| Gallup record vs | rec/yr | location |
| Alamogordo | 3-5 | |
| Alamogordo 47 Gallup 43 | 1964-65 | T |
| Gallup 83 Alamogordo 64 | 1965-66 | T |
| Alamogordo 61 Gallup 38 | 1998-99 | Alamogordo |
| Gallup 80 Alamogordo 65 | 2006-07 | Farmington |
| Alamogordo 65 Gallup 64 | 2006-07 | Alamogordo |
| Alamogordo 82 Gallup 76 | 2007-08 | Farmington |
| Alamogordo 76 Gallup 72 | 2007-08 | Alamogordo |
| Gallup 67 Alamogordo 54 | 2008-09 | Farmington |
| Albuquerque | 16-46 | |
| Gallup 49 Albuquerque 41 | 1953-54 | H |
| Albuquerque 42 Gallup 37 | 1954-55 | T |
| Albuquerque 57 Gallup 56 | 1954-55 | DT-H |
| Albuquerque 49 Gallup 46 | 1955-56 | H |
| Albuquerque 63 Gallup 40 | 1956-57 | T |
| Gallup 38 Albuquerque 31 | 1957-58 | T |
| Albuquerque 70 Gallup 54 | 1957-58 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 48 Gallup 20 | 1958-59 | T |
| Albuquerque 58 Gallup 38 FW | 1959-60 | H |
| Gallup 40 Albuquerque 37 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 58 Albuquerque 44 | 1960-61 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 64 Albuquerque 40 | 1961-62 | H |
| Albuquerque 44 Gallup 41 | 1962-63 | T |
| Gallup 49 Albuquerque 47 | 1963-64 | H |
| Albuquerque 74 Gallup 62 | 1966-67 | T |
| Albuquerque 60 Gallup 52 | 1967-68 | H |
| Albuquerque 67 Gallup 65 | 1972-73 | S-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 67 Gallup 50 | 1973-74 | T |
| Albuquerque 47 Gallup 37 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 77 Albuquerque 70 | 1974-75 | H |
| Albuquerque 74 Gallup 59 | 1974-75 | T |
| Albuquerque 83 Gallup 67 | 1975-76 | H |
| Albuquerque 73 Gallup 69 | 1975-76 | T |
| Albuquerque 77 Gallup 53 | 1976-77 | H |
| Albuquerque 79 Gallup 31 | 1976-77 | T |
| Albuquerque 91 Gallup 53 | 1977-78 | H |
| Albuquerque 77 Gallup 64 | 1977-78 | T |
| Albuquerque 61 Gallup 50 | 1978-79 | T |
| Albuquerque 65 Gallup 56 | 1978-79 | H |
| Albuquerque 91 Gallup 58 | 1979-80 | H |
| Albuquerque 109 Gallup 65 | 1979-80 | T |
| Albuquerque 77 Gallup 47 | 1980-81 | T |
| Albuquerque 75 Gallup 60 | 1980-81 | H |
| Albuquerque 57 Gallup 48 | 1981-82 | H |
| Albuquerque 81 Gallup 55 | 1981-82 | T |
| Albuquerque 82 Gallup 60 | 1982-83 | T |
| Gallup 73 Albuquerque 63 | 1982-83 | H |
| Albuquerque 60 Gallup 50 | 1992-93 | T |
| Albuquerque 73 Gallup 72 | 1993-94 | H |
| Albuquerque 64 Gallup 34 | 1994-95 | T |
| Albuquerque 106 Gallup 65 | 1995-96 | H |
| Albuquerque 99 Gallup 46 | 1996-97 | T |
| Albuquerque 84 Gallup 58 | 1996-97 | H |
| Albuquerque 59 Gallup 40 | 1997-98 | H |
| Albuquerque 96 Gallup 55 | 1997-98 | T |
| Albuquerque 77 Gallup 39 | 1997-98 | DT-T |
| Albuquerque 101 Gallup 64 | 1998-99 | T |
| Albuquerque 64 Gallup 40 | 1998-99 | H |
| Albuquerque 57 Gallup 44 | 1998-99 | DT-T |
| Albuquerque 83 Gallup 59 | 99-2000 | H |
| Albuquerque 71 Gallup 52 | 99-2000 | T |
| Albuquerque 44 Gallup 19 | 2000-01 | H |
| Albuquerque 81 Gallup 43 | 2000-01 | T |
| Gallup 68 Albuquerque 54 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gallup 81 Albuquerque 70 | 2001-02 | H |
| Gallup 68 Albuquerque 63 | 2004-05 | H |
| Gallup 75 Albuquerque 74 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 83 Albuquerque 63 | 2006-07 | H |
| Albuquerque 63 Gallup 62 | 2007-08 | Gallup |
| Gallup 57 Albuquerque 55 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gallup 74 Albuquerque 50 | 2008-09 | H |
| Albuquerque 69 Gallup 66 | 2009-10 | T |
| Albuquerque Academy | 11-8 | |
| Gallup 56 Academy 52 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 64 Academy 62 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 76 Academy 62 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 78 Academy 66 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 76 Academy 56 | 1973-74 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 85 Academy 79 | 1977-78 | Roswell |
| Gallup 62 Academy 54 | 1982-83 | H |
| Academy 60 Gallup 41 | 2003-04 | Moriarty |
| Academy 61 Gallup 55 | 2004-05 | Moriarty |
| Gallup 50 Academy 45 | 2008-09 | H |
| Academy 74 Gallup 63 | 2009-10 | T |
| Academy 48 Gallup 43 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gallup 80 Academy 64 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 53 Academy 50 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 54 Academy 37 | 2015-16 | T |
| Academy 69 Gallup 67 | 2021-22 | H |
| Academy 68 Gallup 58 | 2022-23 | T |
| Academy 87 Gallup 34 | 2023-24 | H |
| Academy 92 Gallup 67 | 2023-24 | S-T |
| Albuquerque Atrisco Heritage | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 69 Atrisco Heritage 66 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 75 Atrisco Heritage 63 | 2015-16 | H |
| Albuquerque Cibola | 16-24 | |
| Cibola 78 Gallup 60 | 1978-79 | Roswell |
| Gallup 70 Cibola 43 | 1992-93 | H |
| Cibola 60 Gallup 47 | 1992-93 | T |
| Cibola 62 Gallup 59 | 1992-93 | DT-T |
| Cibola 68 Gallup 48 | 1993-94 | T |
| Gallup 60 Cibola 59 | 1993-94 | H |
| Cibola 82 Gallup 61 | 1993-94 | DT-T |
| Gallup 66 Cibola 64 | 1994-95 | H |
| Cibola 77 Gallup 57 | 1994-95 | T |
| Cibola 59 Gallup 43 | 1995-96 | T |
| Cibola 98 Gallup 62 | 1995-96 | H |
| Cibola 53 Gallup 21 | 2000-01 | T |
| Cibola 47 Gallup 29 | 2000-01 | H |
| Cibola 61 Gallup 34 | 2000-01 | DT-T |
| Cibola 70 Gallup 58 | 2001-02 | H |
| Cibola 87 Gallup 74 | 2001-02 | T |
| Cibola 68 Gallup 45 | 2002-03 | T |
| Gallup 53 Cibola 49 | 2002-03 | T |
| Cibola 63 Gallup 59 | 2003-04 | H |
| Cibola 78 Gallup 56 | 2003-04 | T |
| Gallup 65 Cibola 64 | 2005-06 | H |
| Cibola 48 Gallup 47 | 2005-06 | T |
| Cibola 57 Gallup 51 | 2005-06 | H |
| Cibola 84 Gallup 66 | 2005-06 | DT-T |
| Cibola 61 Gallup 55 | 2006-07 | T |
| Cibola 54 Gallup 47 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gallup 48 Cibola 40 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 63 Cibola 61 | 2006-07 | DT-T |
| Gallup 61 Cibola 46 | 2007-08 | H |
| Cibola 54 Gallup 44 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gallup 57 Cibola 54 | 2007-08 | H |
| Cibola 61 Gallup 56 | 2007-08 | DT-T |
| Gallup 50 Cibola 43 | 2008-09 | T |
| Gallup 50 Cibola 44 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 44 Cibola 41 | 2008-09 | T |
| Gallup 49 Cibola 47 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gallup 55 Cibola 52 | 2009-10 | H |
| Gallup 59 Cibola 51 | 2009-10 | DT-H |
| Gallup 49 Cibola 37 | 2012-13 | H |
| Cibola 65 Gallup 49 | 2013-14 | T |
| Albuquerque Del Norte | 10-21 | |
| Del Norte 56 Gallup 44 | 1964-65 | Gallup |
| Del Norte 62 Gallup 50 | 1966-67 | T |
| Del Norte 68 Gallup 55 | 1967-68 | H |
| Gallup 70 Del Norte 60 | 1968-69 | T |
| Del Norte 79 Gallup 63 | 1969-70 | H |
| Gallup 66 Del Norte 46 | 1980-81 | H |
| Del Norte 79 Gallup 71 | 1981-82 | T |
| Del Norte 59 Gallup 47 | 1983-84 | T |
| Del Norte 61 Gallup 51 | 1983-84 | H |
| Del Norte 70 Gallup 59 | 1983-84 | DT-T |
| Gallup 52 Del Norte 45 | 1984-85 | T |
| Gallup 71 Del Norte 56 | 1984-85 | H |
| Gallup 51 Del Norte 48 | 1984-85 | DT-H |
| Del Norte 48 Gallup 43 | 1985-86 | T |
| Del Norte 62 Gallup 46 | 1985-86 | H |
| Del Norte 54 Gallup 44 | 1986-87 | T |
| Del Norte 49 Gallup 48 | 1986-87 | H |
| Del Norte 60 Gallup 44 | 1987-88 | T |
| Del Norte 82 Gallup 49 | 1987-88 | H |
| Del Norte 57 Gallup 51 | 1998-99 | H |
| Del Norte 78 Gallup 72 | 99-2000 | T |
| Del Norte 48 Gallup 43 | 2000-01 | H |
| Gallup 52 Del Norte 51 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gallup 76 Del Norte 72 | 2002-03 | H |
| Gallup 72 Del Norte 68 | 2003-04 | T |
| Del Norte 71 Gallup 57 | 2004-05 | T |
| Del Norte 75 Gallup 43 | 2005-06 | H |
| Del Norte 76 Gallup 45 | 2005-06 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Del Norte 63 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 68 Del Norte 37 | 2015-16 | T |
| Del Norte 55 Gallup 47 | 2018-19 | S-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Eldorado | 8-5 | |
| Gallup 96 Eldorado 65 | 1972-73 | Gallup |
| Gallup 72 Eldorado 47 | 1973-74 | Gallup |
| Gallup 40 Eldorado 39 | 1975-76 | Gallup |
| Gallup 60 Eldorado 52 | 1976-77 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Eldorado 64 | 1977-78 | Gallup |
| Eldorado 70 Gallup 68 | 1994-95 | H |
| Eldorado 97 Gallup 58 | 1995-96 | H |
| Eldorado 45 Gallup 29 | 2000-01 | T |
| Eldorado 80 Gallup 66 | 2004-05 | T |
| Eldorado 70 Gallup 35 | 2004-05 | H |
| Gallup 53 Eldorado 48 | 2006-07 | S-T |
| Gallup 79 Eldorado 72 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 55 Eldorado 53 | 2015-16 | H |
| Albuquerque Highland | 10-34 | |
| Highland 65 Gallup 41 | 1953-54 | DT-T |
| Gallup 56 Highland 46 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 65 Highland 58 | 1954-55 | DT-H |
| Highland 53 Gallup 49 | 1955-56 | T |
| Highland 61 Gallup 50 | 1955-56 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Highland 65 Gallup 47 | 1956-57 | H |
| Highland 56 Gallup 47 | 1957-58 | T |
| Highland 40 Gallup 20 | 1958-59 | T |
| Highland 53 Gallup 36 | 1959-60 | T |
| Highland 50 Gallup 46 | 1960-61 | H |
| Highland 55 Gallup 51 | 1961-62 | T |
| Highland 45 Gallup 40 | 1962-63 | H |
| Highland 40 Gallup 39 | 1963-64 | T |
| Highland 54 Gallup 18 | 1963-64 | DT-T |
| Highland 59 Gallup 45 | 1966-67 | H |
| Highland 63 Gallup 46 | 1967-68 | T |
| Highland 57 Gallup 45 | 1971-72 | S-Albuquerque |
| Highland 60 Gallup 52 | 1973-74 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 63 Gallup 38 | 1974-75 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 65 Gallup 56 | 1985-86 | T |
| Highland 54 Gallup 50 | 1986-87 | H |
| Highland 46 Gallup 44 | 1987-88 | T |
| Highland 71 Gallup 54 | 1988-89 | H |
| Highland 59 Gallup 51 | 1989-90 | T |
| Gallup 67 Highland 64 | 1990-91 | H |
| Highland 82 Gallup 59 | 1991-92 | T |
| Highland 65 Gallup 58 | 1992-93 | H |
| Highland 67 Gallup 47 | 1992-93 | T |
| Highland 77 Gallup 64 | 1993-94 | T |
| Highland 63 Gallup 47 | 1993-94 | H |
| Gallup 63 Highland 49 | 1994-95 | H |
| Highland 71 Gallup 62 | 1994-95 | T |
| Highland 87 Gallup 41 | 1995-96 | T |
| Highland 63 Gallup 60 | 1995-96 | H |
| Highland 67 Gallup 56 | 1998-99 | T |
| Highland 58 Gallup 55 | 99-2000 | H |
| Highland 68 Gallup 43 | 2000-01 | T |
| Gallup 54 Highland 46 | 2001-02 | H |
| Gallup 63 Highland 44 | 2002-03 | T |
| Gallup 61 Highland 48 | 2003-04 | H |
| Gallup 59 Highland 55 | 2005-06 | Gallup |
| Gallup 65 Highland 63 | 2007-08 | S-T |
| Gallup 43 Highland 40 | 2009-10 | S-H |
| Highland 69 Gallup 49 | 2019-20 | S-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Hope Christian | 0-3 | |
| Hope Christian 67 Gallup 52 | 2009-10 | Rio Rancho |
| Hope Christian 75 Gallup 46 | 2010-11 | H |
