| Albuquerque West Mesa record vs | rec/yr | location |
| Alamogordo | 4-5 | |
| Alamogordo 54 West Mesa 50 | 1968-69 | S-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 61 Alamogordo 56 | 1985-86 | H |
| West Mesa 47 Alamogordo 39 | 1993-94 | S-Albuquerque |
| Alamogordo 62 West Mesa 61 | 1998-99 | T |
| Alamogordo 54 West Mesa 37 | 99-2000 | H |
| Alamogordo 81 West Mesa 70 | 2004-05 | T |
| Alamogordo 72 West Mesa 60 | 2008-09 | Alamogordo |
| West Mesa 48 Alamogordo 47 | 2010-11 | T |
| West Mesa 54 Alamogordo 48 | 2011-12 | H |
| Albuquerque | 36-80 | |
| Albuquerque 52 West Mesa 36 | 1966-67 | H |
| West Mesa 51 Albuquerque 48 | 1967-68 | T |
| Albuquerque 54 West Mesa 44 | 1967-68 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 69 Albuquerque 67 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 56 Albuquerque 50 | 1968-69 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 72 Albuquerque 62 | 1968-69 | H |
| Albuquerque 68 West Mesa 42 | 1969-70 | H |
| West Mesa 55 Albuquerque 54 | 1969-70 | T |
| West Mesa 55 Albuquerque 53 | 1969-70 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 70 West Mesa 48 | 1970-71 | T |
| Albuquerque 50 West Mesa 41 | 1970-71 | H |
| Albuquerque 66 West Mesa 43 | 1971-72 | H |
| Albuquerque 72 West Mesa 44 | 1971-72 | T |
| Albuquerque 48 West Mesa 47 | 1972-73 | T |
| Albuquerque 49 West Mesa 46 | 1972-73 | H |
| Albuquerque 55 West Mesa 37 | 1973-74 | H |
| Albuquerque 70 West Mesa 58 | 1973-74 | T |
| Albuquerque 63 West Mesa 59 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Albuquerque 53 | 1974-75 | H |
| Albuquerque 56 West Mesa 48 | 1974-75 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 64 Albuquerque 63 | 1975-76 | H |
| Albuquerque 68 West Mesa 63 | 1975-76 | T |
| Albuquerque 54 West Mesa 53 | 1975-76 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 67 West Mesa 57 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Albuquerque 57 | 1976-77 | H |
| Albuquerque 88 West Mesa 70 | 1977-78 | H |
| Albuquerque 56 West Mesa 54 | 1977-78 | T |
| Albuquerque 60 West Mesa 55 | 1977-78 | DT-T |
| Albuquerque 70 West Mesa 51 | 1978-79 | T |
| Albuquerque 57 West Mesa 52 | 1978-79 | H |
| Albuquerque 69 West Mesa 50 | 1979-80 | H |
| Albuquerque 70 West Mesa 47 | 1979-80 | H |
| Albuquerque 54 West Mesa 43 | 1980-81 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 67 West Mesa 49 | 1980-81 | T |
| Albuquerque 66 West Mesa 60 | 1980-81 | H |
| Albuquerque 61 West Mesa 50 | 1981-82 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Albuquerque 55 | 1981-82 | T |
| Albuquerque 79 West Mesa 50 | 1982-83 | T |
| Albuquerque 58 West Mesa 51 | 1982-83 | H |
| Albuquerque 68 West Mesa 47 | 1983-84 | H |
| Albuquerque 60 West Mesa 53 | 1983-84 | T |
| West Mesa 78 Albuquerque 64 | 1984-85 | T |
| Albuquerque 77 West Mesa 61 | 1984-85 | H |
| Albuquerque 48 West Mesa 46 | 1985-86 | H |
| Albuquerque 59 West Mesa 56 | 1985-86 | T |
| Albuquerque 65 West Mesa 46 | 1986-87 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 73 West Mesa 65 | 1986-87 | T |
| Albuquerque 65 West Mesa 58 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Albuquerque 66 | 1987-88 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Albuquerque 54 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 83 Albuquerque 77 | 1988-89 | H |
| Albuquerque 64 West Mesa 53 | 1988-89 | T |
| Albuquerque 84 West Mesa 63 | 1989-90 | T |
| Albuquerque 63 West Mesa 60 | 1989-90 | H |
| Albuquerque 70 West Mesa 59 | 1990-91 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 66 West Mesa 56 | 1990-91 | H |
| Albuquerque 86 West Mesa 68 | 1990-91 | T |
| Albuquerque 94 West Mesa 54 | 1991-92 | H |
| Albuquerque 63 West Mesa 49 | 1991-92 | T |
| Albuquerque 44 West Mesa 39 | 1991-92 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 73 Albuquerque 71 FL | 1992-93 | H |
| Albuquerque 79 West Mesa 61 | 1992-93 | S-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 74 Albuquerque 59 | 1993-94 | T |
| West Mesa 55 Albuquerque 53 | 1994-95 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 78 West Mesa 55 | 1994-95 | H |
| Albuquerque 71 West Mesa 58 | 1994-95 | T |
| Albuquerque 72 West Mesa 48 | 1995-96 | T |
| Albuquerque 47 West Mesa 37 | 1995-96 | H |
| Albuquerque 65 West Mesa 41 | 1996-97 | T |
| Albuquerque 84 West Mesa 70 | 1997-98 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 78 West Mesa 61 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Albuquerque 61 | 1998-99 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Albuquerque 62 | 99-2000 | T |
