| Canutillo record vs | rec/yr | location |
| Abilene | 0-2 | |
| Abilene 65 Canutillo 54 | 2021-22 | Abilene |
| Abilene 48 Canutillo 40 | 2023-24 | Abilene |
| Abilene Cooper | 3-1 | |
| Canutillo 64 Cooper 59 | 2011-12 | Hobbs |
| Canutillo 56 Cooper 44 | 2012-13 | Hobbs |
| Cooper 56 Canutillo 36 | 2021-22 | Abilene |
| Canutillo 51 Cooper 48 | 2023-24 | Abilene |
| Abilene Wylie | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 70 Wylie 64 | 2021-22 | Abilene |
| Addison Trinity Christian | 0-1 | |
| Trinity Christian 40 Canutillo 37 | 2022-23 | San Marcos |
| Alamogordo (NM) | 0-1 | |
| Alamogordo 24 Canutillo 23 | 2013-14 | Alamogordo |
| Albuquerque Volcano Vista (NM) | 0-1 | |
| Volcano Vista 38 Canutillo 35 | 2011-12 | Hobbs |
| Aledo | 0-1 | |
| Aledo 49 Canutillo 38 | 2022-23 | Aledo |
| Amarillo | 0-3 | |
| Amarillo 40 Canutillo 39 | 2017-18 | S-Andrews |
| Amarillo 41 Canutillo 22 | 2021-22 | S-Andrews |
| Amarillo 50 Canutillo 36 | 2022-23 | S-Andrews |
| Amarillo Palo Duro | 0-3 | |
| Palo Duro 75 Canutillo 44 | 99-2000 | S-Odessa |
| Palo Duro 69 Canutillo 65 | 2014-15 | S-Seminole |
| Palo Duro 85 Canutillo 36 | 2023-24 | S-Andrews |
| Anthony | 6-1 | |
| Canutillo 64 Anthony 25 | 2011-12 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 60 Anthony 17 | 2012-13 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 61 Anthony 23 | 2013-14 | Canutillo |
| Anthony 64 Canutillo 55 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 70 Anthony 23 | 2017-18 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 64 Anthony 47 | 2017-18 | H |
| Canutillo 60 Anthony 45 | 2023-24 | Anthony |
| Anthony Gadsden (NM) | 6-8 | |
| Gadsden 57 Canutillo 47 | 1986-87 | |
| Gadsden 74 Canutillo 39 | 1991-92 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 56 Gadsden 48 | 1996-97 | T |
| Canutillo 54 Gadsden 49 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 69 Gadsden 65 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo defeated Gadsden | 99-2000 | T |
| Gadsden 49 Canutillo 48 | 2001-02 | T |
| Gadsden 54 Canutillo 44 | 2003-04 | El Paso |
| Gadsden 38 Canutillo 36 | 2003-04 | T |
| Gadsden 42 Canutillo 37 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gadsden 52 Canutillo 48 | 2010-11 | Anthony |
| Canutillo 36 Gadsden 17 | 2012-13 | H |
| Gadsden 40 Canutillo 37 | 2013-14 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 38 Gadsden 35 | 2013-14 | T |
| Aztec (NM) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 69 Aztec 39 | 2001-02 | Silver City |
| Canyon | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 47 Canyon 36 | 2014-15 | S-Seminole |
| Canyon Randall | 0-1 | |
| Randall 49 Canutillo 43 | 2009-10 | S-Seminole |
| Carlsbad (NM) | 0-2 | |
| Carlsbad 84 Canutillo 55 | 1986-87 | Carlsbad |
| Carlsbad 52 Canutillo 51 | 2013-14 | Alamogordo |
| Chandler Arizona Compass Prep (AZ) | 0-2 | |
| Compass Prep 66 Canutillo 61 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| Compass Prep 58 Canutillo 40 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| Chaparral (NM) | 2-1 | |
| Canutillo 81 Chaparral 47 | 2007-08 | Canutillo |
| Chaparral 43 Canutillo 29 | 2010-11 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 49 Chaparral 42 | 2010-11 | Canutillo |
| Ciudad Juarez Academia (MX) | 1-2 | |
| Academia 54 Canutillo 44 | 1987-88 | Clint |
| Acadamia 77 Canutillo 49 | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 47 Academia 36 | 2001-02 | Fabens |
| Ciudad Juarez Monterrey Tech (MX) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo defeated Monterrey Tech | 1991-92 | El Paso |
| Clint | 26-14 | |
| Canutillo 67 Clint 66 | 1986-87 | T |
| Clint 51 Canutillo 41 | 1987-88 | H |
| Clint 39 Canutillo 37 | 1987-88 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Clint 44 | 1988-89 | H |
| Clint 48 Canutillo 35 | 1988-89 | T |
| Clint 53 Canutillo 41 | 1989-90 | T |
| Clint 44 Canutillo 41 | 1989-90 | H |
| Clint 70 Canutillo 67 | 1990-91 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Clint 30 | 1990-91 | H |
| Canutillo 51 Clint 45 | 1992-93 | H |
| Canutillo 60 Clint 55 | 1992-93 | El Paso |
| Clint 46 Canutillo 38 | 1993-94 | H |
| Canutillo 47 Clint 42 | 1993-94 | T |
| Canutillo 44 Clint 37 | 1994-95 | H |
| Clint 42 Canutillo 39 | 1997-98 | T |
| Clint 31 Canutillo 24 | 1998-99 | H |
| Clint 48 Canutillo 34 | 1998-99 | T |
| Canutillo 61 Clint 56 | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 49 Clint 45 | 99-2000 | H |
| Canutillo 54 Clint 49 | 2000-01 | H |
| Clint 61 Canutillo 38 | 2000-01 | T |
| Clint 62 Canutillo 57 | 2001-02 | T |
| Clint 54 Canutillo 49 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 70 Clint 56 | 2003-04 | H |
| Clint 38 Canutillo 32 | 2004-05 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Clint 46 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 57 Clint 53 | 2006-07 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 49 Clint 43 | 2006-07 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Clint 27 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 61 Clint 45 | 2008-09 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 58 Clint 29 | 2009-10 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 50 Clint 21 | 2010-11 | T |
| Canutillo 39 Clint 26 | 2010-11 | Anthony |
| Canutillo 34 Clint 21 | 2011-12 | H |
| Canutillo 65 Clint 30 | 2012-13 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 56 Clint 41 | 2013-14 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 46 Clint 31 | 2014-15 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 56 Clint 33 | 2015-16 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 58 Clint 54 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 62 Clint 26 | 2022-23 | T |
| Dallas AAA Academy | 0-2 | |
| AAA Academy 62 Canutillo 45 | 2014-15 | Midland |
| AAA Academy 66 Canutillo 40 | 2015-16 | Midland |
| Deming (NM) | 0-3 | |
| Deming 89 Canutillo 61 | 1986-87 | Deming |
| Deming 74 Canutillo 58 | 1994-95 | H |
| Deming 66 Canutillo 65 | 1996-97 | Deming |
| Denver City | 0-1 | |
| Denver City 53 Canutillo 49 | 2003-04 | Monahans |
| Dumas | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 58 Dumas 47 | 2008-09 | Pampa |
| El Paso | 28-34 | |
| El Paso 60 Canutillo 26 | 1988-89 | T |
| El Paso 61 Canutillo 32 | 1988-89 | T |
| Canutillo 59 El Paso 38 | 1989-90 | H |
| El Paso 60 Canutillo 36 | 1989-90 | T |
| El Paso 68 Canutillo 56 | 1990-91 | H |
| El Paso 77 Canutillo 63 | 1990-91 | T |
| El Paso 66 Canutillo 47 | 1991-92 | T |
| El Paso 58 Canutillo 47 | 1991-92 | H |
| El Paso 65 Canutillo 50 | 1992-93 | T |
| El Paso 54 Canutillo 35 | 1992-93 | H |
| El Paso 41 Canutillo 28 | 1993-94 | H |
| El Paso 72 Canutillo 41 | 1993-94 | T |
| El Paso 58 Canutillo 38 | 1994-95 | H |
| El Paso 62 Canutillo 37 | 1994-95 | T |
| Canutillo 43 El Paso 34 | 1995-96 | El Paso |
| El Paso 60 Canutillo 45 | 1995-96 | T |
| El Paso 63 Canutillo 57 | 1995-96 | H |
| El Paso 73 Canutillo 58 | 1996-97 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 52 El Paso 48 | 1996-97 | H |
| Canutillo 58 El Paso 44 | 1996-97 | T |
| Canutillo 64 El Paso 61 | 1997-98 | T |
| Canutillo 48 El Paso 45 | 1997-98 | H |
| El Paso 56 Canutillo 41 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo 73 El Paso 60 | 99-2000 | El Paso |
| El Paso 62 Canutillo 56 | 99-2000 | H |
| El Paso 75 Canutillo 36 | 2000-01 | H |
| El Paso 64 Canutillo 42 | 2001-02 | T |
| Canutillo 60 El Paso 56 | 2001-02 | Clint |