| Hope Christian 85 Gallup 45 | 2011-12 | T |
| Albuquerque Manzano | 6-16 | |
| Gallup 77 Manzano 69 | 1960-61 | H |
| Gallup 57 Manzano 51 | 1961-62 | T |
| Manzano 45 Gallup 44 | 1962-63 | H |
| Manzano 66 Gallup 52 | 1963-64 | T |
| Manzano 87 Gallup 59 | 1966-67 | H |
| Manzano 59 Gallup 54 | 1967-68 | T |
| Gallup 78 Manzano 64 | 1968-69 | H |
| Manzano 78 Gallup 57 | 1969-70 | T |
| Manzano 61 Gallup 44 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 60 Manzano 58 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 69 Manzano 67 | 1972-73 | H |
| Manzano 74 Gallup 51 | 1973-74 | T |
| Manzano 81 Gallup 47 | 1974-75 | H |
| Manzano 75 Gallup 50 | 1975-76 | T |
| Manzano 65 Gallup 54 | 1996-97 | H |
| Manzano 83 Gallup 49 | 1996-97 | T |
| Manzano 74 Gallup 53 | 1997-98 | T |
| Manzano 52 Gallup 44 | 1997-98 | H |
| Manzano 69 Gallup 56 | 1998-99 | T |
| Gallup 60 Manzano 54 | 1998-99 | H |
| Manzano 70 Gallup 53 | 99-2000 | H |
| Manzano 81 Gallup 57 | 99-2000 | T |
| Albuquerque Menaul | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 72 Menaul 22 | 1954-55 | H |
| Albuquerque Rio Grande | 9-25 | |
| Rio Grande 51 Gallup 43 | 1959-60 | Gallup |
| Gallup 64 Rio Grande 63 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 40 Rio Grande 36 | 1961-62 | Gallup |
| Gallup 47 Rio Grande 44 | 1961-62 | H |
| Gallup 47 Rio Grande 45 | 1962-63 | Gallup |
| Rio Grande 48 Gallup 43 | 1962-63 | T |
| Rio Grande 49 Gallup 39 | 1963-64 | T |
| Rio Grande 80 Gallup 71 | 1965-66 | Gallup |
| Rio Grande 72 Gallup 50 | 1966-67 | H |
| Rio Grande 70 Gallup 63 | 1967-68 | T |
| Rio Grande 61 Gallup 55 | 1973-74 | Gallup |
| Gallup 66 Rio Grande 42 | 1982-83 | H |
| Rio Grande 66 Gallup 47 | 1983-84 | T |
| Rio Grande 60 Gallup 57 | 1984-85 | H |
| Rio Grande 57 Gallup 42 | 1985-86 | T |
| Rio Grande 61 Gallup 49 | 1986-87 | H |
| Rio Grande 72 Gallup 59 | 1987-88 | T |
| Rio Grande 73 Gallup 52 | 1996-97 | T |
| Gallup 70 Rio Grande 59 | 1996-97 | H |
| Rio Grande 50 Gallup 48 | 1997-98 | H |
| Rio Grande 56 Gallup 55 | 1997-98 | T |
| Rio Grande 75 Gallup 60 | 1998-99 | H |
| Rio Grande 97 Gallup 87 | 1998-99 | T |
| Gallup 69 Rio Grande 63 | 99-2000 | H |
| Rio Grande 63 Gallup 60 | 99-2000 | T |
| Rio Grande 66 Gallup 39 | 2000-01 | H |
| Gallup 62 Rio Grande 54 | 2002-03 | H |
| Rio Grande 86 Gallup 69 | 2002-03 | T |
| Rio Grande 74 Gallup 29 | 2003-04 | T |
| Rio Grande 68 Gallup 57 | 2003-04 | H |
| Rio Grande 71 Gallup 56 | 2004-05 | H |
| Rio Grande 88 Gallup 70 | 2004-05 | T |
| Gallup 62 Rio Grande 52 | 2010-11 | T |
| Rio Grande 62 Gallup 54 | 2010-11 | H |
| Albuquerque Sandia | 3-24 | |
| Sandia 55 Gallup 27 | 1963-64 | H |
| Sandia 85 Gallup 50 | 1966-67 | Gallup |
| Sandia 72 Gallup 42 | 1966-67 | T |
| Sandia 75 Gallup 47 | 1967-68 | Gallup |
| Sandia 54 Gallup 51 | 1967-68 | H |
| Sandia 81 Gallup 48 | 1983-84 | H |
| Sandia 82 Gallup 48 | 1984-85 | T |
| Sandia 84 Gallup 42 | 1984-85 | S-Albuquerque |
| Sandia 48 Gallup 42 | 1985-86 | H |
| Sandia 80 Gallup 52 | 1986-87 | T |
| Sandia 88 Gallup 65 | 1988-89 | H |
| Sandia 75 Gallup 62 | 1988-89 | T |
| Sandia 88 Gallup 72 | 1989-90 | T |
| Sandia 80 Gallup 73 | 1989-90 | H |
| Sandia 97 Gallup 54 | 1990-91 | H |
| Sandia 86 Gallup 54 | 1990-91 | T |
| Sandia 95 Gallup 79 | 1991-92 | T |
| Sandia 86 Gallup 61 | 1991-92 | H |
| Sandia 47 Gallup 29 | 1996-97 | H |
| Sandia 80 Gallup 20 | 1997-98 | T |
| Sandia 75 Gallup 48 | 1998-99 | H |
| Sandia 62 Gallup 43 | 99-2000 | T |
| Gallup 74 Sandia 62 | 2007-08 | H |
| Gallup 72 Sandia 51 | 2012-13 | T |
| Sandia 58 Gallup 51 | 2013-14 | H |
| Sandia 57 Gallup 51 | 2016-17 | H |
| Gallup 50 Sandia 38 | 2017-18 | T |
| Albuquerque Sandia Prep | 5-1 | |
| Gallup 60 Sandia Prep 51 | 2009-10 | Gallup |
| Gallup 57 Sandia Prep 45 | 2010-11 | Gallup |
| Gallup 51 Sandia Prep 48 | 2013-14 | Gallup |
| Gallup 74 Sandia Prep 46 | 2015-16 | Gallup |
| Sandia Prep 67 Gallup 61 | 2017-18 | Gallup |
| Gallup 61 Sandia Prep 60 | 2019-20 | Gallup |
| Albuquerque St Mary | 8-6 | |
| Gallup 55 St Mary 51 | 1954-55 | T |
| Gallup 67 St Mary 64 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 47 St Mary 44 | 1957-58 | H |
| Gallup 49 St Mary 40 | 1957-58 | T |
| St Mary 50 Gallup 48 | 1958-59 | T |
| Gallup 40 St Mary 35 | 1959-60 | H |
| St Mary 55 Gallup 48 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 44 St Mary 39 | 1961-62 | H |
| St Mary 54 Gallup 46 | 1961-62 | DT-Albuquerque |
| St Mary 58 Gallup 45 | 1962-63 | T |
| St Mary 56 Gallup 41 | 1962-63 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 69 St Mary 47 | 1964-65 | H |
| St Mary 50 Gallup 47 | 1964-65 | DT-Los Lunas |
| Gallup 67 St Mary 65 | 1965-66 | T |
| Albuquerque St Pius X | 11-17 | |
| Gallup 46 St Pius X 37 | 1961-62 | T |
| St Pius X 60 Gallup 50 | 1962-63 | H |
| St Pius X 50 Gallup 41 | 1963-64 | T |
| St Pius X 55 Gallup 38 | 1964-65 | H |
| St Pius X 85 Gallup 64 | 1965-66 | T |
| St Pius X 72 Gallup 60 | 1965-66 | DT-Gallup |
| Gallup 71 St Pius X 63 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 57 St Pius X 48 | 1973-74 | T |
| St Pius X 77 Gallup 75 | 1974-75 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 76 St Pius X 53 | 1981-82 | H |
| St Pius X 66 Gallup 51 | 1991-92 | T |
| Gallup 75 St Pius X 61 | 1992-93 | H |
| Gallup 70 St Pius X 59 | 1993-94 | T |
| Gallup 57 St Pius X 49 | 2010-11 | T |
| St Pius X 50 Gallup 33 | 2011-12 | H |
| St Pius X 57 Gallup 48 | 2011-12 | Gallup |
| Gallup 49 St Pius X 47 | 2011-12 | S-Albuquerque |
| St Pius X 60 Gallup 56 | 2012-13 | T |
| St Pius X 65 Gallup 58 | 2012-13 | Gallup |
| St Pius X 66 Gallup 58 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 45 St Pius X 41 | 2014-15 | H |
| St Pius X 58 Gallup 56 | 2015-16 | T |
| St Pius X 50 Gallup 49 | 2016-17 | Grants |
| St Pius X 77 Gallup 55 | 2017-18 | T |
| St Pius X 58 Gallup 47 | 2017-18 | S-T |
| Gallup 63 St Pius X 44 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 67 St Pius X 59 | 2019-20 | T |
| St Pius X 57 Gallup 50 | 2021-22 | H |
| Albuquerque Valley | 4-34 | |
| Gallup 64 Valley 50 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 64 Valley 53 | 1955-56 | T |
| Valley 63 Gallup 45 | 1956-57 | H |
| Valley 61 Gallup 43 | 1957-58 | H |
| Valley 52 Gallup 34 | 1958-59 | H |
| Valley 81 Gallup 52 | 1959-60 | H |
| Gallup 60 Valley 46 | 1960-61 | H |
| Valley 70 Gallup 55 | 1963-64 | T |
| Valley 76 Gallup 36 | 1966-67 | T |
| Valley 80 Gallup 62 | 1966-67 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Valley 63 Gallup 52 | 1967-68 | H |
| Valley 74 Gallup 65 | 1967-68 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Valley 86 Gallup 64 | 1996-97 | T |
| Valley 98 Gallup 96 | 1996-97 | T |
| Valley 49 Gallup 38 | 1997-98 | H |
| Valley 62 Gallup 53 | 1997-98 | T |
| Valley 82 Gallup 45 | 1998-99 | T |
| Valley 75 Gallup 64 | 1998-99 | H |
| Valley 79 Gallup 70 | 99-2000 | H |
| Valley 95 Gallup 60 | 99-2000 | T |
| Valley 51 Gallup 37 | 2000-01 | H |
| Valley 51 Gallup 44 | 2000-01 | T |
| Valley 66 Gallup 46 | 2001-02 | T |
| Valley 48 Gallup 46 | 2001-02 | T |
| Valley 78 Gallup 58 | 2001-02 | DT-H |
| Valley 81 Gallup 67 | 2002-03 | H |
| Valley 69 Gallup 58 | 2002-03 | T |
| Valley 84 Gallup 57 | 2003-04 | T |
| Valley 56 Gallup 43 | 2003-04 | H |
| Valley 68 Gallup 64 | 2004-05 | H |
| Valley 63 Gallup 43 | 2004-05 | T |
| Valley 67 Gallup 41 | 2004-05 | DT-T |
| Valley 46 Gallup 44 | 2006-07 | T |
| Valley 69 Gallup 65 | 2008-09 | T |
| Valley 63 Gallup 55 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gallup 56 Valley 47 | 2010-11 | H |
| Valley 71 Gallup 66 | 2011-12 | T |
| Valley 63 Gallup 42 | 2022-23 | S-H |
| Albuquerque West Mesa | 25-36 | |
| West Mesa 51 Gallup 46 | 1966-67 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Gallup 51 | 1967-68 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 61 | 1968-69 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 38 | 1969-70 | T |
| Gallup 54 West Mesa 53 | 1973-74 | T |
| Gallup 67 West Mesa 62 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 70 West Mesa 68 | 1974-75 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Gallup 62 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 46 | 1974-75 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 78 Gallup 68 | 1975-76 | H |
| Gallup 59 West Mesa 58 | 1975-76 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Gallup 40 | 1976-77 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Gallup 58 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Gallup 68 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Gallup 61 | 1977-78 | H |
| West Mesa 59 Gallup 57 | 1977-78 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 77 Gallup 61 | 1978-79 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Gallup 57 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Gallup 58 | 1978-79 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 79 Gallup 71 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Gallup 58 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 73 Gallup 64 | 1980-81 | H |
| Gallup 55 West Mesa 53 | 1980-81 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Gallup 54 | 1981-82 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Gallup 57 | 1981-82 | H |
| Gallup 70 West Mesa 66 | 1982-83 | H |
| Gallup 63 West Mesa 57 | 1982-83 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Gallup 35 | 1983-84 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Gallup 43 | 1984-85 | T |
| Gallup 51 West Mesa 48 | 1996-97 | H |
| West Mesa 82 Gallup 48 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Gallup 55 | 1998-99 | T |
| Gallup 68 West Mesa 63 | 99-2000 | T |
| West Mesa 64 Gallup 31 | 2000-01 | T |
| Gallup 33 West Mesa 32 | 2000-01 | H |
| West Mesa 54 Gallup 45 | 2001-02 | H |
| West Mesa 75 Gallup 46 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gallup 50 West Mesa 45 | 2002-03 | T |
| Gallup 55 West Mesa 50 | 2002-03 | H |
| West Mesa 53 Gallup 44 | 2002-03 | DT-H |
| Gallup 71 West Mesa 65 | 2003-04 | H |
| Gallup 55 West Mesa 51 | 2003-04 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Gallup 59 | 2004-05 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Gallup 56 | 2004-05 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 64 | 2005-06 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Gallup 59 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 81 West Mesa 57 | 2005-06 | H |
| Gallup 72 West Mesa 62 | 2005-06 | DT-H |