| Albuquerque 68 West Mesa 48 | 2000-01 | H |
| Albuquerque 69 West Mesa 34 | 2000-01 | T |
| Albuquerque 60 West Mesa 50 | 2001-02 | T |
| West Mesa 47 Albuquerque 43 | 2001-02 | H |
| Albuquerque 63 West Mesa 33 | 2001-02 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 69 Albuquerque 50 | 2002-03 | T |
| Albuquerque 53 West Mesa 52 | 2003-04 | H |
| Albuquerque 59 West Mesa 44 | 2003-04 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 70 Albuquerque 41 | 2004-05 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 61 Albuquerque 47 | 2004-05 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Albuquerque 57 | 2005-06 | T |
| Albuquerque 68 West Mesa 67 | 2006-07 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Albuquerque 63 | 2007-08 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque 75 West Mesa 56 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 56 Albuquerque 52 | 2008-09 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 62 Albuquerque 54 | 2008-09 | H |
| Albuquerque 50 West Mesa 43 | 2009-10 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Albuquerque 67 | 2010-11 | H |
| Albuquerque 63 West Mesa 63 | 2010-11 | T |
| Albuquerque 65 West Mesa 42 | 2011-12 | T |
| Albuquerque 65 West Mesa 54 | 2011-12 | H |
| Albuquerque 50 West Mesa 40 | 2012-13 | H |
| Albuquerque 45 West Mesa 38 | 2012-13 | T |
| Albuquerque 69 West Mesa 61 | 2012-13 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 66 Albuquerque 57 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 64 Albuquerque 55 | 2013-14 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Albuquerque 70 | 2013-14 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Albuquerque 62 | 2013-14 | DT-H |
| Albuquerque 54 West Mesa 52 | 2014-15 | H |
| Albuquerque 68 West Mesa 51 | 2014-15 | T |
| Albuquerque 57 West Mesa 55 | 2014-15 | DT-T |
| Albuquerque 53 West Mesa 36 | 2015-16 | T |
| Albuquerque 55 West Mesa 39 | 2015-16 | H |
| West Mesa 55 Albuquerque 50 | 2016-17 | T |
| Albuquerque 53 West Mesa 47 | 2016-17 | H |
| Albuquerque 56 West Mesa 40 | 2016-17 | DT-T |
| Albuquerque 66 West Mesa 63 | 2017-18 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Albuquerque 56 | 2017-18 | T |
| West Mesa 45 Albuquerque 40 | 2017-18 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 68 Albuquerque 54 | 2018-19 | T |
| Albuquerque 73 West Mesa 62 | 2019-20 | H |
| West Mesa 63 Albuquerque 46 | 2021-22 | T |
| Albuquerque 53 West Mesa 47 | 2023-24 | H |
| Albuquerque Academy | 15-6 | |
| West Mesa 54 Academy 38 | 1973-74 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 60 Academy 46 | 1984-85 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Academy 45 | 1985-86 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Academy 58 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 81 Academy 61 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa defeated Academy | 1988-89 | H |
| Academy 77 West Mesa 59 | 1989-90 | Albuquerque |
| Academy 77 West Mesa 56 | 1989-90 | T |
| West Mesa 64 Academy 56 | 1990-91 | H |
| Academy 81 West Mesa 57 | 1991-92 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Academy 59 | 1994-95 | T |
| Academy 91 West Mesa 63 | 1995-96 | Albuquerque |
| Academy 68 West Mesa 62 | 1995-96 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Academy 55 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| Academy 63 West Mesa 54 | 2006-07 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Academy 63 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Academy 53 | 2009-10 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 43 Academy 36 | 2012-13 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Academy 55 | 2013-14 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Academy 37 | 2016-17 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Academy 50 | 2017-18 | T |
| Albuquerque Atrisco Heritage | 7-16 | |
| West Mesa 55 Atrisco Heritage 50 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Atrisco Heritage 63 | 2012-13 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Atrisco Heritage 46 | 2012-13 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 68 Atrisco Heritage 64 | 2013-14 | T |
| Atrisco Heritage 77 West Mesa 65 | 2013-14 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 76 West Mesa 69 | 2013-14 | DT-T |