| El Paso 68 Canutillo 54 | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| El Paso 39 Canutillo 37 | 2002-03 | T |
| El Paso 60 Canutillo 40 | 2002-03 | H |
| El Paso 44 Canutillo 42 | 2003-04 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 70 El Paso 59 | 2003-04 | H |
| El Paso 49 Canutillo 46 | 2003-04 | T |
| Canutillo defeated El Paso | 2004-05 | H |
| Canutillo defeated El Paso | 2004-05 | T |
| Canutillo 52 El Paso 47 | 2005-06 | T |
| Canutillo 53 El Paso 38 | 2005-06 | H |
| El Paso 41 Canutillo 40 | 2006-07 | H |
| Canutillo 62 El Paso 49 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 51 El Paso 30 | 2010-11 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 53 El Paso 39 | 2010-11 | H |
| Canutillo 52 El Paso 50 | 2011-12 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 51 El Paso 35 | 2011-12 | T |
| El Paso 59 Canutillo 53 | 2014-15 | H |
| Canutillo 43 El Paso 33 | 2014-15 | T |
| El Paso 51 Canutillo 48 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 49 El Paso 40 | 2015-16 | H |
| Canutillo 65 El Paso 60 | 2017-18 | S-H |
| El Paso 58 Canutillo 43 | 2018-19 | T |
| Canutillo 58 El Paso 53 | 2018-19 | H |
| Canutillo 45 El Paso 41 | 2019-20 | H |
| Canutillo 48 El Paso 44 | 2019-20 | T |
| Canutillo 63 El Paso 55 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 49 El Paso 44 | 2021-22 | H |
| Canutillo 65 El Paso 46 | 2021-22 | S-H |
| Canutillo 63 El Paso 44 | 2022-23 | H |
| Canutillo 59 El Paso 44 | 2022-23 | T |
| El Paso 46 Canutillo 45 | 2022-23 | H |
| El Paso 55 Canutillo 51 | 2023-24 | H |
| El Paso 56 Canutillo 54 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Americas | 1-9 | |
| Americas 55 Canutillo 50 | 1998-99 | H |
| Americas 40 Canutillo 39 | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| Americas 49 Canutillo 46 | 2000-01 | T |
| Americas 57 Canutillo 38 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 45 Americas 42 | 2014-15 | El Paso |
| Americas 39 Canutillo 21 | 2014-15 | El Paso |
| Americas 48 Canutillo 45 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Americas 40 Canutillo 37 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| Americas 77 Canutillo 45 | 2020-21 | H |
| Americas 50 Canutillo 32 | 2021-22 | T |
| El Paso Americas (soph) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 47 Soph 38 | 1997-98 | Clint |
| El Paso Andress | 7-32 | |
| Andress 73 Canutillo 36 | 1988-89 | T |
| Andress 73 Canutillo 39 | 1988-89 | H |
| Andress 88 Canutillo 50 | 1989-90 | H |
| Andress 78 Canutillo 55 | 1989-90 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Andress 67 | 1990-91 | H |
| Andress 75 Canutillo 65 | 1990-91 | T |
| Andress 84 Canutillo 50 | 1991-92 | T |
| Andress 60 Canutillo 50 | 1991-92 | H |
| Andress 53 Canutillo 44 | 1992-93 | H |
| Andress 59 Canutillo 50 | 1992-93 | H |
| Andress 67 Canutillo 44 | 1993-94 | H |
| Andress 75 Canutillo 50 | 1993-94 | T |
| Andress defeated Canutillo | 1994-95 | T |
| Andress 70 Canutillo 61 | 2004-05 | T |
| Andress 81 Canutillo 63 | 2004-05 | H |
| Andress 58 Canutillo 55 | 2005-06 | H |
| Andress 60 Canutillo 57 | 2005-06 | T |
| Andress 76 Canutillo 32 | 2006-07 | El Paso |
| Andress 39 Canutillo 37 | 2008-09 | S-El Paso |
| Canutillo 62 Andress 53 | 2009-10 | S-El Paso |
| Canutillo 48 Andress 46 | 2011-12 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 62 Andress 55 | 2012-13 | El Paso |
| Andress 61 Canutillo 40 | 2013-14 | El Paso |
| Andress 47 Canutillo 40 | 2014-15 | T |
| Andress 58 Canutillo 39 | 2014-15 | H |
| Andress 54 Canutillo 48 | 2015-16 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Andress 43 | 2015-16 | T |
| Andress 70 Canutillo 46 | 2016-17 | S-El Paso |
| Andress 62 Canutillo 49 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Andress 70 Canutillo 45 | 2018-19 | H |
| Andress 69 Canutillo 57 | 2018-19 | T |
| Andress 73 Canutillo 58 | 2019-20 | T |
| Andress 70 Canutillo 54 | 2019-20 | H |
| Andress 43 Canutillo 40 | 2020-21 | S-T |
| Canutillo 68 Andress 64 | 2022-23 | H |
| Andress 65 Canutillo 51 | 2022-23 | T |
| Andress 66 Canutillo 55 | 2022-23 | T |
| Canutillo 42 Andress 38 | 2023-24 | T |
| Andress 78 Canutillo 64 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Austin | 15-27 | |
| Austin 45 Canutillo 37 | 1986-87 | H |
| Austin 53 Canutillo 43 | 1986-87 | El Paso |
| Austin 59 Canutillo 31 | 1988-89 | T |
| Austin 36 Canutillo 30 | 1988-89 | H |
| Austin 59 Canutillo 34 | 1989-90 | T |
| Austin 66 Canutillo 52 | 1989-90 | H |
| Austin 56 Canutillo 43 | 1990-91 | H |
| Austin 49 Canutillo 45 | 1990-91 | T |
| Austin 53 Canutillo 49 | 1991-92 | H |
| Austin 59 Canutillo 38 | 1991-92 | T |
| Austin 54 Canutilo 44 | 1992-93 | H |
| Austin 76 Canutillo 34 | 1992-93 | T |
| Austin 59 Canutillo 37 | 1993-94 | T |
| Austin 57 Canutillo 51 | 1993-94 | H |
| Austin 60 Canutillo 36 | 1994-95 | H |
| Austin 59 Canutillo 56 | 99-2000 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Austin 52 | 2000-01 | H |
| Austin 48 Canutillo 43 | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| Austin 49 Canutillo 47 | 2000-01 | T |
| Austin 53 Canutillo 50 | 2001-02 | T |
| Austin 64 Canutillo 61 | 2002-03 | T |
| Austin 42 Canutillo 37 | 2002-03 | T |
| Austin 38 Canutillo 30 | 2003-04 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 37 Austin 25 | 2003-04 | T |
| Canutillo 61 Austin 33 | 2003-04 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Austin 38 | 2004-05 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 39 Austin 37 | 2004-05 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Austin 46 | 2004-05 | H |
| Austin 36 Canutillo 35 | 2005-06 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 73 Austin 52 | 2005-06 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Austin 35 | 2005-06 | T |
| Austin 61 Canutillo 49 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Austin 79 Canutillo 44 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 65 Austin 53 | 2014-15 | H |
| Canutillo 76 Austin 61 | 2014-15 | T |
| Canutillo 46 Austin 29 | 2015-16 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 61 Austin 51 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 48 Austin 18 | 2015-16 | H |
| Austin 46 Canutillo 45 | 2018-19 | H |
| Austin 51 Canutillo 46 | 2018-19 | T |
| Canutillo 39 Austin 35 | 2019-20 | T |
| Canutillo 60 Austin 43 | 2019-20 | H |
| El Paso Bel Air | 10-12 | |
| Bel Air 79 Canutillo 41 | 1986-87 | H |
| Bel Air 83 Canutillo 24 | 1986-87 | T |
| Bel Air 60 Canutillo 54 | 1987-88 | T |
| Canutillo 42 Bel Air 37 | 1987-88 | H |
| Bel Air defeated Canutillo | 1992-93 | El Paso |
| Bel Air 88 Canutillo 56 | 1994-95 | H |
| Bel Air 58 Canutillo 38 | 1997-98 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Bel Air 44 | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 58 Bel Air 55 | 2005-06 | Fabens |
| Bel Air 48 Canutillo 45 | 2012-13 | T |
| Bel Air 57 Canutillo 42 | 2013-14 | H |
| Bel Air 58 Canutillo 45 | 2015-16 | El Paso |
| Bel Air 44 Canutillo 38 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 43 Bel Air 28 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 41 Bel Air 36 | 2017-18 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 50 Bel Air 38 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 56 Bel Air 53 | 2017-18 | H |
| Bel Air 59 Canutillo 39 | 2020-21 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Bel Air 55 | 2020-21 | T |
| Bel Air 58 Canutillo 56 | 2021-22 | H |
| Canutillo 50 Bel Air 44 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 76 Bel Air 74 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Bowie | 10-29 | |