| Gallup 70 West Mesa 67 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 78 West Mesa 54 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gallup 58 West Mesa 53 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 72 West Mesa 61 | 2006-07 | DT-H |
| Gallup 81 West Mesa 67 | 2007-08 | H |
| West Mesa 84 Gallup 76 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Gallup 61 | 2007-08 | H |
| Gallup 90 West Mesa 73 | 2007-08 | DT-H |
| Gallup 67 West Mesa 54 | 2008-09 | T |
| Gallup 66 West Mesa 61 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 66 West Mesa 61 | 2008-09 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Gallup 61 | 2009-10 | T |
| West Mesa 58 Gallup 53 | 2009-10 | H |
| Altus (OK) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 65 Altus 58 | 1972-73 | Hobbs |
| Anthony Gadsden | 0-2 | |
| Gadsden 61 Gallup 48 | 1964-65 | T |
| Gadsden 55 Gallup 49 | 1965-66 | T |
| Gadsden 72 Gallup 70 | 2004-05 | Moriarty |
| Arlington (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Arlington 64 Gallup 61 | 2003-04 | Moriarty |
| Artesia | 4-3 | |
| Gallup 65 Artesia 52 | 2013-14 | Gallup |
| Artesia 63 Gallup 40 | 2016-17 | Artesia |
| Gallup 61 Artesia 45 | 2016-17 | Gallup |
| Gallup 51 Artesia 49 | 2017-18 | Artesia |
| Artesia 76 Gallup 68 | 2018-19 | Artesia |
| Artesia 66 Gallup 56 | 2020-21 | S-Ruidoso |
| Gallup 65 Artesia 52 | 2021-22 | Hobbs |
| Aztec | 35-8 | |
| Gallup 51 Aztec 32 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 57 Aztec 55 | 1955-56 | T |
| Aztec 54 Gallup 53 | 1957-58 | T |
| Aztec 50 Gallup 48 | 1958-59 | H |
| Gallup 60 Aztec 30 | 1959-60 | T |
| Gallup 44 Aztec 25 | 1960-61 | H |
| Gallup 81 Aztec 65 | 1961-62 | T |
| Gallup 56 Aztec 47 | 1961-62 | Gallup |
| Aztec 46 Gallup 45 | 1962-63 | H |
| Gallup 56 Aztec 40 | 1962-63 | Gallup |
| Gallup 63 Aztec 43 | 1963-64 | Gallup |
| Gallup 46 Aztec 40 | 1964-65 | T |
| Gallup 73 Aztec 59 | 1965-66 | H |
| Gallup 87 Aztec 56 | 1966-67 | T |
| Gallup 75 Aztec 47 | 1967-68 | T |
| Aztec 88 Gallup 67 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 105 Aztec 74 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 106 Aztec 57 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 104 Aztec 52 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 83 Aztec 63 | 1979-80 | H |
| Aztec 58 Gallup 56 | 1980-81 | T |
| Gallup 59 Aztec 54 | 1981-82 | H |
| Gallup 59 Aztec 51 | 1982-83 | T |
| Gallup 75 Aztec 52 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 72 Aztec 60 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 79 Aztec 35 | 2015-16 | T |
| Gallup 90 Aztec 73 | 2015-16 | H |
| Gallup 73 Aztec 65 | 2016-17 | H |
| Gallup 77 Aztec 75 | 2016-17 | T |
| Aztec 57 Gallup 56 | 2016-17 | DT-H |
| Gallup 86 Aztec 49 | 2017-18 | H |
| Aztec 59 Gallup 56 | 2017-18 | T |
| Gallup 68 Aztec 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 70 Aztec 32 | 2018-19 | T |
| Gallup 84 Aztec 63 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 75 Aztec 45 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 72 Aztec 46 | 2020-21 | H |
| Gallup 91 Aztec 44 | 2021-22 | T |
| Gallup 83 Aztec 36 | 2021-22 | H |
| Gallup 85 Aztec 44 | 2022-23 | H |
| Gallup 84 Aztec 36 | 2022-23 | T |
| Gallup 86 Aztec 66 | 2023-24 | T |
| Gallup 79 Aztec 56 | 2023-24 | H |
| Bayard Cobre | 10-8 | |
| Gallup 69 Cobre 47 | 1965-66 | Gallup |
| Cobre 79 Gallup 72 | 1965-66 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cobre 80 Gallup 75 | 1966-67 | H |
| Gallup 78 Cobre 58 | 1967-68 | Gallup |
| Cobre 54 Gallup 48 | 1969-70 | Gallup |
| Cobre 56 Gallup 52 | 1970-71 | Gallup |
| Gallup 83 Cobre 62 | 1971-72 | Gallup |
| Gallup 77 Cobre 56 | 1973-74 | Gallup |
| Cobre 66 Gallup 44 | 1975-76 | Gallup |
| Gallup 51 Cobre 46 | 1976-77 | Gallup |
| Cobre 76 Gallup 63 | 1979-80 | Gallup |
| Gallup 70 Cobre 56 | 1980-81 | Gallup |
| Cobre 53 Gallup 48 | 1983-84 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Cobre 39 | 1984-85 | Gallup |
| Cobre 79 Gallup 65 | 1986-87 | Gallup |
| Gallup 91 Cobre 45 | 1989-90 | Gallup |
| Gallup 86 Cobre 84 | 1990-91 | Gallup |
| Gallup 81 Cobre 70 | 1991-92 | Gallup |
| Belen | 41-23 | |
| Gallup 59 Belen 42 | 1953-54 | H |
| Belen 45 Gallup 43 | 1954-55 | Gallup |
| Gallup 52 Belen 41 | 1954-55 | T |
| Gallup 68 Belen 42 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 45 Belen 32 | 1956-57 | Gallup |
| Belen 43 Gallup 41 | 1956-57 | |
| Belen 52 Gallup 39 | 1957-58 | Gallup |
| Gallup defeated Belen | 1957-58 | H |
| Belen 47 Gallup 43 | 1958-59 | Gallup |
| Belen 48 Gallup 46 | 1958-59 | T |
| Belen 61 Gallup 48 | 1958-59 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 43 Belen 40 | 1959-60 | H |
| Belen 52 Gallup 38 | 1959-60 | T |
| Gallup 51 Belen 43 | 1960-61 | T |
| Belen 57 Gallup 48 | 1960-61 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 58 Belen 57 | 1961-62 | H |
| Gallup 70 Belen 42 | 1961-62 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Belen 70 Gallup 50 | 1962-63 | T |
| Gallup 38 Belen 33 | 1963-64 | H |
| Belen 41 Gallup 40 | 1963-64 | T |
| Gallup 50 Belen 48 | 1964-65 | T |
| Gallup 78 Belen 55 | 1964-65 | H |
| Gallup 74 Belen 28 | 1965-66 | H |
| Gallup 73 Belen 62 | 1965-66 | T |
| Gallup 71 Belen 51 | 1969-70 | H |
| Belen 57 Gallup 47 | 1970-71 | T |
| Gallup 67 Belen 58 | 1971-72 | Gallup |
| Gallup 75 Belen 44 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 94 Belen 47 | 1972-73 | Gallup |
| Gallup 63 Belen 56 | 1983-84 | H |
| Belen 78 Gallup 53 | 1984-85 | H |
| Gallup 73 Belen 63 | 1984-85 | Gallup |
| Gallup 42 Belen 41 | 1985-86 | H |
| Gallup 51 Belen 50 | 1985-86 | T |
| Belen 80 Gallup 66 | 1986-87 | Gallup |
| Belen 42 Gallup 40 | 1987-88 | Gallup |
| Belen 84 Gallup 60 | 1988-89 | Gallup |
| Gallup 98 Belen 68 | 1992-93 | H |
| Gallup 42 Belen 41 | 1993-94 | T |
| Gallup 58 Belen 57 | 1993-94 | Gallup |
| Belen 60 Gallup 57 | 1994-95 | H |
| Gallup 51 Belen 46 | 1994-95 | Gallup |
| Belen 64 Gallup 61 | 1995-96 | T |
| Gallup 50 Belen 48 | 1996-97 | H |
| Belen 72 Gallup 58 | 1998-99 | Gallup |
| Gallup 66 Belen 44 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 74 Belen 31 | 2010-11 | T |
| Gallup 73 Belen 31 | 2011-12 | H |
| Gallup 73 Belen 60 | 2011-12 | T |
| Belen 69 Gallup 68 | 2012-13 | T |
| Gallup 74 Belen 54 | 2012-13 | H |
| Belen 66 Gallup 63 | 2012-13 | DT-T |
| Gallup 81 Belen 73 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 67 Belen 60 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 72 Belen 69 | 2014-15 | S-H |
| Gallup 46 Belen 33 | 2015-16 | S-H |
| Belen 53 Gallup 47 | 2016-17 | T |
| Belen 58 Gallup 45 | 2017-18 | H |
| Gallup 58 Belen 51 | 2018-19 | T |
| Gallup 50 Belen 46 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 73 Belen 63 | 2021-22 | H |
| Belen 41 Gallup 36 | 2021-22 | S-T |
| Gallup 54 Belen 49 | 2022-23 | T |
| Gallup 77 Belen 66 | 2023-24 | H |
| Bernalillo | 13-5 | |
| Bernalillo 58 Gallup 42 | 1964-65 | T |
| Gallup 70 Bernalillo 69 | 1965-66 | H |
| Gallup 77 Bernalillo 68 | 1965-66 | DT-Gallup |
| Gallup 60 Bernalillo 58 | 1966-67 | H |
| Gallup 69 Bernalillo 62 | 1967-68 | Gallup |
| Bernalillo 70 Gallup 67 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| Bernalillo 85 Gallup 63 | 1973-74 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 72 Bernalillo 71 | 1974-75 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 87 Bernalillo 73 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gallup 75 Bernalillo 66 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 76 Bernalillo 58 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 66 Bernalillo 55 | 2015-16 | T |
| Gallup 71 Bernalillo 62 | 2018-19 | S-H |
| Gallup 54 Bernalillo 53 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 70 Bernalillo 67 | 2020-21 | S-H |
| Bernalillo 58 Gallup 57 | 2021-22 | T |
| Gallup 93 Bernalillo 72 | 2022-23 | H |
| Bernalillo 74 Gallup 58 | 2023-24 | T |
| Blanding San Juan (UT) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 58 San Juan 53 | 2009-10 | Farmington |
| Bloomfield | 28-5 | |
| Gallup 128 Bloomfield 76 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 69 Bloomfield 40 | 1974-75 | H |
| Gallup 71 Bloomfield 67 | 1988-89 | T |
| Gallup 72 Bloomfield 59 | 1989-90 | H |
| Gallup 66 Bloomfield 64 | 1990-91 | T |
| Gallup 78 Bloomfield 68 | 1991-92 | H |
| Bloomfield 65 Gallup 63 | 1992-93 | Gallup |
| Gallup 62 Bloomfield 52 | 1993-94 | H |
| Gallup 58 Bloomfield 46 | 1994-95 | T |
| Gallup 99 Bloomfield 81 | 1995-96 | H |
| Bloomfield 57 Gallup 49 | 1996-97 | T |
| Gallup 63 Bloomfield 47 | 1997-98 | H |
| Gallup 82 Bloomfield 65 | 2001-02 | H |
| Gallup 57 Bloomfield 52 | 2016-17 | Grants |
| Bloomfield 74 Gallup 68 | 2016-17 | T |
| Gallup 50 Bloomfield 40 | 2016-17 | H |
| Gallup 60 Bloomfield 48 | 2017-18 | Roswell |
| Gallup 60 Bloomfield 45 | 2017-18 | H |
| Gallup 54 Bloomfield 44 | 2017-18 | T |
| Gallup 68 Bloomfield 47 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 79 Bloomfield 61 | 2018-19 | T |
| Gallup 83 Bloomfield 70 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 66 Bloomfield 54 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 94 Bloomfield 83 | 2020-21 | T |
| Gallup 73 Bloomfield 63 | 2020-21 | H |
| Gallup 64 Bloomfield 58 | 2021-22 | H |
| Gallup 71 Bloomfield 55 | 2021-22 | T |
| Gallup 61 Bloomfield 44 | 2022-23 | T |
| Gallup 67 Bloomfield 53 | 2022-23 | H |
| Gallup 68 Bloomfield 63 | 2022-23 | DT-H |
| Gallup 67 Bloomfield 59 | 2023-24 | H |
| Bloomfield 65 Gallup 62 | 2023-24 | T |
| Bloomfield 51 Gallup 44 | 2023-24 | DT-H |
| Blueridge (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 74 Blueridge 58 | 1979-80 | Holbrook |
| Carlsbad | 5-3 | |
| Carlsbad 65 Gallup 46 | 1953-54 | T |
| Carlsbad 61 Gallup 56 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 65 Carlsbad 63 | 1971-72 | S-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 73 Carlsbad 50 | 1976-77 | Roswell |
| Gallup 64 Carlsbad 59 | 2006-07 | Gallup |
| Carlsbad 65 Gallup 34 | 2016-17 | Artesia |
| Gallup 59 Carlsbad 38 | 2017-18 | Artesia |
| Gallup 66 Carlsbad 63 | 2018-19 | Artesia |
| Chaparral | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 90 Chaparral 56 | 2019-20 | S-H |
| Chinle (AZ) | 1-4 | |
| Chinle 62 Gallup 50 | 1969-70 | H |
| Chinle 58 Gallup 54 | 1970-71 | T |
| Gallup 104 Chinle 50 | 1971-72 | H |
| Chinle 70 Gallup 39 | 2021-22 | T |
| Chinle 89 Gallup 82 | 2022-23 | H |
| Clinton (OK) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 66 Clinton 43 | 2014-15 | T |
| Clovis | 1-1 | |
| Gallup 62 Clovis 57 | 2008-09 | Gallup |
| Clovis 64 Gallup 53 | 2018-19 | Gallup |
| Cortez (CO) | 6-4 | |