| Atrisco Heritage 61 West Mesa 58 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 61 Atrisco Heritage 56 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 50 Atrisco Heritage 45 | 2014-15 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 47 West Mesa 28 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| Atrisco Heritage 57 West Mesa 46 | 2015-16 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 68 West Mesa 50 | 2015-16 | T |
| Atrisco Heritage 63 West Mesa 48 | 2015-16 | DT-T |
| Atrisco Heritage 61 West Mesa 56 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| Atrisco Heritage 47 West Mesa 41 | 2016-17 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 50 West Mesa 42 | 2016-17 | T |
| Atrisco Heritage 71 West Mesa 56 | 2017-18 | T |
| Atrisco Heritage 59 West Mesa 49 | 2017-18 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 60 West Mesa 52 | 2018-19 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Atrisco Heritage 49 | 2019-20 | T |
| Atrisco Heritage 64 West Mesa 58 | 2022-23 | H |
| Atrisco Heritage 81 West Mesa 54 | 2023-24 | T |
| Atrisco Heritage 66 West Mesa 64 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Cibola | 34-35 | |
| West Mesa 92 Cibola 48 | 1975-76 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Cibola 59 | 1976-77 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 67 Cibola 57 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 89 Cibola 74 | 1977-78 | H |
| West Mesa 75 Cibola 67 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 82 Cibola 69 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Cibola 64 | 1980-81 | T |
| Cibola 64 West Mesa 61 | 1981-82 | H |
| Cibola 73 West Mesa 56 | 1982-83 | T |
| West Mesa 79 Cibola 66 | 1982-83 | Albuquerque |
| Cibola 60 West Mesa 59 | 1983-84 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Cibola 52 | 1983-84 | H |
| Cibola 67 West Mesa 55 | 1984-85 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Cibola 55 | 1985-86 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Cibola 59 | 1985-86 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 68 Cibola 54 | 1986-87 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 54 Cibola 50 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Cibola 51 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 79 Cibola 74 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Cibola 47 | 1988-89 | H |
| West Mesa 60 Cibola 55 | 1989-90 | H |
| Cibola 78 West Mesa 62 | 1989-90 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Cibola 55 | 1990-91 | Albuquerque |
| Cibola 67 West Mesa 62 | 1990-91 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Cibola 64 | 1990-91 | H |
| Cibola 83 West Mesa 60 | 1991-92 | H |
| Cibola 83 West Mesa 59 | 1991-92 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Cibola 75 | 1991-92 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Cibola 67 West Mesa 64 | 1992-93 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Cibola 59 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 50 Cibola 47 | 1994-95 | T |
| Cibola 74 West Mesa 59 | 1995-96 | H |
| Cibola 85 West Mesa 50 | 1996-97 | T |
| Cibola 70 West Mesa 56 | 1997-98 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cibola 67 West Mesa 65 | 1998-99 | S-Albuquerque |
| Cibola 66 West Mesa 48 | 99-2000 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 58 Cibola 53 | 2000-01 | H |
| Cibola 61 West Mesa 50 | 2000-01 | T |
| Cibola 63 West Mesa 45 | 2001-02 | T |
| Cibola 70 West Mesa 42 | 2001-02 | H |
| Cibola 63 West Mesa 55 | 2002-03 | H |
| Cibola 59 West Mesa 49 | 2002-03 | T |
| Cibola 76 West Mesa 62 | 2003-04 | T |
| Cibola 68 West Mesa 62 | 2003-04 | H |
| Cibola 61 West Mesa 27 | 2005-06 | T |
| Cibola 48 West Mesa 41 | 2005-06 | H |
| Cibola 60 West Mesa 55 | 2005-06 | T |
| West Mesa 50 Cibola 47 | 2006-07 | H |
| Cibola 59 West Mesa 51 | 2006-07 | T |
| Cibola 46 West Mesa 38 | 2006-07 | H |
| Cibola 59 West Mesa 36 | 2007-08 | T |
| Cibola 62 West Mesa 47 | 2007-08 | H |
| Cibola 76 West Mesa 63 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 43 Cibola 29 | 2008-09 | H |
| Cibola 71 West Mesa 58 | 2008-09 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Cibola 44 | 2008-09 | H |
| Cibola 59 West Mesa 58 | 2008-09 | DT-H |
| Cibola 41 West Mesa 29 | 2009-10 | H |
| West Mesa 60 Cibola 51 | 2009-10 | T |
| West Mesa 50 Cibola 47 | 2010-11 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 72 Cibola 52 | 2013-14 | H |
| Cibola 67 West Mesa 54 | 2015-16 | H |
| Cibola 57 West Mesa 38 | 2016-17 | T |
| West Mesa 56 Cibola 54 | 2017-18 | T |