| Bowie 57 Canutillo 55 | 1986-87 | T |
| Bowie 47 Canutillo 29 | 1987-88 | T |
| Bowie 81 Canutillo 37 | 1988-89 | H |
| Bowie 64 Canutillo 39 | 1988-89 | T |
| Bowie 91 Canutillo 49 | 1989-90 | T |
| Bowie 76 Canutillo 59 | 1989-90 | H |
| Bowie 67 Canutillo 65 | 1990-91 | H |
| Bowie 63 Canutillo 54 | 1990-91 | H |
| Bowie 67 Canutillo 65 | 1991-92 | H |
| Bowie 63 Canutillo 44 | 1991-92 | T |
| Bowie 47 Canutillo 41 | 1992-93 | T |
| Bowie 41 Canutillo 36 | 1992-93 | H |
| Bowie 50 Canutillo 36 | 1993-94 | H |
| Canutillo 44 Bowie 41 | 1993-94 | T |
| Canutillo 48 Bowie 46 | 1994-95 | H |
| Bowie 75 Canutillo 39 | 1994-95 | H |
| Bowie 61 Canutillo 46 | 1996-97 | T |
| Bowie 58 Canutillo 36 | 1996-97 | H |
| Bowie 41 Canutillo 33 | 1997-98 | H |
| Bowie 55 Canutillo 29 | 1997-98 | T |
| Bowie 39 Canutillo 37 | 2001-02 | H |
| Bowie 48 Canutillo 39 | 2002-03 | H |
| Bowie 45 Canutillo 22 | 2002-03 | T |
| Canutillo 43 Bowie 38 | 2003-04 | H |
| Canutillo 34 Bowie 30 | 2003-04 | T |
| Bowie defeated Canutillo | 2004-05 | T |
| Bowie 60 Canutillo 30 | 2004-05 | T |
| Bowie 58 Canutillo 56 | 2005-06 | T |
| Bowie 54 Canutillo 53 | 2005-06 | H |
| Canutillo 52 Bowie 38 | 2013-14 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 45 Bowie 44 | 2013-14 | S-El Paso |
| Canutillo 73 Bowie 59 | 2014-15 | T |
| Canutillo 79 Bowie 53 | 2014-15 | H |
| Bowie 66 Canutillo 62 | 2015-16 | H |
| Bowie 57 Canutillo 35 | 2015-16 | T |
| Bowie 62 Canutillo 59 | 2018-19 | H |
| Bowie 55 Canutillo 52 | 2018-19 | T |
| Canutillo 75 Bowie 61 | 2019-20 | T |
| Canutillo 67 Bowie 60 | 2019-20 | H |
| El Paso Burges | 14-37 | |
| Burges 53 Canutillo 40 | 1986-87 | H |
| Burges 70 Canutillo 29 | 1988-89 | H |
| Burges 54 Canutillo 29 | 1988-89 | T |
| FW Burges 56 Canutillo 48 | 1989-90 | T |
| Burges 65 Canutillo 48 | 1989-90 | H |
| Burges 86 Canutillo 65 | 1990-91 | T |
| Burges 79 Canutillo 56 | 1990-91 | H |
| Burges 77 Canutillo 59 | 1991-92 | H |
| Burges 53 Canutillo 50 | 1991-92 | T |
| Burges 59 Canutillo 46 | 1992-93 | H |
| Burges 62 Canutillo 36 | 1992-93 | T |
| Burges 62 Canutillo 38 | 1993-94 | T |
| Burges 90 Canutillo 57 | 1993-94 | H |
| Burges 76 Canutillo 50 | 1994-95 | T |
| Burges 53 Canutillo 44 | 1996-97 | T |
| Canutillo 56 Burges 51 | 1996-97 | H |
| Burges 52 Canutillo 50 | 1997-98 | H |
| Burges 50 Canutillo 40 | 1997-98 | T |
| Burges 49 Canutillo 46 | 1998-99 | T |
| Canutillo 44 Burges 37 | 1998-99 | T |
| Canutillo 38 Burges 37 | 99-2000 | T |
| Burges 50 Canutillo 36 | 2002-03 | T |
| Burges 41 Canutillo 36 | 2002-03 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Burges 44 | 2003-04 | H |
| Burges 43 Canutillo 37 | 2003-04 | T |
| Burges 65 Canutillo 44 | 2004-05 | T |
| Burges 51 Canutillo 46 | 2004-05 | H |
| Burges 47 Canutillo 36 | 2005-06 | H |
| Burges 60 Canutillo 45 | 2005-06 | T |
| Burges 59 Canutillo 28 | 2006-07 | H |
| Canutillo 52 Burges 47 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 48 Burges 34 | 2009-10 | H |
| Burges 69 Canutillo 54 | 2010-11 | El Paso |
| Burges 54 Canutillo 53 | 2010-11 | H |
| Burges 78 Canutillo 53 | 2011-12 | T |
| Burges 52 Canutillo 38 | 2012-13 | S-El Paso |
| Burges 47 Canutillo 43 | 2014-15 | H |
| Canutillo 43 Burges 40 | 2014-15 | T |
| Burges 76 Canutillo 42 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 49 Burges 42 | 2015-16 | H |
| Burges 59 Canutillo 48 | 2017-18 | H |
| Burges 53 Canutillo 36 | 2018-19 | T |
| Burges 57 Canutillo 39 | 2018-19 | H |
| Burges 41 Canutillo 33 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 42 Burges 31 | 2019-20 | H |
| Burges 42 Canutillo 27 | 2019-20 | T |
| Burges 46 Canutillo 45 | 2022-23 | T |
| Canutillo 41 Burges 27 | 2022-23 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Burges 27 | 2022-23 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Burges 66 | 2023-24 | T |
| Canutillo 58 Burges 52 | 2023-24 | H |
| El Paso Cathedral | 10-14 | |
| Cathedral 58 Canutillo 57 | 1986-87 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Cathedral 37 | 1987-88 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 51 Cathedral 49 | 1987-88 | T |
| Cathedral 53 Canutillo 50 | 1987-88 | T |
| Cathedral 47 Canutillo 45 | 1987-88 | H |
| Cathedral 64 Canutillo 35 | 1988-89 | H |
| Cathedral 56 Canutillo 43 | 1988-89 | T |
| Cathedral 86 Cathedral 79 | 1989-90 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Cathedral 58 | 1990-91 | H |
| Cathedral 63 Canutillo 58 | 1990-91 | Canutillo |
| Cathedral 72 Canutillo 65 | 1990-91 | T |
| Canutillo 58 Cathedral 57 | 1991-92 | H |
| Canutillo 77 Cathedral 63 | 1992-93 | T |
| Cathedral 71 Canutillo 60 | 2004-05 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 70 Cathedral 64 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| Cathedral 57 Canutillo 52 | 2004-05 | T |
| Canutillo 44 Cathedral 36 | 2005-06 | H |
| Canutillo 52 Cathedral 36 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 62 Cathedral 48 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cathedral 59 Canutillo 34 | 2010-11 | T |
| Cathedral 38 Canutillo 33 | 2011-12 | H |
| Cathedral 24 Canutillo 20 | 2012-13 | T |
| Cathedral 59 Canutillo 46 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 58 Cathedral 48 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Chapin | 7-16 | |
| Chapin defeated Canutillo | 2002-03 | H |
| Canutillo 70 Chapin 58 | 2002-03 | H |
| Chapin 82 Canutillo 56 | 2003-04 | H |
| Chapin 75 Canutillo 52 | 2003-04 | T |
| Chapin 67 Canutillo 54 | 2004-05 | H |
| Chapin 62 Canutillo 56 | 2004-05 | T |
| Chapin 76 Canutillo 32 | 2005-06 | T |
| Chapin 61 Canutillo 47 | 2005-06 | H |
| Chapin 76 Canutillo 71 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 59 Chapin 57 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 49 Chapin 40 | 2014-15 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Chapin 53 | 2014-15 | T |
| Chapin 47 Canutillo 45 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 63 Chapin 51 | 2015-16 | H |
| Canutillo 51 Chapin 45 | 2018-19 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Chapin 55 | 2018-19 | T |
| Chapin 58 Canutillo 37 | 2019-20 | T |
| Chapin 41 Canutillo 26 | 2019-20 | H |
| Chapin 68 Canutillo 56 | 2022-23 | H |
| Chapin 64 Canutillo 41 | 2022-23 | T |
| Chapin 61 Canutillo 50 | 2022-23 | H |
| Chapin 66 Canutillo 32 | 2023-24 | H |
| Chapin 46 Canutillo 32 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Coronado | 1-27 | |
| Coronado 54 Canutillo 34 | 1986-87 | T |
| Coronado 60 Canutillo 25 | 1987-88 | Canutillo |
| Coronado 54 Canutillo 24 | 1988-89 | H |
| Coronado 55 Canutillo 37 | 1988-89 | T |
| Coronado 48 Canutillo 34 | 1989-90 | T |
| Coronado 70 Canutillo 31 | 1990-91 | T |
| Coronado 55 Canutillo 48 | 1990-91 | H |
| Coronado 44 Canutillo 36 | 1991-92 | T |
| Coronado 46 Canutillo 24 | 1991-92 | H |
| Coronado 62 Canutillo 32 | 1992-93 | T |
| Coronado 38 Canutillo 27 | 1992-93 | H |
| Coronado 36 Canutillo 33 | 1993-94 | T |
| Coronado 32 Canutillo 28 | 1993-94 | H |
| Coronado 58 Canutillo 44 | 2001-02 | H |
| Coronado 43 Canutillo 28 | 2008-09 | El Paso |
| Coronado 46 Canutillo 31 | 2008-09 | T |
| Coronado 79 Canutillo 40 | 2010-11 | El Paso |
| Coronado 67 Canutillo 40 | 2011-12 | El Paso |
| Coronado 72 Canutillo 46 | 2014-15 | T |
| Coronado 47 Canutillo 31 | 2014-15 | H |
| Coronado 67 Canutillo 48 | 2015-16 | H |
| Coronado 46 Canutillo 30 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Coronado 57 Canutillo 38 | 2018-19 | T |
