El Paso 23 | 2014-15 | Hobbs |
| El Paso Andress (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 78 Andress 36 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| El Paso Cathedral (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Cathedral 66 Cleveland 44 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| El Paso Coronado (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Coronado 77 Cleveland 75 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| El Paso Franklin (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 95 Franklin 60 | 2017-18 | Rio Rancho |
| El Paso Irvin (TX) | 3-0 | |
| Cleveland 68 Irvin 39 | 2011-12 | Wolfforth |
| Cleveland 105 Irvin 55 | 2016-17 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 98 Irvin 52 | 2017-18 | Rio Rancho |
| El Paso Montwood (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 64 Montwood 25 | 2013-14 | Farmington |
| Espanola | 6-5 | |
| Espanola 70 Cleveland 57 | 2009-10 | Rio Rancho |
| Espanola 87 Cleveland 70 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 56 Espanola 48 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Espanola 52 Cleveland 49 | 2011-12 | H |
| Espanola 76 Cleveland 67 | 2012-13 | H |
| Espanola 88 Cleveland 83 | 2012-13 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 70 Espanola 36 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 80 Espanola 60 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 87 Espanola 36 | 2020-21 | H |
| Cleveland 69 Espanola 65 | 2021-22 | T |
| Cleveland 88 Espanola 56 | 2022-23 | H |
| Fabens (TX) | 2-0 | |
| Cleveland 71 Fabens 25 | 2013-14 | Farmington |
| Cleveland 81 Fabens 35 | 2015-16 | Farmington |
| Farmington | 2-1 | |
| Cleveland 87 Farmington 62 | 2014-15 | Farmington |
| Cleveland 79 Farmington 49 | 2022-23 | Hobbs |
| Farmington 61 Cleveland 58 | 2023-24 | Hobbs |
| Farmington Piedra Vista | 10-0 | |
| Cleveland 67 Piedra Vista 65 | 2009-10 | H |
| FW Piedra Vista 73 Cleveland 70 | 2011-12 | Farmington |
| Cleveland 66 Piedra Vista 29 | 2014-15 | Farmington |
| Cleveland 80 Piedra Vista 27 | 2016-17 | H |
| Cleveland 79 Piedra Vista 62 | 2016-17 | T |
| Cleveland 77 Piedra Vista 65 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cleveland 82 Piedra Vista 48 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cleveland 79 Piedra Vista 32 | 2018-19 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 76 Piedra Vista 24 | 2021-22 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 78 Piedra Vista 15 | 2022-23 | Rio Rancho |
| Fort Wingate | 0-1 | |
| Wingate 54 Cleveland 53 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gallup | 5-2 | |
| Gallup 76 Cleveland 58 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 72 Gallup 70 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 80 Gallup 66 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 79 Gallup 68 | 2010-11 | T |
| Cleveland 69 Gallup 63 | 2011-12 | Farmington |
| Gallup 68 Cleveland 64 | 2011-12 | H |
| Cleveland 77 Gallup 41 | 2021-22 | Hobbs |
| Gallup Miyamura | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 65 Miyamura 28 | 2023-24 | Rio Rancho |
| Grants | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 59 Grants 58 | 2015-16 | H |
| Hobbs | 5-4 | |
| Hobbs 79 Cleveland 77 | 2013-14 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 60 Cleveland 56 | 2014-15 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 86 Hobbs 70 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 74 Hobbs 65 | 2019-20 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 77 Cleveland 53 | 2021-22 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 94 Cleveland 81 | 2021-22 | T |
| Cleveland 57 Hobbs 54 | 2022-23 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 68 Hobbs 52 | 2022-23 | H |
| Cleveland 92 Hobbs 78 | 2023-24 | T |
| Indio Shadow Hills (CA) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 67 Shadow Hills 48 | 2015-16 | Mission Viejo |
| Irvine Beckman (CA) | 0-1 | |
| Beckman 79 Cleveland 63 | 2015-16 | Mission Viejo |
| Kirtland Central | 2-0 | |
| Cleveland 94 Central 51 | 2014-15 | Farmington |
| Cleveland 64 Central 53 | 2015-16 | Farmington |
| Las Cruces | 4-10 | |
| Las Cruces 89 Cleveland 82 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 72 Las Cruces 52 | 2009-10 | Rio Rancho |
| Las Cruces 68 Cleveland 48 | 2010-11 | T |