| Cibola 59 West Mesa 58 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 61 Cibola 58 | 2021-22 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Cibola 47 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 73 Cibola 57 | 2023-24 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Cibola 63 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Del Norte | 48-30 | |
| Del Norte 55 West Mesa 35 | 1966-67 | H |
| Del Norte 50 West Mesa 48 | 1966-67 | T |
| Del Norte 60 West Mesa 41 | 1967-68 | T |
| Del Norte 50 West Mesa 46 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 49 Del Norte 41 | 1968-69 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Del Norte 52 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 56 Del Norte 45 | 1969-70 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Del Norte 59 | 1969-70 | H |
| Del Norte 47 West Mesa 41 | 1970-71 | H |
| West Mesa 52 Del Norte 44 | 1970-71 | T |
| Del Norte 59 West Mesa 50 | 1971-72 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Del Norte 56 | 1971-72 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Del Norte 57 | 1972-73 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Del Norte 66 | 1972-73 | T |
| Del Norte 51 West Mesa 49 | 1973-74 | Santa Fe |
| Del Norte 57 West Mesa 53 | 1973-74 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Del Norte 55 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Del Norte 64 | 1975-76 | H |
| Del Norte 59 West Mesa 48 | 1976-77 | T |
| Del Norte 74 West Mesa 57 | 1976-77 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Del Norte 70 | 1977-78 | H |
| Del Norte 95 West Mesa 89 | 1978-79 | T |
| Del Norte 67 West Mesa 59 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 62 Del Norte 58 | 1979-80 | Albuquerque |
| Del Norte 56 West Mesa 55 | 1980-81 | T |
| Del Norte 64 West Mesa 46 | 1981-82 | T |
| West Mesa 53 Del Norte 52 | 1981-82 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 78 Del Norte 69 | 1982-83 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Del Norte 54 | 1983-84 | T |
| Del Norte 68 West Mesa 63 | 1983-84 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 Del Norte 47 | 1984-85 | H |
| West Mesa 34 Del Norte 39 | 1985-86 | T |
| Del Norte 56 West Mesa 51 | 1985-86 | Albuquerque |
| Del Norte 60 West Mesa 51 | 1986-87 | Albuquerque |
| Del Norte 55 West Mesa 49 | 1986-87 | H |
| Del Norte 63 West Mesa 48 | 1987-88 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 Del Norte 57 | 1987-88 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Del Norte 51 | 1988-89 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 79 Del Norte 66 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 52 Del Norte 49 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 52 Del Norte 45 | 1989-90 | H |
| West Mesa 50 Del Norte 47 | 1989-90 | T |
| West Mesa 54 Del Norte 37 | 1990-91 | H |
| Del Norte 50 West Mesa 40 | 1990-91 | T |
| Del Norte 90 West Mesa 72 | 1991-92 | H |
| West Mesa defeated Del Norte | 1991-92 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Del Norte 55 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Del Norte 54 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Del Norte 61 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Del Norte 57 | 1993-94 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Del Norte 42 | 1993-94 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 73 Del Norte 56 | 1994-95 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Del Norte 57 | 1995-96 | T |
| Del Norte 61 West Mesa 44 | 1996-97 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Del Norte 62 | 1996-97 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Del Norte 55 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Del Norte 65 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Del Norte 64 | 1998-99 | T |
| West Mesa 89 Del Norte 62 | 1998-99 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Del Norte 59 | 1998-99 | DT-H |
| Del Norte 84 West Mesa 73 | 99-2000 | H |
| West Mesa 77 Del Norte 65 | 99-2000 | T |
| West Mesa 80 Del Norte 55 | 2000-01 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 53 Del Norte 48 | 2000-01 | T |
| West Mesa 41 Del Norte 40 | 2001-02 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Del Norte 61 | 2003-04 | Albuquerque |
| Del Norte 92 West Mesa 54 | 2005-06 | T |
| Del Norte 56 West Mesa 49 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 72 Del Norte 52 | 2013-14 | T |
| Del Norte 68 West Mesa 59 | 2016-17 | T |
| Del Norte 66 West Mesa 55 | 2016-17 | T |
| West Mesa 51 Del Norte 46 | 2017-18 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Del Norte 42 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 54 Del Norte 52 | 2019-20 | T |