| Gallup 66 Cortez 43 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 41 Cortez 36 | 1956-57 | Gallup |
| Cortez 44 Gallup 43 | 1958-59 | T |
| Gallup 86 Cortez 56 | 1968-69 | H |
| Gallup 80 Cortez 77 | 1969-70 | T |
| Cortez 71 Gallup 64 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 79 Cortez 61 | 1971-72 | T |
| Cortez 55 Gallup 40 | 1985-86 | T |
| Gallup 45 Cortez 41 | 1986-87 | H |
| Cortez 81 Gallup 58 | 2002-03 | Cortez |
| Delta (CO) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 86 Delta 53 | 2002-03 | Cortez |
| Deming | 8-7 | |
| Gallup 44 Deming 38 | 1964-65 | Gallup |
| Gallup 70 Deming 61 | 1965-66 | Gallup |
| Gallup 107 Deming 73 | 1968-69 | Gallup |
| Deming 98 Gallup 82 | 1971-72 | Gallup |
| Deming 65 Gallup 61 | 1982-83 | Gallup |
| Deming 65 Gallup 59 | 1983-84 | Gallup |
| Deming 42 Gallup 40 | 1985-86 | Gallup |
| Deming 67 Gallup 66 | 1990-91 | Gallup |
| Gallup 60 Deming 50 | 1991-92 | Gallup |
| Gallup 48 Deming 35 | 1992-93 | Gallup |
| Deming 77 Gallup 69 | 1995-96 | Gallup |
| Gallup 72 Deming 52 | 1996-97 | Gallup |
| Deming 75 Gallup 63 | 99-2000 | Gallup |
| Gallup 89 Deming 75 | 2008-09 | Gallup |
| Gallup 49 Deming 29 | 2023-24 | Artesia |
| Denver Mullen (CO) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 64 Mullen 58 | 2008-09 | Farmington |
| Durango (CO) | 15-10 | |
| Durango defeated Gallup | 1953-54 | |
| Gallup 63 Durango 47 | 1954-55 | T |
| Gallup 57 Durango 50 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 44 Durango 36 | 1956-57 | T |
| Durango 56 Gallup 38 | 1957-58 | H |
| Durango 55 Gallup 50 | 1958-59 | H |
| Gallup 45 Durango 41 | 1959-60 | H |
| Gallup 65 Durango 49 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 53 Durango 44 | 1961-62 | H |
| Gallup 50 Durango 44 | 1963-64 | H |
| Gallup 65 Durango 63 | 1964-65 | T |
| Gallup 75 Durango 64 | 1965-66 | H |
| Gallup 60 Durango 54 | 1967-68 | H |
| Durango 60 Gallup 52 | 1983-84 | T |
| Gallup 52 Durango 51 | 1984-85 | H |
| Durango 50 Gallup 48 | 1985-86 | T |
| Gallup 37 Durango 36 | 1986-87 | H |
| Durango 55 Gallup 54 | 1987-88 | T |
| Gallup 74 Durango 61 | 1988-89 | H |
| Gallup 73 Durango 62 | 1989-90 | T |
| Durango defeated Gallup | 1990-91 | H |
| Durango 87 Gallup 64 | 1991-92 | T |
| Durango 62 Gallup 47 | 2006-07 | Farmington |
| Gallup 64 Durango 62 | 2021-22 | Farmington |
| Gallup 57 Durango 39 | 2022-23 | Farmington |
| Eagar Round Valley (AZ) | 1-1 | |
| Gallup 64 Round Valley 60 | 1955-56 | Gallup |
| Round Valley 74 Gallup 65 | 1979-80 | Holbrook |
| El Paso Austin (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 66 Austin 56 | 2006-07 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Burges (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Burges 56 Gallup 55 | 1976-77 | Roswell |
| El Paso Cathedral (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Cathedral 59 Gallup 56 | 2023-24 | Gallup |
| El Paso Hanks (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Hanks 58 Gallup 45 | 99-2000 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Horizon (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 56 Horizon 35 | 2007-08 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Irvin (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 65 Irvin 54 | 99-2000 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Jefferson (TX) | 1-2 | |
| Jefferson 61 Gallup 52 | 1978-79 | Roswell |
| Jefferson 50 Gallup 46 | 2005-06 | Alamogordo |
| Gallup 55 Jefferson 48 | 2006-07 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Montwood (TX) | 0-5 | |
| Montwood 65 Gallup 49 | 2006-07 | Farmington |
| Montwood 55 Gallup 45 | 2008-09 | Farmington |
| Montwood 55 Gallup 27 | 2011-12 | Farmington |
| Montwood 60 Gallup 45 | 2012-13 | Farmington |
| Montwood 63 Gallup 56 | 2021-22 | Hobbs |
| El Paso Socorro (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Socorro 77 Gallup 50 | 1998-99 | Alamogordo |
| Espanola | 37-40 | |
| Espanola 53 Gallup 45 | 1963-64 | H |
| Espanola 78 Gallup 46 | 1964-65 | T |
| Espanola 73 Gallup 66 | 1965-66 | H |
| Espanola 71 Gallup 53 | 1966-67 | T |
| Espanola 63 Gallup 58 | 1967-68 | T |
| Gallup 90 Espanola 78 | 1968-69 | T |
| Gallup 97 Espanola 81 | 1968-69 | H |
| Espanola 72 Gallup 65 | 1969-70 | H |
| Gallup 68 Espanola 49 | 1969-70 | T |
| Espanola 63 Gallup 57 | 1969-70 | DT-H |
| Gallup 66 Espanola 62 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 77 Espanola 76 | 1974-75 | T |
| Gallup 94 Espanola 67 | 1974-75 | H |
| Gallup 75 Espanola 73 | 1974-75 | DT-H |
| Espanola 66 Gallup 50 | 1975-76 | H |
| Gallup 77 Espanola 73 | 1975-76 | T |
| Espanola 49 Gallup 45 | 1976-77 | T |
| Gallup 59 Espanola 39 | 1976-77 | H |
| Gallup 69 Espanola 65 | 1977-78 | T |
| Gallup 90 Espanola 82 | 1977-78 | H |
| Espanola 68 Gallup 60 | 1978-79 | H |
| Espanola 77 Gallup 62 | 1978-79 | T |
| Espanola 61 Gallup 59 | 1979-80 | H |
| Espanola 72 Gallup 57 | 1979-80 | T |
| Espanola 58 Gallup 54 | 1979-80 | DT-T |
| Gallup 67 Espanola 65 | 1980-81 | T |
| Gallup 64 Espanola 59 | 1980-81 | H |
| Gallup 81 Espanola 51 | 1980-81 | DT-H |
| Gallup 85 Espanola 63 | 1981-82 | H |
| Espanola 72 Gallup 70 | 1981-82 | T |
| Gallup 76 Espanola 67 | 1982-83 | T |
| Gallup 60 Espanola 48 | 1982-83 | H |
| Espanola 64 Gallup 56 | 1983-84 | T |
| Gallup 46 Espanola 44 | 1983-84 | H |
| Gallup 62 Espanola 53 | 1984-85 | T |
| Espanola 55 Gallup 51 | 1984-85 | H |
| Gallup 55 Espanola 51 | 1984-85 | DT-H |
| Gallup 62 Espanola 58 | 1985-86 | T |
| Espanola 69 Gallup 66 | 1985-86 | H |
| Gallup 55 Espanola 51 | 1986-87 | T |
| Gallup 65 Espanola 59 | 1986-87 | H |
| Espanola 62 Gallup 41 | 1987-88 | T |
| Espanola 55 Gallup 48 | 1987-88 | H |
| Espanola 46 Gallup 43 | 1987-88 | DT-T |
| Gallup 69 Espanola 54 | 1988-89 | H |
| Gallup 45 Espanola 44 | 1988-89 | T |
| Espanola 79 Gallup 62 | 1989-90 | T |
| Gallup 77 Espanola 68 | 1989-90 | H |
| Espanola 75 Gallup 70 | 1990-91 | H |
| Espanola 71 Gallup 42 | 1990-91 | T |
| Espanola 50 Gallup 42 | 1991-92 | T |
| Espanola 65 Gallup 59 | 1991-92 | H |
| Gallup 48 Espanola 47 | 1992-93 | T |
| Gallup 60 Espanola 35 | 1992-93 | H |
| Gallup 55 Espanola 42 | 1993-94 | H |
| Espanola 74 Gallup 63 | 1993-94 | T |
| Espanola 53 Gallup 33 | 1994-95 | T |
| Espanola 60 Gallup 58 | 1994-95 | H |
| Espanola 66 Gallup 49 | 1995-96 | H |
| Espanola 72 Gallup 46 | 1995-96 | T |
| Espanola 82 Gallup 64 | 1995-96 | DT-T |
| Gallup 59 Espanola 45 | 2002-03 | Gallup |
| Gallup 54 Espanola 47 | 2003-04 | Gallup |
| Gallup 63 Espanola 57 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 72 Espanola 62 | 2007-08 | H |
| Espanola 66 Gallup 58 | 2008-09 | T |
| Espanola 72 Gallup 60 | 2009-10 | H |
| Espanola 69 Gallup 57 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 69 Espanola 55 | 2013-14 | S-H |
| Espanola 58 Gallup 56 | 2014-15 | T |
| Espanola 62 Gallup 49 | 2015-16 | H |
| Espanola 66 Gallup 60 | 2016-17 | T |
| Espanola 80 Gallup 48 | 2017-18 | H |
| Espanola 78 Gallup 77 | 2018-19 | T |
| Espanola 70 Gallup 63 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 70 Espanola 64 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 72 Espanola 47 | 2019-20 | S-Albuquerque |
| Fabens (TX) | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 67 Fabens 63 | 2012-13 | Farmington |
| Gallup 75 Fabens 51 | 2013-14 | Farmington |
| Farmington | 49-91 | |
| Gallup 49 Farmington 33 | 1953-54 | T |
| Gallup 30 Farmington 28 | 1953-54 | Gallup |
| Gallup 46 Farmington 33 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 57 Farmington 40 | 1953-54 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 68 Farmington 52 | 1954-55 | H |
| Farmington 61 Gallup 59 | 1954-55 | T |
| Gallup 77 Farmington 64 | 1954-55 | DT-H |
| Farmington 75 Gallup 68 | 1955-56 | Gallup |
| Farmington 94 Gallup 77 | 1955-56 | T |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 49 | 1955-56 | H |
| Farmington 53 Gallup 44 | 1956-57 | Gallup |
| Gallup 46 Farmington 39 | 1956-57 | H |
| Farmington 81 Gallup 64 | 1956-57 | T |
| Farmington 52 Gallup 45 | 1957-58 | Gallup |
| Farmington 55 Gallup 46 | 1957-58 | T |
| Farmington 64 Gallup 45 | 1957-58 | H |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 44 | 1958-59 | Gallup |
| Farmington 64 Gallup 30 | 1958-59 | T |
| Farmington 65 Gallup 48 | 1959-60 | H |
| Farmington 70 Gallup 54 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 49 Farmington 42 | 1961-62 | H |
| Gallup 58 Farmington 47 | 1962-63 | T |
| Farmington 67 Gallup 39 | 1963-64 | H |
| Farmington 53 Gallup 40 | 1963-64 | T |
| Farmington 51 Gallup 41 | 1964-65 | T |
| Farmington 68 Gallup 65 | 1965-66 | H |
| Farmington 79 Gallup 61 | 1966-67 | T |
| Farmington 74 Gallup 69 | 1967-68 | T |
| Gallup 81 Farmington 80 | 1968-69 | H |
| Gallup 98 Farmington 95 | 1968-69 | T |
| Farmington 91 Gallup 77 | 1968-69 | DT-Los Alamos |
| Farmington 107 Gallup 84 | 1969-70 | T |
| Farmington 106 Gallup 88 | 1969-70 | H |
| Farmington 90 Gallup 58 | 1970-71 | T |
| Farmington 99 Gallup 80 | 1970-71 | H |
| Farmington 87 Gallup 79 | 1970-71 | DT-Santa Fe |
| Gallup 79 Farmington 74 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 72 Farmington 70 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 65 Farmington 60 | 1971-72 | DT-H |
| Gallup 66 Farmington 60 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 72 Farmington 66 | 1972-73 | H |
| Farmington 77 Gallup 68 | 1972-73 | DT-H |
| Farmington 60 Gallup 58 | 1973-74 | T |
| Gallup 78 Farmington 65 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 64 Farmington 62 | 1973-74 | DT-H |
| Farmington 60 Gallup 56 | 1974-75 | H |
| Gallup 61 Farmington 56 | 1974-75 | T |
| Farmington 65 Gallup 53 | 1975-76 | T |
| Farmington 60 Gallup 56 | 1975-76 | H |
| Farmington 51 Gallup 47 | 1975-76 | DT-T |
| Gallup 62 Farmington 53 | 1976-77 | H |
| Gallup 60 Farmington 59 | 1976-77 | T |
| Farmington 67 Gallup 55 | 1976-77 | DT-H |
| Gallup 59 Farmington 56 | 1977-78 | T |
| Farmington 63 Gallup 57 | 1977-78 | H |
| Gallup 64 Farmington 63 | 1978-79 | T |
| Farmington 39 Gallup 38 | 1978-79 | H |
| Gallup 69 Farmington 56 | 1979-80 | T |
| Gallup 69 Farmington 53 | 1979-80 | H |
| Gallup 63 Farmington 52 | 1980-81 | H |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 50 | 1980-81 | T |
| Farmington 50 Gallup 43 | 1980-81 | DT-T |
| Farmington 91 Gallup 65 | 1981-82 | Gallup |
| Farmington 112 Gallup 48 | 1981-82 | T |
| Farmington 80 Gallup 55 | 1981-82 | H |
| Farmington 47 Gallup 43 | 1982-83 | H |
| Farmington 47 Gallup 43 | 1982-83 | T |
| Farmington 46 Gallup 45 | 1982-83 | DT-T |