| Las Cruces 58 Cleveland 56 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Las Cruces 78 Cleveland 71 | 2011-12 | H |
| Las Cruces 85 Cleveland 63 | 2012-13 | H |
| Las Cruces 67 Cleveland 59 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cleveland 55 Las Cruces 42 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 74 Las Cruces 65 | 2015-16 | H |
| Las Cruces 70 Cleveland 69 | 2016-17 | H |
| Las Cruces 47 Cleveland 45 | 2016-17 | S-Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces 68 Cleveland 64 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cleveland 55 Las Cruces 49 | 2020-21 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces 74 Cleveland 49 | 2021-22 | T |
| Las Cruces Centennial | 6-1 | |
| Cleveland 60 Centennial 56 | 2013-14 | Hobbs |
| Centennial 51 Cleveland 47 | 2014-15 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 84 Centennial 51 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cleveland 61 Centennial 48 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 60 Centennial 59 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 72 Centennial 71 | 2022-23 | H |
| Cleveland 77 Centennial 61 | 2023-24 | T |
| Las Cruces Mayfield | 7-0 | |
| Cleveland 72 Mayfield 58 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 76 Mayfield 46 | 2018-19 | T |
| Cleveland 90 Mayfield 64 | 2019-20 | H |
| Cleveland 73 Mayfield 63 | 2021-22 | H |
| Cleveland 54 Mayfield 40 | 2021-22 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 64 Mayfield 59 | 2022-23 | T |
| Cleveland 70 Mayfield 55 | 2023-24 | H |
| Las Cruces Onate | 6-5 | |
| Onate 69 Cleveland 66 | 2009-10 | T |
| Onate 77 Cleveland 74 | 2010-11 | H |
| Onate 67 Cleveland 50 | 2010-11 | S-Albuquerque |
| Onate 60 Cleveland 59 | 2011-12 | T |
| Cleveland 50 Onate 40 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cleveland 49 Onate 35 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 79 Onate 70 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 65 Onate 59 | 2015-16 | T |
| Onate 76 Cleveland 72 | 2016-17 | T |
| Cleveland 93 Onate 86 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cleveland 84 Onate 52 | 2018-19 | S-Albuquerque |
| Lawton (OK) | 1-1 | |
| Lawton 70 Cleveland 66 | 2016-17 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 75 Lawton 45 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Little Elm (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 58 Little Elm 56 | 2010-11 | Weatherford |
| Los Lunas | 5-2 | |
| Cleveland 83 Los Lunas 65 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 68 Los Lunas 59 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cleveland 57 Los Lunas 24 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 67 Los Lunas 63 | 2016-17 | Rio Rancho |
| Los Lunas 74 Cleveland 71 | 2017-18 | Rio Rancho |
| Los Lunas 59 Cleveland 53 | 2021-22 | S-T |
| Cleveland 67 Los Lunas 61 | 2023-24 | T |
| Lubbock (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 59 Lubbock 48 | 2012-13 | Wolfforth |
| Lubbock Coronado (TX) | 0-2 | |
| Coronado 77 Cleveland 62 | 2011-12 | Wolfforth |
| Coronado 57 Cleveland 38 | 2012-13 | Wolfforth |
| Lubbock Monterey (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 74 Monterey 72 | 2010-11 | Weatherford |
| Moore (OK) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 83 Moore 69 | 2014-15 | Hobbs |
| Moriarty | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 94 Moriarty 64 | 2009-10 | T |
| Odessa (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 73 Odessa 47 | 2013-14 | Hobbs |
| Phoenix Central (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 103 Central 98 | 2009-10 | Rio Rancho |
| Red Oak (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 74 Red Oak 70 | 2010-11 | Weatherford |
| Rio Rancho | 30-16 | |
| Rio Rancho 90 Cleveland 85 | 2009-10 | H |
| Rio Rancho 75 Cleveland 67 | 2009-10 | T |
| Rio Rancho 81 Cleveland 73 | 2009-10 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 75 Rio Rancho 53 | 2010-11 | H |
| Cleveland 73 Rio Rancho 26 | 2010-11 | T |
| Cleveland 86 Rio Rancho 69 | 2010-11 | DT-H |
| Rio Rancho 79 Cleveland 66 | 2011-12 | T |
| Cleveland 78 Rio Rancho 71 | 2011-12 | H |
| Cleveland 66 Rio Rancho 65 | 2011-12 | DT-H |
| Rio Rancho 82 Cleveland 81 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 68 Rio Rancho 62 | 2012-13 | H |