| Del Norte 76 West Mesa 67 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Del Norte 48 West Mesa 40 | 2021-22 | T |
| Del Norte 63 West Mesa 62 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Del Norte 38 | 2023-24 | H |
| Albuquerque Eldorado | 30-45 | |
| West Mesa 62 Eldorado 48 | 1970-71 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Eldorado 48 | 1971-72 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Eldorado 50 | 1971-72 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Eldorado 47 | 1972-73 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Eldorado 61 | 1972-73 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Eldorado 63 | 1973-74 | H |
| Eldorado 64 West Mesa 62 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Eldorado 57 | 1975-76 | H |
| West Mesa 78 Eldorado 42 | 1975-76 | T |
| Eldorado 69 West Mesa 67 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Eldorado 69 | 1977-78 | H |
| Eldorado 68 West Mesa 66 | 1977-78 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 82 West Mesa 77 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Eldorado 54 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Eldorado 57 | 1980-81 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 80 West Mesa 52 | 1981-82 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 68 West Mesa 50 | 1983-84 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Eldorado 53 | 1984-85 | T |
| Eldorado 55 West Mesa 52 | 1985-86 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 69 Eldorado 57 | 1985-86 | H |
| Eldorado 59 West Mesa 56 | 1986-87 | T |
| West Mesa 70 Eldorado 63 | 1987-88 | H |
| Eldorado 57 West Mesa 51 | 1988-89 | H |
| Eldorado 66 West Mesa 65 | 1988-89 | T |
| Eldorado 53 West Mesa 50 | 1989-90 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Eldorado 58 | 1989-90 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Eldorado 45 | 1990-91 | H |
| Eldorado 70 West Mesa 59 | 1990-91 | T |
| Eldorado 70 West Mesa 68 | 1990-91 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 59 West Mesa 58 | 1991-92 | T |
| Eldorado 63 West Mesa 62 | 1991-92 | H |
| West Mesa 73 Eldorado 69 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 52 Eldorado 45 | 1993-94 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Eldorado 61 | 1994-95 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 76 West Mesa 60 | 1994-95 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Eldorado 75 | 1995-96 | H |
| Eldorado 60 West Mesa 58 | 1996-97 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 58 West Mesa 41 | 1996-97 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Eldorado 59 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Eldorado 62 | 1998-99 | T |
| Eldorado 72 West Mesa 59 | 99-2000 | H |
| Eldorado 76 West Mesa 61 | 2000-01 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 58 West Mesa 36 | 2000-01 | T |
| Eldorado 43 West Mesa 41 | 2001-02 | H |
| Eldorado 54 West Mesa 53 | 2002-03 | T |
| Eldorado 71 West Mesa 46 | 2003-04 | H |
| Eldorado 60 West Mesa 30 | 2004-05 | H |
| Eldorado 70 West Mesa 47 | 2004-05 | T |
| Eldorado 61 West Mesa 44 | 2005-06 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Eldorado 64 | 2007-08 | H |
| Eldorado 57 West Mesa 35 | 2009-10 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 64 West Mesa 53 | 2010-11 | H |
| Eldorado 63 West Mesa 62 | 2011-12 | T |
| Eldorado 72 West Mesa 47 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Eldorado 53 | 2013-14 | H |
| Eldorado 61 West Mesa 44 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 63 West Mesa 56 | 2015-16 | T |
| Eldorado 44 West Mesa 30 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 45 West Mesa 44 | 2016-17 | H |
| Eldorado 79 West Mesa 68 | 2017-18 | S-Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 69 West Mesa 47 | 2018-19 | T |
| Eldorado 54 West Mesa 37 | 2018-19 | H |
| Eldorado 70 West Mesa 69 | 2018-19 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 65 Eldorado 47 | 2019-20 | H |
| Eldorado 86 West Mesa 65 | 2019-20 | T |
| Eldorado 83 West Mesa 73 | 2019-20 | DT-T |
| Eldorado 47 West Mesa 40 | 2020-21 | H |
| Eldorado 60 West Mesa 54 | 2021-22 | H |
| Eldorado 64 West Mesa 62 | 2021-22 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Eldorado 55 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Eldorado 58 West Mesa 54 | 2022-23 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Eldorado 53 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 77 Eldorado 55 | 2022-23 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 72 Eldorado 66 | 2023-24 | H |