| Gallup 49 Farmington 47 | 1983-84 | H |
| Farmington 90 Gallup 69 | 1983-84 | T |
| Farmington 100 Gallup 59 | 1984-85 | T |
| Farmington 79 Gallup 58 | 1984-85 | H |
| Farmington 101 Gallup 48 | 1984-85 | DT-T |
| Farmington 72 Gallup 60 | 1985-86 | H |
| Farmington 107 Gallup 60 | 1985-86 | T |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 42 | 1986-87 | T |
| Farmington 80 Gallup 53 | 1986-87 | H |
| Farmington 89 Gallup 46 | 1987-88 | H |
| Farmington 78 Gallup 56 | 1987-88 | T |
| Farmington 61 Gallup 50 | 1988-89 | T |
| Farmington 71 Gallup 33 | 1988-89 | H |
| Farmington 78 Gallup 63 | 1989-90 | T |
| Gallup 73 Farmington 69 | 1989-90 | H |
| Farmington 65 Gallup 42 | 1989-90 | DT-H |
| Farmington 77 Gallup 73 | 1990-91 | T |
| Farmington 79 Gallup 60 | 1990-91 | H |
| Farmington 64 Gallup 55 | 1991-92 | H |
| Farmington 60 Gallup 47 | 1991-92 | T |
| Farmington 49 Gallup 38 | 1991-92 | DT-T |
| Farmington 82 Gallup 67 | 1992-93 | H |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 41 | 1992-93 | T |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 44 | 1993-94 | T |
| Gallup 72 Farmington 56 | 1993-94 | H |
| Farmington 67 Gallup 58 | 1994-95 | H |
| Farmington 73 Gallup 48 | 1994-95 | T |
| Farmington 56 Gallup 49 | 1994-95 | DT-T |
| Farmington 88 Gallup 41 | 1995-96 | T |
| Farmington 47 Gallup 38 | 1995-96 | H |
| Farmington 62 Gallup 50 | 1996-97 | T |
| Farmington 44 Gallup 39 | 1996-97 | H |
| Farmington 67 Gallup 50 | 1996-97 | DT-T |
| Farmington 77 Gallup 39 | 1997-98 | H |
| Farmington 65 Gallup 48 | 1997-98 | T |
| Farmington 72 Gallup 37 | 1998-99 | H |
| Farmington 86 Gallup 50 | 1998-99 | T |
| Farmington 77 Gallup 57 | 99-2000 | T |
| Farmington 77 Gallup 66 | 99-2000 | H |
| Farmington 70 Gallup 63 | 99-2000 | DT-T |
| Farmington 61 Gallup 32 | 2000-01 | T |
| Farmington 70 Gallup 37 | 2001-02 | H |
| Farmington 61 Gallup 47 | 2002-03 | T |
| Gallup 66 Farmington 35 | 2003-04 | H |
| Farmington 71 Gallup 58 | 2004-05 | T |
| Gallup 66 Farmington 63 | 2004-05 | T |
| Farmington 63 Gallup 58 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 71 Farmington 58 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gallup 60 Farmington 41 | 2007-08 | Farmington |
| Gallup 60 Farmington 42 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 63 Farmington 41 | 2009-10 | H |
| Gallup 100 Farmington 65 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 81 Farmington 59 | 2010-11 | Gallup |
| Gallup 78 Farmington 65 | 2011-12 | H |
| Gallup 60 Farmington 51 | 2011-12 | S-H |
| Gallup 57 Farmington 54 | 2012-13 | T |
| Gallup 49 Farmington 43 | 2012-13 | Farmington |
| Gallup 53 Farmington 47 | 2012-13 | Gallup |
| Gallup 71 Farmington 53 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 50 Farmington 36 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 57 Farmington 52 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 62 Farmington 48 | 2014-15 | DT-H |
| Gallup 61 Farmington 59 | 2014-15 | S-Albuquerque |
| Farmington 56 Gallup 43 | 2015-16 | H |
| Farmington 55 Gallup 51 | 2015-16 | T |
| Farmington 54 Gallup 50 | 2015-16 | DT-T |
| Farmington 61 Gallup 50 | 2016-17 | T |
| Farmington 61 Gallup 49 | 2016-17 | H |
| Gallup 61 Farmington 47 | 2017-18 | H |
| Gallup 41 Farmington 36 | 2017-18 | T |
| Farmington 72 Gallup 55 | 2021-22 | Farmington |
| Farmington 74 Gallup 64 | 2022-23 | Gallup |
| Farmington Navajo Mission | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 69 Mission 57 | 1954-55 | T |
| Farmington Navajo Prep | 2-1 | |
| Gallup 75 Navajo Prep 54 | 2019-20 | Gallup |
| Navajo Prep 58 Gallup 48 | 2021-22 | Farmington |
| Gallup 54 Navajo Prep 48 | 2022-23 | Gallup |
| Farmington Piedra Vista | 17-4 | |
| Gallup 83 Piedra Vista 61 | 2001-02 | H |
| Gallup 75 Piedra Vista 55 | 2002-03 | T |
| Gallup 73 Piedra Vista 48 | 2004-05 | T |
| Gallup 65 Piedra Vista 39 | 2005-06 | H |
| Gallup 77 Piedra Vista 61 | 2007-08 | Farmington |
| Gallup 101 Piedra Vista 75 | 2009-10 | Farmington |
| Gallup 75 Piedra Vista 66 | 2012-13 | H |
| Piedra Vista 73 Gallup 65 | 2013-14 | Farmington |
| Piedra Vista 68 Gallup 59 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 75 Piedra Vista 50 | 2014-15 | Grants |
| Gallup 58 Piedra Vista 51 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 60 Piedra Vista 49 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 51 Piedra Vista 42 | 2015-16 | Grants |
| Gallup 71 Piedra Vista 52 | 2015-16 | H |
| Gallup 63 Piedra Vista 54 | 2015-16 | T |
| Gallup 61 Piedra Vista 49 | 2015-16 | DT-H |
| Piedra Vista 65 Gallup 64 | 2016-17 | H |
| Piedra Vista 92 Gallup 74 | 2017-18 | T |
| Gallup 69 Piedra Vista 28 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 74 Piedra Vista 67 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 52 Piedra Vista 50 | 2023-24 | Gallup |
| Flagstaff Coconino (AZ) | 0-1 | |
| Coconino 67 Gallup 60 | 1975-76 | Holbrook |
| Fort Defiance Window Rock (AZ) | 34-15 | |
| Window Rock 87 Gallup 81 | 1969-70 | T |
| Window Rock 49 Gallup 43 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 121 Window Rock 63 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 48 Window Rock 47 | 1973-74 | T |
| Gallup 62 Window Rock 59 | 1974-75 | H |
| Window Rock 54 Gallup 50 | 1975-76 | T |
| Gallup 48 Window Rock 32 | 1976-77 | T |
| Window Rock 57 Gallup 53 | 1977-78 | T |
| Window Rock 64 Gallup 54 | 1978-79 | H |
| Gallup 52 Window Rock 51 | 1980-81 | H |
| Window Rock 85 Gallup 59 | 1981-82 | T |
| Gallup 77 Window Rock 54 | 1982-83 | H |
| Window Rock 58 Gallup 48 | 1983-84 | T |
| Window Rock 53 Gallup 39 | 1984-85 | H |
| Gallup 64 Window Rock 41 | 1986-87 | T |
| Gallup 57 Window Rock 51 | 1987-88 | H |
| Window Rock 76 Gallup 68 | 1988-89 | Gallup |
| Gallup 80 Window Rock 75 | 1988-89 | T |
| Window Rock 78 Gallup 76 | 1989-90 | H |
| Window Rock 90 Gallup 55 | 1990-91 | T |
| Window Rock 68 Gallup 66 | 1991-92 | H |
| Window Rock 55 Gallup 52 | 1992-93 | T |
| Gallup 68 Window Rock 50 | 1993-94 | Gallup |
| Gallup 65 Window Rock 63 | 1993-94 | H |
| Gallup 67 Window Rock 65 | 1994-95 | T |
| Gallup 93 Window Rock 89 | 1995-96 | H |
| Gallup 85 Window Rock 82 | 1996-97 | T |
| Gallup 58 Window Rock 54 | 1997-98 | H |
| Gallup 45 Window Rock 43 | 1997-98 | Gallup |
| Window Rock 64 Gallup 62 | 1998-99 | Gallup |
| Gallup 77 Window Rock 65 | 99-2000 | Gallup |
| Gallup 55 Window Rock 44 | 2000-01 | H |
| Gallup 81 Window Rock 58 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gallup 68 Window Rock 39 | 2002-03 | H |
| Gallup 72 Window Rock 47 | 2002-03 | Gallup |
| Gallup 77 Window Rock 72 | 2003-04 | T |
| Gallup 67 Window Rock 66 | 2005-06 | T |
| Window Rock 74 Gallup 68 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 79 Window Rock 69 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gallup 68 Window Rock 52 | 2007-08 | Gallup |
| Gallup 71 Window Rock 55 | 2008-09 | Gallup |
| Gallup 66 Window Rock 32 | 2009-10 | Gallup |
| Gallup 77 Window Rock 75 | 2010-11 | Gallup |
| Gallup 81 Window Rock 40 | 2014-15 | Grants |
| Gallup 68 Window Rock 45 | 2017-18 | Gallup |
| Gallup 64 Window Rock 42 | 2018-19 | Gallup |
| Gallup 75 Window Rock 60 | 2021-22 | Gallup |
| Gallup 62 Window Rock 34 | 2022-23 | Farmington |
| Gallup 61 Window Rock 58 | 2023-24 | T |
| Fort Sumner | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 49 Fort Sumner 33 | 1960-61 | Gallup |
| Gallup 78 Fort Sumner 52 | 2018-19 | Roswell |
| Fort Wingate | 35-10 | |
| Gallup 50 Wingate 34 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 43 Wingate 42 | 1953-54 | T |
| Gallup 62 Wingate 40 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 73 Wingate 45 | 1954-55 | T |
| Gallup 74 Wingate 53 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup defeated Wingate | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 46 Wingate 45 | 1956-57 | H |
| Wingate 53 Gallup 51 | 1956-57 | T |
| Gallup 54 Wingate 40 | 1957-58 | H |
| Gallup 48 Wingate 41 | 1957-58 | T |
| Gallup 49 Wingate 47 | 1958-59 | H |
| Wingate 61 Gallup 52 | 1958-59 | T |
| Gallup 59 Wingate 49 | 1958-59 | Gallup |
| Gallup defeated Wingate | 1959-60 | H |
| Gallup 45 Wingate 42 | 1959-60 | T |
| Gallup 57 Wingate 47 | 1959-60 | Gallup |
| Gallup 51 Wingate 38 | 1960-61 | H |
| Gallup 56 Wingate 48 | 1960-61 | Gallup |
| Wingate 54 Gallup 46 | 1961-62 | T |
| Gallup 58 Wingate 43 | 1962-63 | H |
| Gallup 46 Wingate 38 | 1963-64 | T |
| Wingate 63 Gallup 49 | 1964-65 | H |
| Wingate 65 Gallup 55 | 1964-65 | Gallup |
| Gallup 74 Wingate 73 | 1965-66 | H |
| Wingate 78 Gallup 68 | 1966-67 | T |
| Wingate 85 Gallup 51 | 1966-67 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Wingate 64 | 1967-68 | H |
| Wingate 85 Gallup 78 | 1968-69 | T |
| Gallup 97 Wingate 89 | 1968-69 | H |
| Wingate 67 Gallup 62 | 1969-70 | H |
| Wingate 74 Gallup 49 | 1969-70 | Gallup |
| Gallup 73 Wingate 66 | 1969-70 | T |
| Wingate 59 Gallup 55 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 69 Wingate 67 | 1970-71 | T |
| Gallup 86 Wingate 54 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 85 Wingate 53 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 110 Wingate 56 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 91 Wingate 39 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 76 Wingate 46 | 1978-79 | Gallup |
| Gallup 69 Wingate 51 | 1986-87 | Gallup |
| Gallup 79 Wingate 66 | 1989-90 | Gallup |
| Gallup 91 Wingate 58 | 1994-95 | Gallup |
| Gallup 61 Wingate 53 | 1995-96 | Gallup |
| Gallup 77 Wingate 72 | 1998-99 | Gallup |
| Gallup 58 Wingate 46 | 99-2000 | Gallup |
| Gallup Cathedral | 16-4 | |
| Gallup 36 CathedraL 26 | 1953-54 | T |
| Gallup 53 Cathedral 29 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 40 Cathedral 36 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 53 Cathedral 51 | 1954-55 | Gallup |
| Gallup 73 Cathedral 65 | 1955-56 | H |
| Cathedral 57 Gallup 41 | 1956-57 | H |
| Cathedral 54 Gallup 44 | 1956-57 | T |
| Gallup 52 Cathedral 32 | 1957-58 | H |
| Gallup 28 Cathedral 25 | 1958-59 | H |
| Cathedral 52 Gallup 30 | 1959-60 | T |
| Cathedral 54 Gallup 34 | 1959-60 | H |
| Gallup 67 Cathedral 33 | 1960-61 | H |
| Gallup 53 Cathedral 42 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 44 Cathedral 40 | 1961-62 | H |
| Gallup 53 Cathedral 32 | 1961-62 | T |
| Gallup 50 Cathedral 45 | 1962-63 | H |
| Gallup 48 Cathedral 39 | 1963-64 | H |
| Gallup 65 Cathedral 38 | 1964-65 | H |
| Gallup 74 Cathedral 61 | 1966-67 | H |
| Gallup 68 Cathedral 45 | 1967-68 | H |
| Gallup Miyamura | 33-3 | |