| Rio Rancho 62 Cleveland 52 | 2012-13 | T |
| Rio Rancho 80 Cleveland 77 | 2012-13 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 86 Rio Rancho 54 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 65 Rio Rancho 56 | 2013-14 | T |
| Cleveland 88 Rio Rancho 66 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cleveland 58 Rio Rancho 51 | 2013-14 | DT-H |
| Rio Rancho 85 Cleveland 84 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 67 Rio Rancho 62 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 76 Rio Rancho 75 | 2014-15 | DT-H |
| Rio Rancho 79 Cleveland 72 | 2015-16 | T |
| Cleveland 78 Rio Rancho 61 | 2015-16 | H |
| Rio Rancho 49 Cleveland 43 | 2015-16 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 105 Rio Rancho 103 | 2016-17 | H |
| Rio Rancho 78 Cleveland 70 | 2016-17 | T |
| Rio Rancho 85 Cleveland 83 | 2016-17 | DT-H |
| Rio Rancho 85 Cleveland 83 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cleveland 108 Rio Rancho 77 | 2017-18 | H |
| Cleveland 87 Rio Rancho 73 | 2017-18 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 86 Rio Rancho 73 | 2017-18 | S-H |
| Cleveland 90 Rio Rancho 68 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 77 Rio Rancho 64 | 2018-19 | T |
| Cleveland 83 Rio Rancho 74 | 2018-19 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 71 Rio Rancho 60 | 2019-20 | T |
| Cleveland 67 Rio Rancho 43 | 2019-20 | H |
| Cleveland 66 Rio Rancho 55 | 2019-20 | S-H |
| Cleveland 50 Rio Rancho 44 | 2020-21 | H |
| Cleveland 67 Rio Rancho 58 | 2020-21 | T |
| Cleveland 54 Rio Rancho 46 | 2021-22 | T |
| Rio Rancho 55 Cleveland 43 | 2021-22 | H |
| Rio Rancho 71 Cleveland 57 | 2021-22 | DT-T |
| Cleveland 85 Rio Rancho 74 | 2022-23 | H |
| Rio Rancho 63 Cleveland 50 | 2022-23 | T |
| Cleveland 48 Rio Rancho 40 | 2022-23 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 85 Rio Rancho 59 | 2023-24 | T |
| Cleveland 85 Rio Rancho 53 | 2023-24 | H |
| Roswell | 5-0 | |
| Cleveland 100 Roswell 97 | 2018-19 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 90 Roswell 41 | 2019-20 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 76 Roswell 62 | 2020-21 | Estancia |
| Cleveland 82 Roswell 52 | 2022-23 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 90 Roswell 52 | 2023-24 | Rio Rancho |
| Roswell Goddard | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 63 Goddard 58 | 2009-10 | Artesia |
| Santa Fe | 13-1 | |
| Cleveland 61 Santa Fe 56 | 2014-15 | T |
| Cleveland 96 Santa Fe 58 | 2014-15 | H |
| Cleveland 81 Santa Fe 53 | 2015-16 | H |
| Cleveland 67 Santa Fe 27 | 2015-16 | T |
| Cleveland 77 Santa Fe 65 | 2017-18 | Hobbs |
| Santa Fe 63 Cleveland 62 | 2018-19 | T |
| Cleveland 70 Santa Fe 58 | 2019-20 | H |
| Cleveland 66 Santa Fe 45 | 2019-20 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 65 Santa Fe 42 | 2020-21 | T |
| Cleveland 60 Santa Fe 49 | 2020-21 | S-H |
| Cleveland 66 Santa Fe 63 | 2021-22 | H |
| Cleveland 64 Santa Fe 62 | 2022-23 | T |
| Cleveland 79 Santa Fe 74 | 2023-24 | H |
| Cleveland 79 Santa Fe 46 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Santa Fe Capital | 6-1 | |
| Cleveland 90 Capital 72 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 66 Capital 53 | 2010-11 | T |
| Cleveland 83 Capital 69 | 2018-19 | H |
| Cleveland 75 Capital 64 | 2019-20 | T |
| Capital 74 Cleveland 64 | 2019-20 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cleveland 73 Capital 64 | 2022-23 | H |
| Cleveland 80 Capital 48 | 2023-24 | T |
| Santa Fe St Michaels | 2-0 | |
| Cleveland 68 St Michaels 61 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 66 St Michaels 43 | 2021-22 | Rio Rancho |
| Santa Teresa | 0-2 | |
| Santa Teresa 57 Cleveland 47 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Santa Teresa 58 Cleveland 45 | 2012-13 | Rio Rancho |
| Shiprock | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 71 Shiprock 26 | 2013-14 | Farmington |
| Thousand Oaks (CA) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 59 Thousand Oaks 37 | 2015-16 | Mission Viejo |
| Trophy Club Nelson (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Nelson 66 Cleveland 63 | 2011-12 | Wolfforth |
| Wichita Falls Hirschi (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Cleveland 43 Hirschi 40 | 2016-17 | Hobbs |
| Winslow (AZ) | 0-1 | |
| Winslow 59 Cleveland 55 | 2010-11 | Chinle |