| Coronado 54 Canutillo 43 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| Coronado 47 Canutillo 28 | 2019-20 | H |
| Coronado 59 Canutillo 45 | 2020-21 | T |
| Coronado 58 Canutillo 54 | 2023-24 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Coronado 33 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| El Paso Del Valle | 22-18 | |
| Del Valle 38 Canutillo 36 | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| Del Valle 45 Canutillo 34 | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| Del Valle defeated Canutillo | 1995-96 | El Paso |
| Del Valle defeated Canutillo | 1995-96 | T |
| Del Valle 70 Canutillo 62 | 1996-97 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 78 Del Valle 75 | 1997-98 | El Paso |
| Del Valle 61 Canutillo 49 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Del Valle 59 Canutillo 49 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Del Valle 56 Canutillo 48 | 99-2000 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 70 Del Valle 58 | 2002-03 | T |
| Del Valle 45 Canutillo 43 | 2003-04 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 47 Del Valle 36 | 2004-05 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 65 Del Valle 62 | 2005-06 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 53 Del Valle 49 | 2006-07 | T |
| Canutillo 60 Del Valle 49 | 2006-07 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Del Valle 42 | 2007-08 | H |
| Canutillo 55 Del Valle 40 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 66 Del Valle 57 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 60 Del Valle 29 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 48 Del Valle 38 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 47 Del Valle 42 | 2009-10 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Del Valle 47 | 2009-10 | T |
| Del Valle 46 Canutillo 43 | 2010-11 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Del Valle 47 | 2010-11 | H |
| Del Valle 55 Canutillo 53 | 2011-12 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Del Valle 44 | 2011-12 | T |
| Del Valle 55 Canutillo 48 | 2012-13 | T |
| Del Valle 50 Canutillo 47 | 2012-13 | H |
| Canutillo 64 Del Valle 53 | 2013-14 | H |
| Del Valle 48 Canutillo 46 | 2013-14 | T |
| Del Valle 57 Canutillo 54 | 2015-16 | S-El Paso |
| Del Valle 57 Canutillo 56 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 61 Del Valle 53 | 2016-17 | H |
| Del Valle 60 Canutillo 56 | 2017-18 | H |
| Canutillo 91 Del Valle 69 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 63 Del Valle 58 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 55 Del Valle 47 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 46 Del Valle 38 | 2020-21 | H |
| Canutillo 59 Del Valle 45 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 42 Del Valle 40 | 2021-22 | H |
| El Paso Eastlake | 10-6 | |
| Canutillo 52 Eastlake 49 | 2012-13 | T |
| Canutillo 60 Eastlake 41 | 2012-13 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Eastlake 47 | 2013-14 | H |
| Eastlake 56 Canutillo 48 | 2013-14 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Eastlake 58 | 2014-15 | S-El Paso |
| Canutillo 64 Eastlake 47 | 2016-17 | H |
| Eastlake 53 Canutillo 51 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 59 Eastlake 54 | 2016-17 | TB-El Paso |
| Eastlake 74 Canutillo 70 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 58 Eastlake 56 | 2017-18 | H |
| Eastlake 63 Canutillo 59 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| Eastlake 59 Canutillo 39 | 2019-20 | S-T |
| Eastlake 56 Canutillo 38 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 65 Eastlake 43 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 50 Eastlake 46 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 52 Eastlake 44 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| El Paso Eastwood | 2-14 | |
| Eastwood 53 Canutillo 41 | 1986-87 | T |
| Eastwood 69 Canutillo 39 | 1986-87 | H |
| Eastwood 72 Canutillo 37 | 1987-88 | H |
| Eastwood 92 Canutillo 55 | 1987-88 | T |
| Eastwood 65 Canutillo 51 | 1992-93 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 83 Canutillo 44 | 1993-94 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 76 Canutillo 44 | 1994-95 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 53 Canutillo 42 | 2014-15 | H |
| Eastwood 65 Canutillo 52 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 61 Eastwood 52 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 64 Canutillo 46 | 2017-18 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 54 Canutillo 46 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 53 Canutillo 50 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| Eastwood 67 Canutillo 39 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 62 Eastwood 53 | 2022-23 | T |
| Eastwood 47 Canutillo 44 | 2023-24 | H |
| El Paso El Dorado | 4-5 | |
| El Dorado 55 Canutillo 35 | 2007-08 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 57 El Dorado 55 | 2008-09 | H |
| El Dorado 49 Canutillo 39 | 2010-11 | Canutillo |
| El Dorado 35 Canutillo 28 | 2011-12 | H |
| El Dorado 49 Canutillo 38 | 2012-13 | T |
| Canutillo 52 El Dorado 45 | 2020-21 | H |
| El Dorado 58 Canutillo 55 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 58 El Dorado 40 | 2021-22 | H |
| Canutillo 43 El Dorado 38 | 2021-22 | T |
| El Paso Faith Christian | 3-3 | |
| Canutillo 58 Faith Christian 38 | 2006-07 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 49 Faith Christian 40 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 63 Faith Christian 25 | 2009-10 | Canutillo |
| Faith Christian 54 Canutillo 33 | 2012-13 | Canutillo |
| Faith Christian 45 Canutillo 35 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Faith Christian 50 Canutillo 35 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| El Paso Franklin | 0-9 | |
| Franklin 40 Canutillo 36 | 1995-96 | T |
| Franklin 64 Canutillo 37 | 1996-97 | H |
| Franklin 54 Canutillo 43 | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| Franklin 54 Canutillo 42 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| Franklin 59 Canutillo 53 | 2011-12 | El Paso |
| Franklin 61 Canutillo 57 | 2014-15 | H |
| Franklin 57 Canutillo 40 | 2015-16 | T |
| Franklin 77 Canutillo 55 | 2021-22 | H |
| Franklin 60 Canutillo 49 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| El Paso Hanks | 9-14 | |
| Hanks 63 Canutillo 40 | 1986-87 | Carlsbad |
| Hanks 36 Canutillo 34 | 1986-87 | H |
| Hanks 38 Canutillo 37 | 1986-87 | T |
| Hanks 67 Canutillo 46 | 1987-88 | H |
| Hanks 64 Canutillo 40 | 1987-88 | T |
| Hanks 45 Canutillo 42 | 1993-94 | H |
| Hanks defeated Canutillo | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| Hanks 63 Canutillo 59 | 2012-13 | El Paso |
| Hanks 52 Canutillo 39 | 2012-13 | H |
| Hanks 70 Canutillo 53 | 2012-13 | T |
| Hanks 66 Canutillo 61 | 2013-14 | T |
| Hanks 64 Canutillo 60 | 2013-14 | H |
| Hanks 31 Canutillo 27 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 54 Hanks 51 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 47 Hanks 38 | 2017-18 | H |
| Hanks 69 Canutillo 56 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 63 Hanks 47 | 2020-21 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Hanks 55 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 59 Hanks 44 | 2021-22 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Hanks 45 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 50 Hanks 42 | 2022-23 | S-T |