| West Mesa 59 Eldorado 58 | 2023-24 | T |
| Albuquerque Highland | 40-44 | |
| Highland 68 West Mesa 25 | 1966-67 | T |
| West Mesa 50 Highland 44 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Highland 56 | 1968-69 | H |
| Highland 70 West Mesa 65 | 1968-69 | T |
| Highland 58 West Mesa 41 | 1968-69 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 44 Highland 40 | 1969-70 | H |
| Highland 47 West Mesa 45 | 1969-70 | T |
| West Mesa 46 Highland 45 | 1969-70 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Highland 52 West Mesa 33 | 1970-71 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 38 West Mesa 35 | 1970-71 | T |
| West Mesa 52 Highland 42 | 1970-71 | H |
| Highland 49 West Mesa 37 | 1970-71 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Highland 53 West Mesa 49 | 1971-72 | H |
| Highland 76 West Mesa 48 | 1971-72 | T |
| Highland 57 West Mesa 43 | 1972-73 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 56 Highland 51 | 1972-73 | T |
| Highland 54 West Mesa 50 | 1972-73 | H |
| Highland 57 West Mesa 52 | 1973-74 | H |
| Highland 54 West Mesa 52 | 1974-75 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 53 West Mesa 48 | 1974-75 | T |
| Highland 62 West Mesa 59 | 1974-75 | H |
| Highland 65 West Mesa 53 | 1975-76 | T |
| Highland 43 West Mesa 38 | 1975-76 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 57 West Mesa 55 | 1976-77 | H |
| West Mesa 85 Highland 83 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 70 Highland 39 | 1978-79 | H |
| Highland 87 West Mesa 72 | 1979-80 | T |
| Highland 51 West Mesa 50 | 1980-81 | H |
| Highland 68 West Mesa 44 | 1981-82 | T |
| West Mesa 62 Highland 53 | 1982-83 | H |
| West Mesa 53 Highland 48 | 1983-84 | T |
| Highland 76 West Mesa 54 | 1983-84 | H |
| Highland 67 West Mesa 58 | 1984-85 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Highland 67 | 1984-85 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Highland 56 | 1985-86 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Highland 57 | 1985-86 | H |
| Highland 51 West Mesa 46 | 1986-87 | H |
| Highland 74 West Mesa 59 | 1986-87 | T |
| West Mesa 80 Highland 76 | 1986-87 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 59 Highland 55 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 88 Highland 77 | 1987-88 | H |
| Highland 48 West Mesa 43 | 1987-88 | DT-H |
| Highland 53 West Mesa 45 | 1988-89 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 50 Highland 47 | 1988-89 | H |
| Highland 70 West Mesa 60 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 62 Highland 44 | 1989-90 | T |
| West Mesa 70 Highland 58 | 1989-90 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Highland 47 | 1990-91 | H |
| Highland 59 West Mesa 49 | 1990-91 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Highland 50 | 1990-91 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Highland 78 West Mesa 58 | 1991-92 | T |
| Highland 81 West Mesa 60 | 1991-92 | H |
| Highland 65 West Mesa 49 | 1992-93 | Albuquerque |
| Highland defeated West Mesa | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Highland 43 | 1993-94 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 59 Highland 50 | 1993-94 | T |
| West Mesa 62 Highland 52 | 1994-95 | H |
| Highland 92 West Mesa 60 | 1995-96 | T |
| West Mesa 94 Highland 78 | 1996-97 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 81 Highland 78 | 99-2000 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 76 Highland 52 | 2002-03 | T |
| Highland 56 West Mesa 53 | 2003-04 | H |
| Highland 55 West Mesa 46 | 2005-06 | T |
| Highland 66 West Mesa 53 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 79 West Mesa 58 | 2007-08 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 52 Highland 48 | 2010-11 | H |
| West Mesa 82 Highland 56 | 2010-11 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Highland 59 | 2011-12 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Highland 52 | 2011-12 | H |
| West Mesa 47 Highland 35 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 41 Highland 34 | 2012-13 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Highland 46 | 2012-13 | DT-H |
| Highland 73 West Mesa 63 | 2013-14 | T |
| Highland 68 West Mesa 64 | 2013-14 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Highland 70 | 2013-14 | DT-T |
| Highland 83 West Mesa 63 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 Highland 37 | 2016-17 | T |