| Gallup 84 Miyamura 42 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 79 Miyamura 52 | 2010-11 | T |
| Gallup 65 Miyamura 50 | 2011-12 | H |
| Gallup 49 Miyamura 43 | 2011-12 | T |
| Gallup 72 Miyamura 46 | 2012-13 | T |
| Gallup 65 Miyamura 50 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gallup 69 Miyamura 64 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 33 Miyamura 32 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 92 Miyamura 68 | 2014-15 | H |
| Gallup 80 Miyamura 54 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 57 Miyamura 44 | 2015-16 | H |
| Gallup 74 Miyamura 42 | 2015-16 | T |
| Gallup 69 Miyamura 42 | 2016-17 | Gallup |
| Gallup 63 Miyamura 52 | 2016-17 | H |
| Gallup 71 Miyamura 51 | 2016-17 | T |
| Gallup 57 Miyamura 35 | 2017-18 | T |
| Gallup 63 Miyamura 50 | 2017-18 | H |
| Gallup 41 Miyamura 38 | 2017-18 | DT-T |
| Gallup 80 Miyamura 53 | 2018-19 | Gallup |
| Gallup 64 Miyamura 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 79 Miyamura 52 | 2018-19 | T |
| Miyamura 68 Gallup 63 | 2018-19 | DT-H |
| Gallup 76 Miyamura 46 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 56 Miyamura 51 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 72 Miyamura 39 | 2019-20 | DT-H |
| Gallup 69 Miyamura 49 | 2020-21 | H |
| Gallup 69 Miyamura 45 | 2020-21 | T |
| Miyamura 54 Gallup 51 | 2021-22 | Gallup |
| Miyamura 62 Gallup 60 | 2021-22 | T |
| Gallup 73 Miyamura 52 | 2021-22 | H |
| Gallup 62 Miyamura 56 | 2021-22 | DT-H |
| Gallup 71 Miyamura 47 | 2022-23 | H |
| Gallup 87 Miyamura 55 | 2022-23 | T |
| Gallup 74 Miyamura 32 | 2022-23 | DT-H |
| Gallup 71 Miyamura 55 | 2023-24 | T |
| Gallup 56 Miyamura 52 | 2023-24 | H |
| Ganado (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 75 Ganado 26 | 2011-12 | Farmington |
| Grants | 74-48 | |
| Gallup 58 Grants 30 | 1953-54 | T |
| Gallup 49 Grants 44 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 54 Grants 48 | 1955-56 | T |
| Gallup 60 Grants 45 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 35 Grants 33 | 1956-57 | |
| Grants 48 Gallup 47 | 1957-58 | T |
| Gallup 55 Grants 34 | 1957-58 | H |
| Grants 42 Gallup 33 | 1958-59 | T |
| Grants 73 Gallup 62 | 1959-60 | H |
| Grants 49 Gallup 39 | 1959-60 | T |
| Gallup 61 Grants 37 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 57 Grants 56 | 1960-61 | H |
| Grants 60 Gallup 47 | 1961-62 | H |
| Gallup 67 Grants 60 | 1961-62 | T |
| Grants 60 Gallup 47 | 1962-63 | T |
| Gallup 42 Grants 32 | 1962-63 | Gallup |
| Grants 56 Gallup 52 | 1962-63 | H |
| Gallup 70 Grants 39 | 1963-64 | H |
| Grants 43 Gallup 34 | 1964-65 | T |
| Grants 44 Gallup 43 | 1964-65 | H |
| Gallup 61 Grants 54 | 1965-66 | H |
| Grants 67 Gallup 52 | 1965-66 | T |
| Gallup 55 Grants 50 | 1965-66 | DT-Gallup |
| Gallup 71 Grants 40 | 1966-67 | H |
| Gallup 76 Grants 61 | 1967-68 | H |
| Gallup 69 Grants 56 | 1968-69 | T |
| Grants 85 Gallup 64 | 1969-70 | H |
| Gallup 54 Grants 44 | 1970-71 | H |
| Grants 91 Gallup 41 | 1970-71 | T |
| Gallup 90 Grants 69 | 1971-72 | T |
| Grants 53 Gallup 48 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 59 Grants 54 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 65 Grants 44 | 1972-73 | Gallup |
| Gallup 76 Grants 68 | 1973-74 | T |
| Gallup 64 Grants 60 | 1974-75 | H |
| Gallup 61 Grants 48 | 1974-75 | Gallup |
| Grants 68 Gallup 61 | 1975-76 | T |
| Gallup 45 Grants 35 | 1976-77 | H |
| Gallup 53 Grants 24 | 1976-77 | T |
| Grants 64 Gallup 62 | 1977-78 | H |
| Gallup 77 Grants 68 | 1977-78 | T |
| Gallup 79 Grants 64 | 1977-78 | DT-H |
| Gallup 64 Grants 48 | 1978-79 | T |
| Gallup 52 Grants 48 | 1978-79 | H |
| Gallup 84 Grants 35 | 1979-80 | T |
| Gallup 79 Grants 74 | 1979-80 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Grants 65 | 1979-80 | H |
| Gallup 66 Grants 54 | 1980-81 | H |
| Gallup 69 Grants 68 | 1980-81 | T |
| Gallup 56 Grants 54 | 1981-82 | T |
| Gallup 51 Grants 44 | 1981-82 | H |
| Gallup 75 Grants 73 | 1982-83 | H |
| Gallup 67 Grants 55 | 1982-83 | T |
| Gallup 70 Grants 62 | 1982-83 | DT-H |
| Grants 62 Gallup 47 | 1983-84 | T |
| Grants 69 Gallup 41 | 1983-84 | H |
| Grants 57 Gallup 55 | 1984-85 | H |
| Grants 48 Gallup 43 | 1984-85 | T |
| Grants 48 Gallup 38 | 1985-86 | H |
| Grants 69 Gallup 55 | 1985-86 | T |
| Grants 64 Gallup 52 | 1986-87 | T |
| Grants defeated Gallup | 1986-87 | H |
| Grants defeated Gallup | 1987-88 | T |
| Grants 71 Gallup 60 | 1987-88 | H |
| Grants 60 Gallup 42 | 1987-88 | Gallup |
| Grants 57 Gallup 51 | 1988-89 | H |
| Grants 53 Gallup 51 | 1989-90 | T |
| Gallup 64 Grants 49 | 1989-90 | Gallup |
| Grants 82 Gallup 66 | 1990-91 | H |
| Gallup 66 Grants 59 | 1991-92 | T |
| Grants 69 Gallup 64 | 1991-92 | H |
| Gallup 63 Grants 60 | 1992-93 | H |
| Gallup 57 Grants 46 | 1992-93 | Gallup |
| Grants 60 Gallup 57 | 1992-93 | T |
| Gallup 74 Grants 55 | 1993-94 | T |
| Grants 75 Gallup 59 | 1994-95 | T |
| Grants 69 Gallup 65 | 1994-95 | Gallup |
| Gallup 56 Grants 53 | 1994-95 | H |
| Grants 88 Gallup 67 | 1995-96 | H |
| Grants 93 Gallup 73 | 1995-96 | T |
| Grants 81 Gallup 48 | 1996-97 | T |
| Grants 64 Gallup 44 | 1996-97 | Gallup |
| Gallup 76 Grants 65 | 1996-97 | H |
| Grants 55 Gallup 40 | 1997-98 | H |
| Gallup 45 Grants 37 | 1997-98 | Gallup |
| Grants 59 Gallup 49 | 1997-98 | T |
| Grants 49 Gallup 44 | 1998-99 | T |
| Grants 43 Gallup 34 | 99-2000 | H |
| Gallup 51 Grants 39 | 2000-01 | T |
| Grants 36 Gallup 31 | 2000-01 | Gallup |
| Gallup 51 Grants 48 | 2001-02 | H |
| Gallup 64 Grants 52 | 2002-03 | T |
| Grants 58 Gallup 48 | 2003-04 | H |
| Gallup 54 Grants 45 | 2004-05 | T |
| Grants 61 Gallup 48 | 2004-05 | Gallup |
| Gallup 70 Grants 64 | 2005-06 | H |
| Gallup 61 Grants 56 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 72 Grants 37 | 2007-08 | H |
| Gallup 78 Grants 50 | 2008-09 | T |
| Gallup 56 Grants 48 | 2009-10 | H |
| Gallup 71 Grants 60 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 64 Grants 54 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 65 Grants 57 | 2010-11 | DT-H |
| Gallup 61 Grants 55 | 2011-12 | Gallup |
| Grants 66 Gallup 63 | 2011-12 | H |
| Gallup 67 Grants 62 | 2011-12 | T |
| Grants 62 Gallup 47 | 2011-12 | DT-H |
| Gallup 61 Grants 44 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gallup 68 Grants 38 | 2012-13 | T |
| Gallup 74 Grants 66 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 78 Grants 76 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 78 Grants 72 | 2013-14 | DT-H |
| Gallup 62 Grants 54 | 2014-15 | Grants |
| Gallup 70 Grants 63 | 2014-15 | Gallup |
| Gallup 69 Grants 63 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 70 Grants 36 | 2014-15 | S-Albuquerque |
| Grants 62 Gallup 58 | 2015-16 | Grants |
| Gallup 78 Grants 72 | 2015-16 | Gallup |
| Grants 59 Gallup 39 | 2015-16 | S-Albuquerque |
| Grants 67 Gallup 54 | 2016-17 | Grants |
| Gallup 72 Grants 44 | 2020-21 | H |
| Gallup 77 Grants 64 | 2022-23 | T |
| Hatch | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 66 Hatch 16 | 2022-23 | Gallup |
| Hereford (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 68 Hereford 55 | 2014-15 | T |
| Hobbs | 1-3 | |
| Gallup 80 Hobbs 73 | 1971-72 | S-Albuquerque |
| Hobbs 81 Gallup 62 | 1972-73 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 64 Gallup 59 | 2006-07 | S-Albuquerque |
| Hobbs 109 Gallup 73 | 2019-20 | Gallup |
| Holbrook (AZ) | 14-12 | |
| Holbrook 47 Gallup 40 | 1953-54 | T |
| Gallup 55 Holbrook 44 | 1953-54 | Gallup |
| Holbrook 78 Gallup 62 | 1964-65 | T |
| Holbrook 84 Gallup 78 | 1965-66 | H |
| Holbrook 55 Gallup 46 | 1966-67 | T |
| Gallup 79 Holbrook 59 | 1966-67 | Gallup |
| Gallup 54 Holbrook 53 | 1967-68 | H |
| Gallup 72 Holbrook 63 | 1968-69 | Gallup |
| Holbrook 83 Gallup 82 | 1968-69 | T |
| Holbrook 80 Gallup 62 | 1969-70 | H |
| Holbrook 68 Gallup 46 | 1970-71 | Gallup |
| Holbrook 91 Gallup 53 | 1970-71 | T |
| Gallup 80 Holbrook 63 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 79 Holbrook 47 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 81 Holbrook 53 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 64 Holbrook 60 | 1975-76 | H |
| Holbrook 62 Gallup 58 | 1976-77 | T |
| Gallup 69 Holbrook 54 | 1977-78 | H |
| Gallup 76 Holbrook 53 | 1978-79 | T |
| Gallup 76 Holbrook 50 | 1979-80 | H |
| Holbrook 68 Gallup 60 | 1979-80 | Holbrook |
| Gallup 67 Holbrook 57 | 1980-81 | T |
| Holbrook 49 Gallup 44 | 1987-88 | H |
| Holbrook 87 Gallup 82 | 1988-89 | T |
| Gallup 66 Holbrook 62 | 1989-90 | T |
| Holbrook 77 Gallup 67 | 1990-91 | T |
| Ignacio (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Ignacio 69 Gallup 58 | 2009-10 | Farmington |
| Kirtland Central | 58-17 | |
| Gallup 53 Central 27 | 1953-54 | Gallup |
| Gallup 58 Central 35 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 57 Central 49 | 1954-55 | Gallup |
| Gallup 59 Central 46 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 76 Central 53 | 1955-56 | T |
| Central 58 Gallup 53 | 1957-58 | T |
| Central 51 Gallup 48 | 1958-59 | H |
| Gallup 49 Central 30 | 1959-60 | Gallup |
| Gallup 59 Central 57 | 1959-60 | T |
| Gallup 55 Central 34 | 1960-61 | Gallup |
| Gallup 50 Central 43 | 1960-61 | H |
| Gallup 64 Central 50 | 1961-62 | T |
| Gallup 45 Central 31 | 1962-63 | H |
| Central 61 Gallup 48 | 1969-70 | T |
| Gallup 52 Central 48 | 1983-84 | H |
| Central 56 Gallup 32 | 1984-85 | T |
| Gallup 59 Central 45 | 1985-86 | T |
| Gallup 55 Central 46 | 1986-87 | T |
| Gallup 63 Central 36 | 1987-88 | H |
| Gallup 67 Central 56 | 1988-89 | T |
| Gallup 81 Central 49 | 1989-90 | H |
| Gallup 74 Central 66 | 1990-91 | T |
| Gallup 74 Central 53 | 1991-92 | H |
| Central 61 Gallup 57 | 1992-93 | T |
| Gallup 69 Central 53 | 1993-94 | H |
| Gallup 63 Central 51 | 1994-95 | T |
| Central 81 Gallup 71 | 1995-96 | H |
| Central 75 Gallup 71 | 1996-97 | T |
| Gallup 48 Central 47 | 1997-98 | H |
| Central 58 Gallup 41 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gallup 75 Central 71 | 2001-02 | Gallup |
| Gallup 61 Central 57 | 2002-03 | H |
| Gallup 78 Central 72 | 2002-03 | Gallup |
| Gallup 49 Central 47 | 2003-04 | T |
| Gallup 47 Central 46 | 2003-04 | H |
| Gallup 64 Central 55 | 2004-05 | H |
| Gallup 75 Central 63 | 2004-05 | Gallup |
| Central 81 Gallup 62 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 69 Central 49 | 2005-06 | Gallup |
| Gallup 61 Central 43 | 2007-08 | H |
| Gallup 83 Central 33 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 74 Central 48 | 2009-10 | H |
| Gallup 73 Central 49 | 2010-11 | H |
| Gallup 59 Central 56 | 2010-11 | S-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 85 Central 62 | 2011-12 | H |