| Canutillo 54 Hanks 45 | 2023-24 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Hanks 46 | 2023-24 | S-T |
| El Paso Harmony Science Academy | 2-0 | |
| Canutillo 60 Harmony 23 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 50 Harmony 38 | 2023-24 | Anthony |
| El Paso Horizon | 26-5 | |
| Canutillo 41 Horizon 36 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 41 Horizon 33 | 2006-07 | El Paso |
| Horizon 45 Canutillo 18 | 2006-07 | H |
| Canutillo 52 Horizon 42 | 2006-07 | T |
| Canutillo 50 Horizon 39 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 45 Horizon 34 | 2007-08 | H |
| Canutillo 46 Horizon 41 | 2008-09 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 37 Horizon 10 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 65 Horizon 33 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Horizon 41 | 2009-10 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 49 Horizon 43 | 2009-10 | H |
| Horizon 60 Canutillo 59 | 2009-10 | T |
| Canutillo 61 Horizon 28 | 2010-11 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Horizon 29 | 2010-11 | T |
| Canutillo 49 Horizon 32 | 2011-12 | T |
| Canutillo 49 Horizon 23 | 2011-12 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Horizon 31 | 2012-13 | T |
| Canutillo 64 Horizon 20 | 2012-13 | H |
| Canutillo 63 Horizon 39 | 2013-14 | H |
| Canutillo 72 Horizon 25 | 2013-14 | H |
| Canutillo 54 Horizon 43 | 2014-15 | El Paso |
| Horizon 57 Canutillo 55 | 2015-16 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 63 Horizon 62 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 68 Horizon 62 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Horizon 48 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 80 Horizon 47 | 2017-18 | H |
| Horizon 53 Canutillo 48 | 2020-21 | H |
| Canutillo 55 Horizon 53 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 78 Horizon 64 | 2021-22 | H |
| Horizon 67 Canutillo 63 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 50 Horizon 48 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 63 Horizon 48 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Immanuel Christian | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 66 Immanuel Christian 23 | 2013-14 | Canutillo |
| El Paso Irvin | 14-21 | |
| Irvin 67 Canutillo 31 | 1988-89 | T |
| Irvin 48 Canutillo 27 | 1988-89 | H |
| Irvin 71 Canutillo 43 | 1989-90 | T |
| Irvin 82 Canutillo 54 | 1989-90 | H |
| Irvin 64 Canutillo 45 | 1990-91 | T |
| Irvin 58 Canutillo 54 | 1990-91 | H |
| Irvin 80 Canutillo 40 | 1991-92 | T |
| Canutillo 51 Irvin 49 | 1991-92 | H |
| Canutillo 46 Irvin 34 | 1992-93 | H |
| Irvin 54 Canutillo 44 | 1992-93 | T |
| Irvin 65 Canutillo 44 | 1993-94 | H |
| Irvin 62 Canutillo 51 | 1993-94 | T |
| Irvin 76 Canutillo 33 | 1994-95 | T |
| Canutillo 67 Irvin 63 | 1997-98 | El Paso |
| Irvin 85 Canutillo 52 | 2001-02 | T |
| Irvin 50 Canutillo 49 | 2002-03 | H |
| Canutillo 62 Irvin 54 | 2002-03 | T |
| Irvin 60 Canutillo 51 | 2003-04 | T |
| Irvin 57 Canutillo 45 | 2003-04 | H |
| Irvin 59 Canutillo 52 | 2004-05 | H |
| Irvin 60 Canutillo 38 | 2004-05 | T |
| Irvin 41 Canutillo 34 | 2005-06 | T |
| Canutillo 54 Irvin 44 | 2005-06 | H |
| Irvin 52 Canutillo 45 | 2006-07 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Irvin 38 | 2006-07 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 52 Irvin 42 | 2007-08 | H |
| Irvin 46 Canutillo 39 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 70 Irvin 51 | 2014-15 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Irvin 53 | 2014-15 | H |
| Irvin 48 Canutillo 43 | 2015-16 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Irvin 41 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 52 Irvin 49 | 2018-19 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Irvin 31 | 2018-19 | H |
| Canutillo 51 Irvin 48 | 2019-20 | H |
| Canutillo 65 Irvin 55 | 2019-20 | T |
| El Paso Jefferson | 25-22 | |
| Jefferson 63 Canutillo 36 | 1987-88 | H |
| Jefferson 49 Canutillo 30 | 1988-89 | H |
| Jefferson 68 Canutillo 45 | 1988-89 | T |
| Jefferson 65 Canutillo 57 | 1989-90 | H |
| Jefferson 59 Canutillo 54 | 1989-90 | T |
| Jefferson 66 Canutillo 64 | 1990-91 | H |
| Canutillo 45 Jefferson 44 | 1990-91 | T |
| Jefferson 58 Canutillo 47 | 1991-92 | T |
| Jefferson 44 Canutillo 41 | 1991-92 | H |
| Canutillo 33 Jefferson 28 | 1992-93 | H |
| Jefferson 34 Canutillo 27 | 1992-93 | T |
| Jefferson 41 Canutillo 37 | 1993-94 | T |
| Jefferson 51 Canutillo 44 | 1993-94 | H |
| Jefferson 42 Canutillo 38 | 1994-95 | H |
| Jefferson 54 Canutillo 31 | 1994-95 | T |
| Jefferson 40 Canutillo 30 | 1995-96 | T |
| Jefferson 47 Canutillo 32 | 1995-96 | H |
| Jefferson 61 Canutillo 42 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Jefferson 48 | 99-2000 | H |
| Jefferson 68 Canutillo 63 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Jefferson 44 | 2002-03 | T |
| Jefferson 70 Canutillo 61 FW | 2002-03 | H |
| Jefferson 42 Canutillo 40 | 2003-04 | H |
| Canutillo 50 Jefferson 37 | 2003-04 | T |
| Jefferson 48 Canutillo 46 | 2004-05 | T |
| Jefferson 53 Canutillo 42 | 2004-05 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Jefferson 37 | 2005-06 | H |
| Canutillo 60 Jefferson 54 | 2005-06 | T |
| Jefferson 63 Canutillo 61 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Jefferson 46 Canutillo 37 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 70 Jefferson 48 | 2012-13 | H |
| Canutillo 45 Jefferson 24 | 2013-14 | T |
| Canutillo 52 Jefferson 47 | 2014-15 | T |
| Canutillo 56 Jefferson 47 | 2014-15 | H |
| Canutillo 48 Jefferson 47 | 2015-16 | H |
| Canutillo 43 Jefferson 40 | 2015-16 | T |
| Canutillo 60 Jefferson 25 | 2017-18 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 67 Jefferson 56 | 2018-19 | T |
| Canutillo 62 Jefferson 42 | 2018-19 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Jefferson 34 | 2019-20 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 47 Jefferson 41 | 2019-20 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Jefferson 36 | 2019-20 | T |
| Canutillo 62 Jefferson 19 | 2022-23 | T |
| Canutillo 55 Jefferson 28 | 2022-23 | H |
| Canutillo 64 Jefferson 22 | 2022-23 | T |
| Canutillo 74 Jefferson 34 | 2023-24 | T |
| Canutillo 54 Jefferson 21 | 2023-24 | H |
| El Paso Loretto Academy | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo defeated Loretto | 2002-03 | T |
| El Paso Maranata | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 60 Maranata 25 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| El Paso Montwood | 5-7 | |
| Montwood 49 Canutillo 33 | 1991-92 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 50 Montwood 48 | 1992-93 | H |
| Montwood defeated Canutillo | 1997-98 | El Paso |
| Montwood 69 Canutillo 44 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Montwood 57 Canutillo 48 | 1998-99 | H |
| Montwood 75 Canutillo 55 | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 47 Montwood 40 | 2015-16 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 46 Montwood 37 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 37 Montwood 35 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 70 Montwood 60 | 2017-18 | H |
| Montwood 48 Canutillo 47 | 2018-19 | H |
| Montwood 54 Canutillo 49 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| El Paso Mountainview | 29-7 | |
| Canutillo 65 Mountainview 40 | 1990-91 | H |
| Canutillo 64 Mountainview 37 | 1990-91 | Canutillo |
| Mountainview 69 Canutillo 54 | 1991-92 | H |
| Canutillo defeated Mountainview | 1991-92 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 55 Mountainview 34 | 1995-96 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Mountainview 37 | 1996-97 | H |