| West Mesa 45 Highland 37 | 2016-17 | H |
| West Mesa 55 Highland 51 | 2017-18 | H |
| West Mesa 78 Highland 44 | 2017-18 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Highland 67 | 2017-18 | DT-H |
| Highland 65 West Mesa 47 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Highland 56 West Mesa 55 | 2023-24 | H |
| Highland 55 West Mesa 49 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Hope Christian | 3-7 | |
| West Mesa 70 Hope Christian 62 | 2004-05 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 68 Hope Christian 64 | 2007-08 | Albuquerque |
| Hope Christian 66 West Mesa 50 | 2010-11 | Albuquerque |
| Hope Christian 68 West Mesa 44 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 51 Hope Christian 50 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| Hope Christian 70 West Mesa 60 | 2013-14 | H |
| Hope Christian 54 West Mesa 51 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Hope Christian 63 West Mesa 42 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Hope Christian 62 West Mesa 53 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| Hope Christian 55 West Mesa 52 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Indian School | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 63 Indian School 47 | 1966-67 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Indian School 49 | 1967-68 | H |
| Albuquerque La Cueva | 19-47 | |
| West Mesa 64 La Cueva 54 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 77 La Cueva 56 | 1986-87 | T |
| La Cueva 62 West Mesa 60 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 69 La Cueva 62 | 1987-88 | H |
| La Cueva 74 West Mesa 65 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 57 La Cueva 55 | 1989-90 | H |
| La Cueva 83 West Mesa 66 | 1990-91 | T |
| La Cueva 86 West Mesa 69 | 1991-92 | H |
| La Cueva 69 West Mesa 58 | 1992-93 | T |
| La Cueva 70 West Mesa 53 | 1993-94 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 59 La Cueva 53 | 1993-94 | H |
| La Cueva 64 West Mesa 55 | 1993-94 | SC-Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 77 West Mesa 58 | 1994-95 | T |
| La Cueva 60 West Mesa 45 | 1994-95 | H |
| West Mesa 61 La Cueva 59 | 1995-96 | H |
| La Cueva 56 West Mesa 46 | 1995-96 | T |
| La Cueva 62 West Mesa 56 | 1996-97 | H |
| La Cueva 62 West Mesa 57 | 1996-97 | T |
| West Mesa 62 La Cueva 60 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 82 La Cueva 76 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 73 La Cueva 69 | 1997-98 | DT-H |
| La Cueva 82 West Mesa 63 | 1998-99 | H |
| La Cueva 73 West Mesa 68 | 1998-99 | T |
| La Cueva 78 West Mesa 55 | 1998-99 | DT-T |
| La Cueva 77 West Mesa 66 | 99-2000 | T |
| West Mesa 91 La Cueva 86 | 99-2000 | H |
| La Cueva 69 West Mesa 49 | 2000-01 | H |
| West Mesa 54 La Cueva 45 | 2001-02 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 71 West Mesa 43 | 2001-02 | T |
| La Cueva 61 West Mesa 40 | 2002-03 | H |
| La Cueva 88 West Mesa 43 | 2003-04 | T |
| La Cueva 68 West Mesa 50 | 2005-06 | H |
| La Cueva 72 West Mesa 57 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 62 West Mesa 47 | 2006-07 | T |
| La Cueva 97 West Mesa 89 | 2007-08 | H |
| La Cueva 57 West Mesa 44 | 2008-09 | T |
| La Cueva 78 West Mesa 54 | 2009-10 | H |
| West Mesa 65 La Cueva 58 | 2010-11 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 52 West Mesa 45 | 2010-11 | H |
| La Cueva 73 West Mesa 54 | 2011-12 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 71 West Mesa 59 | 2012-13 | H |
| La Cueva 71 West Mesa 55 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 62 La Cueva 56 | 2013-14 | T |
| La Cueva 62 West Mesa 51 | 2015-16 | T |
| La Cueva 78 West Mesa 58 | 2017-18 | T |
| La Cueva 71 West Mesa 50 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 65 West Mesa 40 | 2018-19 | T |
| La Cueva 54 West Mesa 47 | 2018-19 | H |
| La Cueva 73 West Mesa 53 | 2019-20 | H |
| La Cueva 65 West Mesa 54 | 2019-20 | T |
| La Cueva 55 West Mesa 52 | 2020-21 | T |
| La Cueva 59 West Mesa 37 | 2020-21 | H |
| La Cueva 71 West Mesa 46 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 60 West Mesa 44 | 2021-22 | T |
| West Mesa 50 La Cueva 47 | 2021-22 | T |
| La Cueva 57 West Mesa 34 | 2021-22 | S-T |
| West Mesa 67 La Cueva 66 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 77 La Cueva 63 | 2022-23 | T |
| La Cueva 68 West Mesa 63 | 2023-24 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 La Cueva 55 | 2023-24 | T |
| La Cueva 71 West Mesa 63 | 2023-24 | H |