| Gallup 63 Central 55 | 2011-12 | Gallup |
| Gallup 53 Central 41 | 2011-12 | S-Albuquerque |
| Central 54 Gallup 53 | 2012-13 | T |
| Gallup 82 Central 69 | 2013-14 | Farmington |
| Central 80 Gallup 66 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 86 Central 59 | 2014-15 | T |
| Gallup 68 Central 48 | 2014-15 | Gallup |
| Gallup 61 Central 57 | 2015-16 | H |
| Central 59 Gallup 55 | 2016-17 | T |
| Central 67 Gallup 61 | 2016-17 | H |
| Gallup 59 Central 52 | 2017-18 | H |
| Central 55 Gallup 54 | 2017-18 | T |
| Central 52 Gallup 46 | 2017-18 | TB-Shiprock |
| Gallup 52 Central 51 | 2017-18 | DT-T |
| Gallup 85 Central 41 | 2018-19 | T |
| Gallup 88 Central 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 90 Central 51 | 2018-19 | DT-H |
| Gallup 95 Central 59 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 64 Central 54 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 60 Central 41 | 2019-20 | DT-H |
| Central 60 Gallup 56 | 2020-21 | T |
| Gallup 78 Central 52 | 2020-21 | H |
| Gallup 84 Central 55 | 2021-22 | H |
| Gallup 66 Central 50 | 2021-22 | T |
| Gallup 76 Central 58 | 2021-22 | DT-H |
| Gallup 73 Central 60 | 2022-23 | T |
| Gallup 88 Central 71 | 2022-23 | H |
| Gallup 74 Central 71 | 2023-24 | H |
| Central 53 Gallup 49 | 2023-24 | T |
| Gallup 66 Central 49 | 2023-24 | DT-H |
| Las Cruces | 0-1 | |
| Las Cruces 77 Gallup 74 | 2008-09 | S-Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces Centennial | 0-1 | |
| Centennial 52 Gallup 38 | 2014-15 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces Mayfield | 0-3 | |
| Mayfield 64 Gallup 35 | 2005-06 | S-T |
| Mayfield 62 Gallup 56 | 2007-08 | S-Albuquerque |
| Mayfield 69 Gallup 53 | 2009-10 | S-Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces Onate | 0-1 | |
| Onate 63 Gallup 61 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Las Vegas Rancho (NV) | 0-1 | |
| Rancho 85 Gallup 61 | 2022-23 | Page |
| Las Vegas Spring Valley (NV) | 0-1 | |
| Spring Valley 82 Gallup 70 | 2019-20 | Gallup |
| West Las Vegas | 3-0 | |
| Gallup 49 West 43 | 1957-58 | H |
| Gallup 77 West 76 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 80 West 48 | 2006-07 | Gallup |
| Laveen Fairfax (AZ) | 1-1 | |
| Gallup 55 Fairfax 43 | 2009-10 | Rio Rancho |
| Fairfax 72 Gallup 50 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Los Alamos | 22-40 | |
| Gallup defeated Los Alamos | 1953-54 | T |
| Los Alamos 52 Gallup 44 | 1953-54 | S-Hobbs |
| Los Alamos 75 Gallup 56 | 1967-68 | T |
| Los Alamos 79 Gallup 68 | 1968-69 | T |
| Los Alamos 82 Gallup 81 | 1968-69 | T |
| Los Alamos 54 Gallup 49 | 1969-70 | H |
| Los Alamos 76 Gallup 59 | 1969-70 | T |
| Los Alamos 109 Gallup 52 | 1970-71 | T |
| Los Alamos 88 Gallup 56 | 1970-71 | H |
| Los Alamos 78 Gallup 61 | 1971-72 | T |
| Los Alamos 73 Gallup 66 | 1971-72 | H |
| Los Alamos 89 Gallup 63 | 1971-72 | DT-T |
| Gallup 74 Los Alamos 66 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 93 Los Alamos 62 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 57 Los Alamos 50 | 1973-74 | H |
| Los Alamos 57 Gallup 56 | 1973-74 | T |
| Los Alamos 78 Gallup 74 | 1973-74 | DT-T |
| Los Alamos 77 Gallup 66 | 1974-75 | T |
| Los Alamos 62 Gallup 61 | 1974-75 | H |
| Los Alamos 86 Gallup 64 | 1975-76 | H |
| Los Alamos 62 Gallup 50 | 1975-76 | T |
| Los Alamos 72 Gallup 68 | 1976-77 | T |
| Gallup 64 Los Alamos 62 | 1976-77 | H |
| Gallup 74 Los Alamos 69 | 1977-78 | T |
| Gallup 73 Los Alamos 66 | 1977-78 | H |
| Gallup 52 Los Alamos 51 | 1978-79 | H |
| Los Alamos 66 Gallup 52 | 1978-79 | T |
| Los Alamos 73 Gallup 71 | 1979-80 | T |
| Los Alamos 100 Gallup 67 | 1979-80 | H |
| Gallup 70 Los Alamos 66 | 1980-81 | H |
| Los Alamos 59 Gallup 57 | 1980-81 | T |
| Gallup 90 Los Alamos 69 | 1980-81 | DT-H |
| Los Alamos 75 Gallup 55 | 1981-82 | T |
| Los Alamos 67 Gallup 63 | 1981-82 | T |
| Los Alamos 79 Gallup 58 | 1982-83 | H |
| Los Alamos 69 Gallup 47 | 1982-83 | T |
| Los Alamos 68 Gallup 41 | 1983-84 | H |
| Los Alamos 78 Gallup 60 | 1983-84 | T |
| Los Alamos 72 Gallup 71 | 1984-85 | T |
| Gallup 62 Los Alamos 42 | 1984-85 | H |
| Gallup 49 Los Alamos 45 | 1984-85 | DT-T |
| Gallup 60 Los Alamos 52 | 1985-86 | H |
| Los Alamos 70 Gallup 54 | 1985-86 | T |
| Los Alamos 63 Gallup 57 | 1985-86 | DT-T |
| Los Alamos 49 Gallup 40 | 1986-87 | T |
| Gallup 44 Los Alamos 35 | 1986-87 | H |
| Gallup 58 Los Alamos 50 | 1986-87 | DT-H |
| Los Alamos 67 Gallup 34 | 1987-88 | H |
| Los Alamos 56 Gallup 52 | 1987-88 | T |
| Los Alamos 54 Gallup 50 | 1988-89 | T |
| Gallup 70 Los Alamos 59 | 1988-89 | H |
| Gallup 64 Los Alamos 58 | 1988-89 | DT-H |
| Gallup 53 Los Alamos 50 | 1989-90 | H |
| Gallup 86 Los Alamos 66 | 1989-90 | T |
| Los Alamos 63 Gallup 61 | 1990-91 | T |
| Los Alamos 64 Gallup 62 | 1990-91 | H |
| Los Alamos 86 Gallup 62 | 1991-92 | H |
| Los Alamos 72 Gallup 64 | 1991-92 | T |
| Gallup 72 Los Alamos 70 | 1991-92 | DT-T |
| Los Alamos 68 Gallup 58 | 1997-98 | H |
| Gallup 73 Los Alamos 70 | 2003-04 | Gallup |
| Gallup 57 Los Alamos 51 | 2017-18 | Roswell |
| Los Lunas | 30-20 | |
| Gallup 48 Los Lunas 36 | 1955-56 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup defeated Los Lunas | 1956-57 | T |
| Gallup 54 Los Lunas 39 | 1956-57 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Gallup 49 Los Lunas 41 | 1957-58 | H |
| Gallup 51 Los Lunas 47 | 1958-59 | T |
| Los Lunas 52 Gallup 48 | 1959-60 | H |
| Gallup 49 Los Lunas 47 | 1960-61 | T |
| Gallup 45 Los Lunas 31 | 1961-62 | T |
| Gallup 70 Los Lunas 52 | 1962-63 | T |
| Los Lunas 41 Gallup 38 | 1963-64 | T |
| Gallup 56 Los Lunas 29 | 1964-65 | H |
| Gallup 68 Los Lunas 64 | 1965-66 | T |
| Gallup 78 Los Lunas 47 | 1988-89 | Gallup |
| Gallup 82 Los Lunas 68 | 1990-91 | T |
| Gallup 58 Los Lunas 50 | 1990-91 | Gallup |
| Gallup 60 Los Lunas 43 | 1991-92 | T |
| Gallup 77 Los Lunas 55 | 1991-92 | Gallup |
| Gallup 76 Los Lunas 63 | 1992-93 | H |
| Los Lunas 60 Gallup 55 | 1993-94 | T |
| Gallup 70 Los Lunas 60 | 1994-95 | H |
| Gallup 70 Los Lunas 68 | 1995-96 | T |
| Los Lunas 64 Gallup 55 | 1996-97 | H |
| Los Lunas 60 Gallup 46 | 1997-98 | T |
| Los Lunas 68 Gallup 62 | 99-2000 | T |
| Los Lunas 68 Gallup 43 | 2000-01 | H |
| Los Lunas 43 Gallup 37 | 2000-01 | Gallup |
| Los Lunas 62 Gallup 59 | 2001-02 | T |
| Los Lunas 75 Gallup 69 | 2004-05 | T |
| Gallup 75 Los Lunas 71 | 2005-06 | H |
| Gallup 56 Los Lunas 55 | 2006-07 | Gallup |
| Los Lunas 62 Gallup 58 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 59 Los Lunas 58 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gallup 51 Los Lunas 46 | 2007-08 | Gallup |
| Gallup 73 Los Lunas 62 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 71 Los Lunas 58 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gallup 62 Los Lunas 59 | 2010-11 | T |
| Gallup 57 Los Lunas 54 | 2010-11 | T |
| Gallup 50 Los Lunas 48 | 2011-12 | T |
| Gallup 51 Los Lunas 50 | 2011-12 | H |
| Los Lunas 79 Gallup 68 | 2012-13 | H |
| Los Lunas 59 Gallup 56 | 2012-13 | T |
| Los Lunas 85 Gallup 67 | 2013-14 | T |
| Los Lunas 70 Gallup 68 | 2013-14 | H |
| Los Lunas 87 Gallup 70 | 2013-14 | DT-T |
| Los Lunas 54 Gallup 49 | 2016-17 | T |
| Gallup 50 Los Lunas 38 | 2017-18 | H |
| Los Lunas 55 Gallup 44 | 2018-19 | Artesia |
| Gallup 67 Los Lunas 61 | 2018-19 | H |
| Los Lunas 63 Gallup 55 | 2019-20 | T |
| Los Lunas 75 Gallup 30 | 2023-24 | Artesia |
| Los Lunas Valencia | 7-2 | |
| Gallup 61 Valencia 49 | 2010-11 | H |
| Valencia 74 Gallup 69 | 2010-11 | T |
| Gallup 66 Valencia 58 | 2011-12 | T |
| Gallup 57 Valencia 44 | 2011-12 | H |
| Gallup 49 Valencia 35 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gallup 54 Valencia 27 | 2012-13 | T |
| Gallup 68 Valencia 56 | 2013-14 | T |
| Gallup 82 Valencia 54 | 2013-14 | H |
| Valencia 66 Gallup 58 | 2023-24 | H |
| Lovington | 1-2 | |
| Lovington 73 Gallup 67 | 2017-18 | Roswell |
| Gallup 78 Lovington 64 | 2019-20 | T |
| Lovington 85 Gallup 53 | 2023-24 | Artesia |
| Moriarty | 9-0 | |
| Gallup 68 Moriarty 46 | 1992-93 | Gallup |
| Gallup 65 Moriarty 47 | 1993-94 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Moriarty 56 | 1995-96 | Gallup |
| Gallup 63 Moriarty 53 | 1996-97 | Gallup |
| Gallup 50 Moriarty 38 | 1997-98 | Gallup |
| Gallup 64 Moriarty 51 | 2000-01 | Gallup |
| Gallup 87 Moriarty 70 | 2004-05 | Moriarty |
| Gallup 72 Moriarty 53 | 2004-05 | Gallup |
| Gallup 76 Moriarty 31 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Odessa (TX) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 63 Odessa 60 | 1972-73 | Hobbs |
| Page (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 76 Page 62 | 2022-23 | Page |
| Payson (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 63 Payson 55 | 2022-23 | Page |
| Pojoaque | 4-4 | |
| Pojoaque 66 Gallup 60 | 2013-14 | Gallup |
| Gallup 50 Pojoaque 39 | 2015-16 | Artesia |
| Gallup 72 Pojoaque 30 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 65 Pojoaque 61 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 91 Pojoaque 80 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Pojoaque 61 Gallup 59 | 2021-22 | H |
| Pojoaque 76 Gallup 68 | 2022-23 | T |
| Pojoaque 66 Gallup 44 | 2023-24 | H |
| Portales | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 46 Portales 38 | 1962-63 | H |
| Gallup 83 Portales 75 | 2023-24 | H |
| Ramah | 1-1 | |
| Ramah 74 Gallup 67 | 99-2000 | H |
| Gallup 72 Ramah 49 | 2010-11 | H |
| Reheboth Mission | 4-1 | |
| Gallup 56 Mission 32 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 82 Mission 32 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup 59 Mission 31 | 1954-55 | H |
| Gallup 73 Mission 61 | 2021-22 | H |
| Mission 63 Gallup 45 | 2023-24 | Gallup |
| Ringgold (LA) | 1-1 | |
| Gallup 59 Ringgold 53 | 1955-56 | H |
| Ringgold 43 Gallup 36 | 1959-60 | H |
| Rio Rancho | 16-27 | |
| Rio Rancho 52 Gallup 50 | 1998-99 | H |
| Rio Rancho 64 Gallup 63 | 99-2000 | T |
| Rio Rancho 52 Gallup 27 | 2000-01 | T |
| Rio Rancho 55 Gallup 49 | 2000-01 | H |
| Gallup 91 Rio Rancho 87 | 2001-02 | H |
| Rio Rancho 54 Gallup 52 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gallup 77 Rio Rancho 68 | 2002-03 | T |
| Gallup 66 Rio Rancho 52 | 2002-03 | H |
| Rio Rancho 79 Gallup 77 | 2003-04 | H |
| Rio Rancho 95 Gallup 80 | 2003-04 | T |
| Rio Rancho 59 Gallup 52 | 2003-04 | DT-T |
| Rio Rancho 81 Gallup 66 | 2004-05 | T |
| Rio Rancho 84 Gallup 59 | 2004-05 | H |
| Rio Rancho 80 Gallup 61 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 70 Rio Rancho 67 | 2005-06 | H |
| Rio Rancho 66 Gallup 63 | 2005-06 | T |