| Canutillo 39 Mountainview 32 | 1997-98 | H |
| Canutillo 43 Mountainview 42 | 1997-98 | T |
| Mountainview 36 Canutillo 31 | 1997-98 | T |
| Mountainview 52 Canutillo 49 | 1998-99 | T |
| Mountainview 43 Canutillo 35 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo 64 Mountainview 61 | 99-2000 | T |
| Mountainview 46 Canutillo 39 | 99-2000 | H |
| Canutillo 46 Mountainview 30 | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 40 Mountainview 31 | 2000-01 | H |
| Mountainview 67 Canutillo 47 | 2000-01 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Mountainview 48 | 2001-02 | Clint |
| Canutillo 45 Mountainview 40 | 2001-02 | T |
| Canutillo 49 Mountainview 42 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 62 Mountainview 40 | 2005-06 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 51 Mountainview 36 | 2005-06 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 50 Mountainview 34 | 2006-07 | H |
| Canutillo 38 Mountainview 24 | 2006-07 | T |
| Canutillo 50 Mountainview 43 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 55 Mountainview 42 | 2007-08 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Mountainview 30 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Mountainview 39 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 56 Mountainview 45 | 2009-10 | T |
| Canutillo 54 Mountainview 36 | 2009-10 | H |
| Mountainview 44 Canutillo 36 | 2010-11 | T |
| Canutillo 48 Mountainview 40 | 2011-12 | H |
| Canutillo 68 Mountainview 34 | 2013-14 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 45 Mountainview 23 | 2015-16 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 66 Mountainview 36 | 2022-23 | H |
| Canutillo 55 Mountainview 38 | 2023-24 | T |
| Canutillo 55 Mountainview 33 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| El Paso Parkland | 13-33 | |
| Parkland 77 Canutillo 51 | 1986-87 | T |
| Parkland 58 Canutillo 55 | 1986-87 | H |
| Parkland 68 Canutillo 40 | 1987-88 | T |
| Parkland defeated Canutillo | 1987-88 | H |
| Parkland 82 Canutillo 40 | 1994-95 | H |
| Parkland 69 Canutillo 45 | 1994-95 | T |
| Parkland 57 Canutillo 51 | 1995-96 | T |
| Parkland 57 Canutillo 45 | 1995-96 | H |
| Parkland 101 Canutillo 76 | 1996-97 | H |
| Parkland 80 Canutillo 77 | 1996-97 | T |
| Parkland 87 Canutillo 72 | 1997-98 | T |
| Parkland 77 Canutillo 67 | 1997-98 | H |
| Parkland 77 Canutillo 58 | 2000-01 | T |
| Parkland 109 Canutillo 61 | 2001-02 | Clint |
| Parkland 78 Canutillo 59 | 2003-04 | T |
| Parkland 52 Canutillo 45 | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| Parkland 57 Canutillo 56 | 2006-07 | T |
| Parkland 35 Canutillo 33 | 2006-07 | H |
| Parkland 54 Canutillo 38 | 2007-08 | H |
| Parkland 75 Canutillo 55 | 2007-08 | T |
| Parkland 63 Canutillo 37 | 2008-09 | T |
| Parkland 62 Canutillo 44 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 63 Parkland 56 | 2009-10 | T |
| Canutillo 67 Parkland 53 | 2009-10 | H |
| Parkland 78 Canutillo 29 | 2010-11 | T |
| Parkland 76 Canutillo 28 | 2010-11 | H |
| Parkland 65 Canutillo 48 | 2011-12 | H |
| Parkland 53 Canutillo 49 | 2011-12 | T |
| Parkland 65 Canutillo 54 | 2012-13 | T |
| Parkland 63 Canutillo 61 | 2012-13 | H |
| Canutillo 66 Parkland 31 | 2013-14 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Parkland 28 | 2013-14 | T |
| Parkland 52 Canutillo 51 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Parkland 42 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 63 Parkland 50 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 65 Parkland 49 | 2017-18 | H |
| Parkland 59 Canutillo 50 | 2018-19 | H |
| Parkland 51 Canutillo 43 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Parkland 46 Canutillo 43 | 2019-20 | T |
| Canutillo 44 Parkland 41 | 2019-20 | H |
| Canutillo 59 Parkland 58 | 2020-21 | T |
| Canutillo 51 Parkland 39 | 2020-21 | H |
| Parkland 75 Canutillo 69 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 65 Parkland 61 | 2021-22 | H |
| Canutillo 81 Parkland 69 | 2022-23 | H |
| Canutillo 65 Parkland 49 | 2023-24 | T |
| El Paso Lydia Patterson | 11-7 | |
| Canutillo 45 Patterson 44 | 1988-89 | H |
| Canutillo 54 Patterson 52 | 1989-90 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Patterson 53 | 1989-90 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 85 Patterson 39 | 1991-92 | H |
| Patterson 72 Canutillo 53 | 1995-96 | H |
| Patterson 77 Canutillo 63 | 1995-96 | T |
| Patterson 66 Canutillo 63 | 1996-97 | Clint |
| Patterson 57 Canutillo 43 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 59 Patterson 48 | 99-2000 | H |
| Patterson 66 Canutillo 49 | 2002-03 | H |
| Patterson 85 Canutillo 71 | 2002-03 | T |
| Canutillo 51 Patterson 42 | 2004-05 | T |
| Canutillo 64 Patterson 50 | 2005-06 | T |
| Canutillo 38 Patterson 25 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Patterson 51 Canutillo 48 | 2007-08 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 56 Patterson 25 | 2009-10 | T |
| Canutillo 58 Patterson 39 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 46 Patterson 23 | 2010-11 | Canutillo |
| El Paso Pebble Hills | 0-4 | |
| Pebble Hills 66 Canutillo 51 | 2018-19 | T |
| Pebble Hills 59 Canutillo 52 | 2019-20 | H |
| Pebble Hills 63 Canutillo 41 | 2021-22 | T |
| Pebble Hills 59 Canutillo 47 | 2023-24 | El Paso |
| El Paso Riverside | 15-22 | |
| Riverside 57 Canutillo 33 | 1986-87 | T |
| Riverside 87 Canutillo 36 | 1986-87 | H |
| Riverside 79 Canutillo 41 | 1987-88 | H |
| Riverside 86 Canutillo 48 | 1987-88 | T |
| Riverside 102 Canutillo 52 | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| Canutillo defeated Riverside | 1992-93 | Midland |
| Riverside 90 Canutillo 45 | 1994-95 | T |
| Riverside 65 Canutillo 52 | 1996-97 | H |
| Riverside 59 Canutillo 39 | 1996-97 | T |
| Riverside 79 Canutillo 56 | 1997-98 | H |
| Riverside 65 Canutillo 41 | 1997-98 | T |
| Canutillo 75 Riverside 68 | 2000-01 | H |
| Riverside 57 Canutillo 43 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 53 Riverside 47 | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| Riverside 48 Canutillo 45 | 2006-07 | H |
| Riverside 57 Canutillo 40 | 2006-07 | T |
| Riverside 65 Canutillo 54 | 2007-08 | T |
| Riverside 55 Canutillo 46 | 2007-08 | H |
| Riverside 43 Canutillo 40 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 51 Riverside 44 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 52 Riverside 47 | 2009-10 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Riverside 53 | 2009-10 | H |
| Riverside 55 Canutillo 34 | 2010-11 | T |
| Riverside 49 Canutillo 31 | 2010-11 | H |
| Riverside 61 Canutillo 28 | 2011-12 | Canutillo |
| Riverside 55 Canutillo 45 | 2011-12 | H |
| Riverside 45 Canutillo 41 | 2011-12 | T |
| Riverside 33 Canutillo 28 | 2012-13 | H |
| Canutillo 35 Riverside 32 | 2012-13 | T |
| Canutillo 54 Riverside 41 | 2013-14 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Riverside 48 | 2013-14 | H |
| Canutillo 50 Riverside 40 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 52 Riverside 51 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 67 Riverside 34 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 60 Riverside 37 | 2017-18 | H |
| Canutillo 83 Riverside 57 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 62 Riverside 42 | 2022-23 | T |
| El Paso Socorro | 5-9 | |
| Socorro 77 Canutillo 46 | 1986-87 | H |
| Socorro 77 Canutillo 36 | 1986-87 | T |
| Socorro 60 Canutillo 34 | 1987-88 | H |
| Socorro 77 Canutillo 33 | 1987-88 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Socorro 49 | 1991-92 | H |
| Socorro 69 Canutillo 52 | 1991-92 | Canutillo |
| Socorro 80 Canutillo 72 | 1994-95 | H |
| Socorro 66 Canutillo 56 | 1994-95 | T |
| Socorro 54 Canutillo 53 | 1998-99 | T |
| Canutillo 45 Socorro 39 | 2003-04 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 44 Socorro 38 | 2005-06 | Canutillo |
| Socorro 43 Canutillo 41 | 2006-07 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 55 Socorro 40 | 2012-13 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 57 Socorro 53 | 2019-20 | H |
| El Paso Father Yermo | 2-0 | |
| Canutillo 73 Father Yermo 39 | 2000-01 | H |
| Canutillo 70 Father Yermo 37 | 2001-02 | Fabens |
| El Paso Ysleta | 24-23 | |
| Ysleta 55 Canutillo 42 | 1986-87 | T |
| Ysleta 41 Canutillo 25 | 1986-87 | H |
| Ysleta 45 Canutillo 30 | 1987-88 | T |
| Ysleta 44 Canutillo 25 | 1987-88 | H |
| Ysleta 52 Canutillo 49 | 1993-94 | H |
| Ysleta 70 Canutillo 53 | 1994-95 | El Paso |
| Ysleta 69 Canutillo 56 | 1994-95 | T |
| Ysleta 65 Canutillo 52 | 1995-96 | H |
| Canutillo 72 Ysleta 67 | 1996-97 | El Paso |
| Ysleta 42 Canutillo 41 | 1996-97 | T |
| Canutillo 62 Ysleta 54 | 1996-97 | T |
| Ysleta 74 Canutillo 49 | 1997-98 | T |
| Ysleta 73 Canutillo 68 | 1997-98 | H |
| Canutillo 49 Ysleta 44 | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 60 Ysleta 59 | 99-2000 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Ysleta 52 | 2000-01 | H |
| Canutillo defeated Ysleta | 2002-03 | H |
| Ysleta 55 Canutillo 52 | 2002-03 | Silver City |
| Ysleta 52 Canutillo 43 | 2006-07 | H |
| Ysleta 49 Canutillo 44 | 2006-07 | T |
| Ysleta 92 Canutillo 61 | 2007-08 | T |
| Ysleta 62 Canutillo 47 | 2007-08 | H |
| Ysleta 59 Canutillo 56 | 2008-09 | T |
| Ysleta 52 Canutillo 51 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Ysleta 47 | 2009-10 | H |
| Canutillo 74 Ysleta 47 | 2009-10 | H |
| Canutillo 69 Ysleta 65 | 2010-11 | Anthony |
| Canutillo 71 Ysleta 62 | 2010-11 | H |
| Ysleta 60 Canutillo 46 | 2010-11 | T |
| Ysleta 48 Canutillo 40 | 2010-11 | TB-El Paso |
| Canutillo 62 Ysleta 61 | 2011-12 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Ysleta 47 | 2011-12 | H |
| Canutillo 89 Ysleta 59 | 2012-13 | H |
| Ysleta 59 Canutillo 52 | 2012-13 | T |
| Canutillo 74 Ysleta 48 | 2013-14 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Ysleta 48 | 2013-14 | H |
| Canutillo 55 Ysleta 38 | 2014-15 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 59 Ysleta 37 | 2016-17 | T |
| Ysleta 57 Canutillo 46 | 2016-17 | H |
| Canutillo 56 Ysleta 50 | 2017-18 | H |
| Canutillo 52 Ysleta 32 | 2017-18 | T |
| Canutillo 45 Ysleta 39 | 2019-20 | T |
| Canutillo 64 Ysleta 61 | 2020-21 | T |
| Ysleta 48 Canutillo 41 | 2020-21 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Ysleta 35 | 2021-22 | T |
| Canutillo 56 Ysleta 40 | 2021-22 | H |
| Canutillo 67 Ysleta 40 | 2023-24 | H |
| Everman | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 66 Canutillo 58 | 2022-23 | Aledo |
| Fabens | 19-7 | |
| Canutillo 53 Fabens 42 | 1986-87 | T |
| Canutillo 30 Fabens 23 | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 43 Fabens 39 | 1989-90 | T |
| Canutillo 50 Fabens 43 | 1989-90 | Van Horn |
| Canutillo 63 Fabens 52 | 1991-92 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo defeated Fabens | 1991-92 | |
| Fabens defeated Canutillo | 1995-96 | El Paso |
| Fabens 55 Canutillo 53 | 1995-96 | T |
| Canutillo 63 Fabens 49 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Fabens 49 | 1998-99 | T |
| Canutillo 67 Fabens 53 | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Fabens 45 | 99-2000 | H |
| Fabens 86 Canutillo 54 | 2000-01 | H |
| Fabens 87 Canutillo 60 | 2000-01 | T |
| Fabens 70 Canutillo 63 | 2001-02 | T |
| Canutillo 70 Fabens 56 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 60 Fabens 50 | 2002-03 | H |
| Canutillo 51 Fabens 49 | 2003-04 | T |
| Canutillo 64 Fabens 34 | 2004-05 | H |
| Canutillo 54 Fabens 45 | 2005-06 | T |
| Canutillo 49 Fabens 39 | 2005-06 | El Paso |
| Fabens 54 Canutillo 36 | 2006-07 | Fabens |
| Canutillo 62 Fabens 45 | 2010-11 | H |
| Fabens 56 Canutillo 50 | 2011-12 | Hobbs |
| Canutillo 57 Fabens 46 | 2016-17 | T |
| Canutillo 67 Fabens 19 | 2023-24 | Anthony |
| Fort Hancock | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 59 Fort Hancock 56 | 1989-90 | Van Horn |
| Fort Worth Benbrook | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 36 Benbrook 31 | 2023-24 | Abilene |
| Fort Worth Chisholm Trail | 0-1 | |
| Chisholm Trail 68 Canutillo 44 | 2021-22 | Abilene |
| Hallsville | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 56 Hallsville 53 | 2022-23 | San Marcos |
| Hobbs (NM) | 0-4 | |
| Hobbs 91 Canutillo 49 | 2012-13 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 79 Canutillo 52 | 2016-17 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 63 Canutillo 56 | 2017-18 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 78 Canutillo 62 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Houston Texas Christian Academy | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 48 Texas Christian Academy 38 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Katy Taylor | 0-1 | |
| Taylor 63 Canutillo 41 | 2022-23 | San Marcos |
| Keller Central | 0-1 | |
| Central 64 Canutillo 39 | 2022-23 | Aledo |
| Las Cruces (NM) | 2-3 | |
| Las Cruces 59 Canutillo 49 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 53 Las Cruces 51 | 2009-10 | H |
| Canutillo 65 Las Cruces 51 | 2009-10 | El Paso |
| Las Cruces 50 Canutillo 41 | 2010-11 | T |
| Las Cruces 61 Canutillo 43 | 2011-12 | H |
| Las Cruces Mayfield (NM) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 63 Mayfield 54 | 2017-18 | Hobbs |
| Las Cruces Onate (NM) | 1-2 | |
| Onate 44 Canutillo 41 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 70 Onate 53 | 2009-10 | T |
| Onate 49 Canutillo 41 | 2014-15 | El Paso |
| Las Vegas Robertson (NM) | 0-1 | |
| Robertson 70 Canutillo 56 | 1986-87 | Deming |
| Lawton (OK) | 0-3 | |
| Lawton 61 Canutillo 40 | 2011-12 | Hobbs |
| Lawton 70 Canutillo 59 | 2012-13 | Hobbs |
| Lawton 73 Canutillo 54 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Lawton Eisenhower (OK) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 64 Eisenhower 61 | 2019-20 | Hobbs |
| Levelland | 0-1 | |
| Levelland 66 Canutillo 44 | 1986-87 | Carlsbad |
| Los Lunas Valencia (NM) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 47 Valencia 31 | 2013-14 | Alamogordo |
| Lovington (NM) | 0-1 | |
| Lovington 59 Canutillo 58 | 1995-96 | Denver City |
| Lubbock | 0-2 | |
| Lubbock 75 Canutillo 51 | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| Lubbock 58 Canutillo 29 | 2003-04 | Monahans |
| Magnolia | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 51 Magnolia 37 | 2022-23 | San Marcos |
| Midland | 0-3 | |
| Midland 62 Canutillo 42 | 1992-93 | Midland |
| Midland 66 Canutillo 52 | 2014-15 | Midland |
| Midland 64 Canutillo 42 | 2015-16 | Midland |
| Midland JV | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 56 JV 42 | 1995-96 | Denver City |
| Midland Christian | 0-2 | |
| Christian 62 Canutillo 52 | 2021-22 | Abilene |
| Christian 45 Canutillo 29 | 2023-24 | Abilene |
| Midland Lee | 0-3 | |
| Lee 77 Canutillo 50 | 1992-93 | Midland |
| Lee 48 Canutillo 47 | 2014-15 | Midland |
| Lee 49 Canutillo 39 | 2015-16 | Midland |
| Midland Lee JV | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 57 JV 46 | 2003-04 | Monahans |