| Rio Rancho 86 Gallup 57 | 2006-07 | H |
| Rio Rancho 89 Gallup 70 | 2006-07 | T |
| Rio Rancho 87 Gallup 55 | 2006-07 | H |
| Rio Rancho 102 Gallup 56 | 2006-07 | DT-T |
| Rio Rancho 85 Gallup 78 | 2007-08 | H |
| Rio Rancho 88 Gallup 82 | 2007-08 | T |
| Rio Rancho 86 Gallup 69 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gallup 61 Rio Rancho 58 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 75 Rio Rancho 67 | 2008-09 | T |
| Gallup 64 Rio Rancho 50 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 84 Rio Rancho 72 | 2008-09 | DT-H |
| Gallup 74 Rio Rancho 65 | 2009-10 | Rio Rancho |
| Gallup 80 Rio Rancho 71 | 2009-10 | H |
| Gallup 72 Rio Rancho 61 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gallup 83 Rio Rancho 78 | 2009-10 | DT-H |
| Gallup 66 Rio Rancho 44 | 2010-11 | T |
| Rio Rancho 74 Gallup 67 | 2011-12 | H |
| Rio Rancho 75 Gallup 64 | 2012-13 | T |
| Rio Rancho 76 Gallup 74 | 2013-14 | H |
| Gallup 82 Rio Rancho 74 | 2014-15 | T |
| Rio Rancho 72 Gallup 63 | 2015-16 | H |
| Gallup 52 Rio Rancho 49 | 2015-16 | Artesia |
| Rio Rancho 81 Gallup 58 | 2016-17 | Artesia |
| Gallup 72 Rio Rancho 62 | 2017-18 | H |
| Rio Rancho 69 Gallup 45 | 2017-18 | Artesia |
| Rio Rancho 73 Gallup 52 | 2018-19 | T |
| Rio Rancho 68 Gallup 60 | 2019-20 | H |
| Rio Rancho Cleveland | 2-5 | |
| Gallup 76 Cleveland 68 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 72 Gallup 70 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 80 Gallup 66 | 2010-11 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 79 Gallup 68 | 2010-11 | H |
| Cleveland 69 Gallup 63 | 2011-12 | Farmington |
| Gallup 68 Cleveland 64 | 2011-12 | T |
| Cleveland 77 Gallup 41 | 2021-22 | Hobbs |
| Roswell | 1-3 | |
| Gallup 58 Roswell 51 | 1977-78 | Roswell |
| Roswell 82 Gallup 47 | 99-2000 | Alamogordo |
| Roswell 72 Gallup 57 | 2013-14 | S-Albuquerque |
| Roswell 88 Gallup 59 | 2018-19 | Roswell |
| Roswell Goddard | 7-6 | |
| Gallup 61 Goddard 50 | 1967-68 | T |
| Gallup 76 Goddard 61 | 1968-69 | H |
| Goddard 74 Gallup 69 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| Gallup 42 Goddard 40 | 1976-77 | Roswell |
| Goddard 84 Gallup 78 | 1977-78 | Roswell |
| Goddard 56 Gallup 51 | 1978-79 | Roswell |
| Goddard 94 Gallup 76 | 1980-81 | Gallup |
| Gallup 73 Goddard 52 | 1981-82 | Gallup |
| Goddard 81 Gallup 55 | 1998-99 | Alamogordo |
| Goddard 72 Gallup 54 | 2010-11 | S-Albuquerque |
| Goddard 55 Gallup 51 | 2015-16 | Artesia |
| Gallup 69 Goddard 67 | 2016-17 | Artesia |
| Gallup 74 Goddard 59 | 2018-19 | Roswell |
| Roswell NMMI | 3-2 | |
| NMMI 59 Gallup 56 | 1974-75 | Gallup |
| Gallup 54 NMMI 46 | 1976-77 | Gallup |
| Gallup 58 NMMI 55 | 1977-78 | Gallup |
| NMMI 53 Gallup 51 | 1978-79 | Gallup |
| Gallup 52 NMMI 46 | 1983-84 | Gallup |
| Ruidoso | 0-1 | |
| Ruidoso 78 Gallup 56 | 2005-06 | Alamogordo |
| Santa Fe | 24-46 | |
| Santa Fe 42 Gallup 34 | 1963-64 | H |
| Santa Fe 83 Gallup 65 | 1965-66 | H |
| Santa Fe 58 Gallup 55 | 1966-67 | H |
| Santa Fe 86 Gallup 76 | 1967-68 | T |
| Gallup 58 Santa Fe 49 | 1968-69 | H |
| Gallup 78 Santa Fe 74 | 1968-69 | T |
| Santa Fe 72 Gallup 67 | 1968-69 | DT-Los Alamos |
| Santa Fe 83 Gallup 63 | 1969-70 | T |
| Santa Fe 87 Gallup 68 | 1969-70 | H |
| Santa Fe 68 Gallup 56 | 1970-71 | T |
| Santa Fe 90 Gallup 60 | 1970-71 | H |
| Gallup 62 Santa Fe 58 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 58 Santa Fe 53 | 1971-72 | T |
| Gallup 68 Santa Fe 64 | 1971-72 | DT-H |
| Gallup 93 Santa Fe 80 | 1972-73 | H |
| Gallup 88 Santa Fe 72 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 56 Santa Fe 36 | 1973-74 | H |
| Santa Fe 40 Gallup 37 | 1973-74 | T |
| Gallup 80 Santa Fe 52 | 1974-75 | T |
| Santa Fe 59 Gallup 54 | 1974-75 | H |
| Santa Fe 52 Gallup 46 | 1975-76 | H |
| Santa Fe 66 Gallup 46 | 1975-76 | T |
| Santa Fe 62 Gallup 45 | 1976-77 | T |
| Santa Fe 60 Gallup 55 | 1976-77 | H |
| Santa Fe 78 Gallup 74 | 1977-78 | T |
| Gallup 66 Santa Fe 65 | 1977-78 | H |
| Santa Fe 62 Gallup 52 | 1978-79 | H |
| Santa Fe 81 Gallup 49 | 1978-79 | T |
| Santa Fe 74 Gallup 57 | 1979-80 | T |
| Santa Fe 73 Gallup 55 | 1979-80 | H |
| Gallup 52 Santa Fe 49 | 1980-81 | H |
| Santa Fe 88 Gallup 68 | 1980-81 | T |
| Santa Fe 64 Gallup 55 | 1981-82 | T |
| Gallup 57 Santa Fe 55 | 1981-82 | H |
| Santa Fe 62 Gallup 49 | 1981-82 | DT-T |
| Gallup 46 Santa Fe 43 | 1982-83 | H |
| Santa Fe 59 Gallup 56 | 1982-83 | T |
| Santa Fe 64 Gallup 59 | 1983-84 | H |
| Santa Fe 64 Gallup 48 | 1983-84 | T |
| Santa Fe 51 Gallup 39 | 1984-85 | T |
| Gallup 59 Santa Fe 45 | 1984-85 | H |
| Santa Fe 48 Gallup 46 | 1985-86 | H |
| Santa Fe 51 Gallup 40 | 1985-86 | T |
| Santa Fe 78 Gallup 53 | 1986-87 | T |
| Gallup 66 Santa Fe 60 | 1986-87 | H |
| Santa Fe 62 Gallup 60 | 1986-87 | DT-T |
| Santa Fe 82 Gallup 73 | 1987-88 | H |
| Santa Fe 74 Gallup 48 | 1987-88 | T |
| Gallup 72 Santa Fe 66 | 1988-89 | T |
| Santa Fe 73 Gallup 70 | 1988-89 | H |
| Santa Fe 96 Gallup 62 | 1988-89 | DT-T |
| Santa Fe 92 Gallup 79 | 1989-90 | H |
| Santa Fe 68 Gallup 66 | 1989-90 | T |
| Santa Fe 82 Gallup 65 | 1990-91 | T |
| Santa Fe 68 Gallup 66 | 1990-91 | H |
| Santa Fe 75 Gallup 66 | 1990-91 | DT-T |
| Gallup 67 Santa Fe 38 | 1991-92 | H |
| Gallup 63 Santa Fe 61 | 1991-92 | T |
| Gallup 69 Santa Fe 64 | 1991-92 | DT-T |
| Gallup 62 Santa Fe 51 | 1992-93 | T |
| Gallup 75 Santa Fe 55 | 1992-93 | H |
| Gallup 66 Santa Fe 62 | 1993-94 | H |
| Santa Fe 67 Gallup 55 | 1993-94 | T |
| Santa Fe 71 Gallup 59 | 1994-95 | T |
| Santa Fe 49 Gallup 45 | 1994-95 | H |
| Santa Fe 66 Gallup 64 | 1995-96 | H |
| Santa Fe 61 Gallup 56 | 1995-96 | T |
| Gallup 66 Santa Fe 47 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 64 Santa Fe 47 | 2008-09 | S-H |
| Santa Fe 49 Gallup 47 | 2009-10 | T |
| Santa Fe Capital | 1-3 | |
| Capital 74 Gallup 60 | 2001-02 | Gallup |
| Capital 47 Gallup 42 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 59 Capital 51 | 2005-06 | H |
| Capital 54 Gallup 38 | 2016-17 | S-T |
| Santa Fe St Michael | 1-6 | |
| Gallup 54 St Michael 50 | 1953-54 | DT-Albuquerque |
| St Michael 70 Gallup 49 | 1954-55 | T |
| St Michael 64 Gallup 51 | 1955-56 | H |
| St Michael 68 Gallup 58 | 1955-56 | DT-Albuquerque |
| St Michael 44 Gallup 40 | 1956-57 | DT-Albuquerque |
| St Michael 74 Gallup 49 | 1957-58 | H |
| St Michael 52 Gallup 49 | 1958-59 | T |
| Santa Teresa | 2-2 | |
| Gallup 76 Santa Teresa 67 | 2005-06 | Alamogordo |
| Gallup 63 Santa Teresa 39 | 2007-08 | Alamogordo |
| Santa Teresa 58 Gallup 43 | 2011-12 | SC-Albuquerque |
| Santa Teresa 57 Gallup 53 | 2012-13 | S-T |
| Saratoga Springs Westlake (UT) | 0-1 | |
| Westlake 51 Gallup 33 | 2022-23 | Farmington |
| Silver City | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 71 Silver City 34 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Shiprock | 34-5 | |
| Gallup 54 Shiprock 46 | 1968-69 | Gallup |
| Gallup 72 Shiprock 69 | 1969-70 | Gallup |
| Gallup 77 Shiprock 51 | 1970-71 | Gallup |
| Gallup 96 Shiprock 59 | 1972-73 | T |
| Gallup 80 Shiprock 45 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 65 Shiprock 59 | 1974-75 | T |
| Gallup 96 Shiprock 57 | 1975-76 | H |
| Gallup 66 Shiprock 62 | 1976-77 | H |
| Gallup 93 Shiprock 67 | 1977-78 | H |
| Gallup 101 Shiprock 81 | 1977-78 | Gallup |
| Shiprock 59 Gallup 58 | 1978-79 | T |
| Shiprock 70 Gallup 55 | 1978-79 | Gallup |
| Gallup 65 Shiprock 37 | 1979-80 | H |
| Gallup 58 Shiprock 55 | 1979-80 | T |
| Gallup 76 Shiprock 62 | 1979-80 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Shiprock 47 | 1980-81 | T |
| Gallup 64 Shiprock 55 | 1980-81 | Gallup |
| Gallup 52 Shiprock 40 | 1981-82 | H |
| Gallup 84 Shiprock 59 | 1981-82 | Gallup |
| Gallup 72 Shiprock 46 | 1982-83 | T |
| Gallup 59 Shiprock 53 | 1982-83 | Gallup |
| Shiprock 46 Gallup 45 | 1984-85 | Gallup |
| Gallup 71 Shiprock 36 | 2001-02 | Gallup |
| Gallup 52 Shiprock 49 | 2009-10 | Gallup |
| Gallup 87 Shiprock 39 | 2014-15 | Gallup |
| Gallup 74 Shiprock 34 | 2015-16 | Grants |
| Gallup 82 Shiprock 43 | 2018-19 | T |
| Gallup 80 Shiprock 50 | 2018-19 | H |
| Gallup 83 Shiprock 80 | 2019-20 | H |
| Gallup 76 Shiprock 50 | 2019-20 | T |
| Gallup 83 Shiprock 67 | 2020-21 | T |
| Gallup 81 Shiprock 69 | 2020-21 | H |
| Gallup 93 Shiprock 42 | 2021-22 | H |
| Gallup 90 Shiprock 59 | 2021-22 | T |
| Shiprock 70 Gallup 65 | 2022-23 | T |
| Gallup 99 Shiprock 54 | 2022-23 | H |
| Shiprock 71 Gallup 62 | 2023-24 | H |
| Gallup 93 Shiprock 60 | 2023-24 | T |
| Gallup 76 Shiprock 73 | 2023-24 | TB-Farmington |
| Socorro | 2-1 | |
| Gallup 68 Socorro 38 | 1964-65 | H |
| Gallup 78 Socorro 60 | 1965-66 | T |
| Socorro 74 Gallup 62 | 2021-22 | Gallup |
| St Johns (AZ) | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 44 St Johns 40 | 1955-56 | H |
| Gallup 57 St Johns 46 | 1975-76 | Holbrook |
| Taos | 4-1 | |
| Gallup defeated Taos | 1953-54 | T |
| Gallup 56 Taos 31 | 1953-54 | H |
| Gallup defeated Taos | 1954-55 | T |
| Gallup 63 Taos 60 | 2022-23 | H |
| Taos 52 Gallup 46 | 2023-24 | T |
| Thoreau | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 80 Thoreau 41 | 2016-17 | T |
| Tohatchi | 6-0 | |
| Gallup 73 Tohatchi 42 | 1982-83 | Gallup |
| Gallup 60 Tohatchi 43 | 1985-86 | Gallup |
| Gallup 57 Tohatchi 55 | 2012-13 | Gallup |
| Gallup 68 Tohatchi 51 | 2015-16 | Gallup |
| Gallup 78 Tohatchi 31 | 2016-17 | Gallup |
| Gallup 65 Tohatchi 43 | 2017-18 | Gallup |
| Tuba City (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 68 Tuba City 53 | 1975-76 | Holbrook |
| Tucumcari | 1-0 | |
| Gallup 74 Tucumcari 41 | 1987-88 | T |
| Tucson Desert View (AZ) | 0-1 | |
| Desert View defeated Gallup | 2003-04 | Moriarty |
| Tularosa | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 74 Tularosa 60 | 1974-75 | Gallup |
| Gallup 65 Tularosa 53 | 1975-76 | Gallup |
| Wagon Mound | 2-0 | |
| Gallup 55 Wagon Mound 50 | 1954-55 | Gallup |
| Gallup 36 Wagon Mound 35 | 1961-62 | Gallup |
| Winslow (AZ) | 7-6 | |
| Gallup 98 Winslow 45 | 1954-55 | Gallup |
| Gallup 35 Winslow 27 | 1955-56 | Gallup |
| Winslow 74 Gallup 51 | 1970-71 | T |
| Gallup 99 Winslow 52 | 1971-72 | H |
| Gallup 81 Winslow 68 | 1974-75 | T |
| Gallup 73 Winslow 61 | 1975-76 | H |
| Gallup 77 Winslow 61 | 1976-77 | T |
| Winslow 81 Gallup 71 | 1977-78 | T |
| Winslow 71 Gallup 55 | 1987-88 | T |
| Winslow 74 Gallup 60 | 1988-89 | H |
| Gallup 58 Winslow 57 | 1989-90 | T |
| Winslow 61 Gallup 43 | 1997-98 | T |
| Winslow 61 Gallup 43 | 1998-99 | H |
| unknown | ||
| unknown win | 1955-56 | |
| unknown win | 1956-57 | |
| unknown win | 1962-63 |