| Muleshoe | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 48 Muleshoe 41 | 1995-96 | Denver City |
| Odessa Permian | 0-1 | |
| Permian 58 Canutillo 35 | 2014-15 | Midland |
| Oklahoma City Storm (OK) | 0-1 | |
| Storm 74 Canutillo 51 | 2015-16 | Midland |
| Ontario Cooper International (CA) | 0-1 | |
| Cooper International 60 Canutillo 57 | 2022-23 | El Paso |
| Pampa | 0-1 | |
| Pampa 60 Canutillo 58 | 2008-09 | Pampa |
| Pecos | 7-0 | |
| Canutillo 54 Pecos 37 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo defeated Pecos | 1998-99 | T |
| Canutillo defeated Pecos | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 68 Pecos 43 | 99-2000 | H |
| Canutillo 58 Pecos 36 | 2000-01 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Pecos 37 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo defeated Pecos | 2001-02 | T |
| Phoenix South Mountain (AZ) | 1-2 | |
| Canutillo 52 South Mountain 38 | 2016-17 | Hobbs |
| South Mountain 37 Canutillo 36 | 2017-18 | El Paso |
| South Mountain 44 Canutillo 29 | 2019-20 | Hobbs |
| Rio Rancho Cleveland (NM) | 0-3 | |
| Cleveland 58 Canutillo 32 | 2016-17 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 78 Canutillo 44 | 2017-18 | Hobbs |
| Cleveland 53 Canutillo 38 | 2019-20 | Hobbs |
| Roswell Goddard (NM) | 1-2 | |
| Goddard 67 Canutillo 51 | 1986-87 | Deming |
| Goddard 52 Canutillo 40 | 2001-02 | Silver City |
| Canutillo 66 Goddard 65 | 2002-03 | Silver City |
| San Angelo Central | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 70 Central 45 | 2008-09 | Pampa |
| San Antonio Jefferson | 0-2 | |
| Jefferson 80 Canutillo 39 | 2018-19 | El Paso |
| Roosevelt 64 Canutillo 63 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| San Elizario | 32-12 | |
| Canutillo 58 San Elizario 37 | 1987-88 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 80 San Elizario 38 | 1989-90 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo defeated San Elizario | 1992-93 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 67 San Elizario 65 | 1993-94 | El Paso |
| San Elizario defeated Canutillo | 1994-95 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 69 San Elizario 51 | 1994-95 | H |
| Canutillo 57 San Elizario 52 | 1995-96 | T |
| San Elizario 61 Canutillo 54 | 1996-97 | T |
| Canutillo 58 San Elizario 43 | 1996-97 | H |
| Canutillo 55 San Elizario 52 | 1997-98 | Clint |
| Canutillo 70 San Elizario 54 | 1997-98 | H |
| San Elizario 65 Canutillo 60 | 1997-98 | T |
| Canutillo 54 San Elizario 52 | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| San Elizario 51 Canutillo 45 | 1998-99 | H |
| San Elizario 50 Canutillo 46 | 1998-99 | H |
| Canutillo 54 San Elizario 48 | 99-2000 | H |
| San Elizario 49 Canutillo 43 | 99-2000 | T |
| Canutillo 47 San Elizario 36 | 2000-01 | H |
| San Elizario 50 Canutillo 46 | 2000-01 | T |
| Canutillo 36 San Elizario 34 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 40 San Elizario 39 | 2001-02 | T |
| Canutillo 55 San Elizario 51 | 2002-03 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 48 San Elizario 37 | 2002-03 | T |
| Canutillo 64 San Elizario 45 | 2003-04 | H |
| San Elizario 50 Canutillo 37 | 2006-07 | T |
| Canutillo 56 San Elizario 40 | 2006-07 | H |
| Canutillo 49 San Elizario 48 | 2007-08 | H |
| Canutillo 53 San Elizario 50 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 51 San Elizario 17 | 2008-09 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 50 San Elizario 38 | 2008-09 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 64 San Elizario 32 | 2008-09 | H |
| Canutillo 42 San Elizario 34 | 2008-09 | T |
| Canutillo 58 San Elizario 45 | 2009-10 | T |
| Canutillo 55 San Elizario 32 | 2009-10 | H |
| Canutillo 57 San Elizario 46 | 2010-11 | H |
| San Elizario 43 Canutillo 30 | 2010-11 | T |
| San Elizario 44 Canutillo 39 | 2011-12 | T |
| San Elizario 45 Canutillo 32 | 2011-12 | H |
| Canutillo 48 San Elizario 31 | 2012-13 | T |
| Canutillo 59 San Elizario 40 | 2012-13 | H |
| San Elizario 52 Canutillo 47 | 2013-14 | H |
| Canutillo 48 San Elizario 38 | 2013-14 | T |
| Canutillo 81 San Elizario 41 | 2018-19 | H |
| Canutillo 49 San Elizario 43 | 2023-24 | H |
| San Marcos | 0-1 | |
| San Marcos 55 Canutillo 39 | 2022-23 | San Marcos |
| Santa Teresa (NM) | 10-3 | |
| Canutillo 65 Santa Teresa 64 | 1995-96 | H |
| Santa Teresa 66 Canutillo 58 | 1996-97 | H |
| Canutillo 84 Santa Teresa 49 | 99-2000 | H |
| Canutillo 57 Santa Teresa 43 | 2000-01 | T |
| Canutillo 57 Santa Teresa 51 | 2000-01 | Clint |
| Canutillo 62 Santa Teresa 43 | 2000-01 | H |
| Canutillo 61 Santa Teresa 32 | 2001-02 | H |
| Canutillo 41 Santa Teresa 34 | 2001-02 | T |
| Canutillo 69 Santa Teresa 62 | 2005-06 | Canutillo |
| Canutillo 56 Santa Teresa 42 | 2006-07 | T |
| Santa Teresa 53 Canutillo 44 | 2007-08 | T |
| Canutillo 44 Santa Teresa 34 | 2008-09 | Canutillo |
| Santa Teresa 41 Canutillo 37 | 2011-12 | Canutillo |
| Shiprock (NM) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 62 Shiprock 35 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Silver City (NM) | 2-0 | |
| Canutillo 55 Silver City 51 | 2001-02 | Silver City |
| Canutillo 65 Silver City 54 | 2002-03 | Silver City |
| Spring Legacy of Sports Academy | 0-1 | |
| Legacy of Sports 48 Canutillo 45 | 2021-22 | El Paso |
| Tornillo | 6-0 | |
| Canutillo 37 Tornillo 30 | 1996-97 | Clint |
| Canutillo 54 Tornillo 51 | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| Canutillo defeated Tornillo | 2000-01 | Clint |
| Canutillo 53 Tornillo 29 | 2007-08 | El Paso |
| Canutillo 65 Tornillo 24 | 2017-18 | H |
| Canutillo 69 Tornillo 36 | 2023-24 | Anthony |
| Tucson (AZ) | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 46 Tucson 45 | 2016-17 | El Paso |
| Van Horn | 1-0 | |
| Canutillo 76 Van Horn 70 | 1989-90 | Van Horn |
| Wolfforth Frenship | 0-1 | |
| Frenship 46 Canutillo 43 | 2013-14 | S-Fort Stockton |
| woodland Hills Taft (CA) | 0-1 | |
| Taft 60 Canutillo 52 | 2017-18 | El Paso |
| unknown | ||
| unknown loss | 1986-87 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1986-87 | El Paso |
| unknown win | 1987-88 | |
| unknown loss | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1988-89 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1989-90 | Canutillo |
| unknown win | 1989-90 | |
| unknown loss | 1989-90 | |
| unknown loss | 1989-90 | |
| unknown win | 1990-91 | El Paso |
| unknown win | 1990-91 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1990-91 | El Paso |
| unknown win | 1990-91 | Van Horn |
| unknown win | 1990-91 | Van Horn |
| unknown loss | 1992-93 | El Paso |
| unknown win | 1992-93 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 1993-94 | El Paso |
| unknown win | 1993-94 | |
| unknown loss | 1994-95 | |
| unknown loss | 1995-96 | |
| unknown loss | 1998-99 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | Clint |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | Clint |
| unknown loss | 99-2000 | Clint |
| unknown loss | 2000-01 | |
| unknown loss | 2000-01 | |
| unknown win | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| unknown win | 2000-01 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 2001-02 | Fabens |
| unknown loss | 2001-02 | Clint |
| unknown win | 2003-04 | Fabens |
| unknown win | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 2004-05 | El Paso |
| unknown loss | 2006-07 | Fabens |
| unknown win | 2010-11 | Canutillo |
| unknown scores | ||
| Canutillo vs El Paso El Dorado | 2010-11 | T |