| West Mesa 56 La Cueva 53 | 2023-24 | TB-Albuquerque |
| La Cueva 77 West Mesa 60 | 2023-24 | DT-H |
| Albuquerque Manzano | 35-43 | |
| Manzano 85 West Mesa 48 | 1966-67 | T |
| Manzano 64 West Mesa 45 | 1966-67 | H |
| Manzano 55 West Mesa 38 | 1966-67 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 61 Manzano 60 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Manzano 65 | 1967-68 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Manzano 54 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Manzano 54 | 1968-69 | H |
| West Mesa 59 Manzano 46 | 1968-69 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Manzano 45 West Mesa 40 | 1969-70 | H |
| Manzano 62 West Mesa 49 | 1969-70 | T |
| Manzano 42 West Mesa 27 | 1970-71 | T |
| West Mesa 51 Manzano 50 | 1970-71 | H |
| Manzano 61 West Mesa 47 | 1971-72 | H |
| Manzano 62 West Mesa 48 | 1971-72 | T |
| Manzano 63 West Mesa 40 | 1971-72 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Manzano 62 West Mesa 60 | 1972-73 | T |
| West Mesa 47 Manzano 40 | 1972-73 | T |
| Manzano 61 West Mesa 55 | 1973-74 | H |
| Manzano 66 West Mesa 56 | 1974-75 | T |
| Manzano 72 West Mesa 69 | 1975-76 | H |
| Manzano 65 West Mesa 50 | 1976-77 | T |
| Manzano 64 West Mesa 47 | 1976-77 | Albuquerque |
| Manzano 66 West Mesa 60 | 1977-78 | H |
| Manzano 66 West Mesa 51 | 1977-78 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 74 Manzano 66 | 1978-79 | T |
| Manzano 69 West Mesa 48 | 1979-80 | H |
| Manzano 64 West Mesa 63 | 1979-80 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 62 Manzano 51 | 1981-82 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 79 Manzano 75 | 1983-84 | T |
| Manzano 62 West Mesa 60 | 1983-84 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 69 Manzano 59 | 1984-85 | H |
| West Mesa 60 Manzano 48 | 1985-86 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Manzano 61 | 1987-88 | Albuquerque |
| Manzano 76 West Mesa 73 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Manzano 72 | 1988-89 | H |
| Manzano 62 West Mesa 44 | 1988-89 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 66 Manzano 65 | 1989-90 | H |
| West Mesa 83 Manzano 79 | 1989-90 | T |
| Manzano 70 West Mesa 65 | 1989-90 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 91 Manzano 78 | 1990-91 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Manzano 65 | 1990-91 | H |
| Manzano 66 West Mesa 58 | 1991-92 | H |
| Manzano 88 West Mesa 69 | 1991-92 | T |
| Manzano 52 West Mesa 48 | 1992-93 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 66 Manzano 65 | 1992-93 | T |
| West Mesa 90 Manzano 60 | 1993-94 | H |
| Manzano 74 West Mesa 64 | 1994-95 | H |
| Manzano 73 West Mesa 62 | 1994-95 | T |
| Manzano 51 West Mesa 49 | 1994-95 | DT-T |
| Manzano 81 West Mesa 75 | 1995-96 | T |
| Manzano 63 West Mesa 51 | 1995-96 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Manzano 58 | 1996-97 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Manzano 64 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Manzano 51 | 1998-99 | H |
| Manzano 71 West Mesa 57 | 99-2000 | T |
| Manzano 65 West Mesa 63 | 2000-01 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Manzano 60 | 2001-02 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 57 Manzano 52 | 2001-02 | T |
| Manzano 61 West Mesa 50 | 2002-03 | H |
| Manzano 51 West Mesa 49 | 2003-04 | T |
| Manzano 42 West Mesa 41 | 2004-05 | H |
| Manzano 64 West Mesa 48 | 2006-07 | H |
| Manzano 42 West Mesa 36 | 2007-08 | T |
| Manzano 48 West Mesa 38 | 2009-10 | H |
| Manzano 55 West Mesa 41 | 2009-10 | T |
| Manzano 55 West Mesa 44 | 2011-12 | T |
| Manzano 45 West Mesa 41 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 45 Manzano 32 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 53 Manzano 36 | 2014-15 | H |
| West Mesa 53 Manzano 32 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Manzano 57 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 56 Manzano 40 | 2016-17 | H |
| West Mesa 84 Manzano 76 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 65 Manzano 61 | 2017-18 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Manzano 53 | 2017-18 | S-H |
| Manzano 54 West Mesa 52 | 2019-20 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Manzano 46 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Manzano 59 | 2023-24 | T |
| Albuquerque Menaul | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 81 Menaul 45 | 2022-23 | Rio Rancho |
| Albuquerque Rio Grande | 68-40 | |
| Rio Grande 95 West Mesa 35 | 1966-67 | H |
| Rio Grande 65 West Mesa 42 | 1966-67 | T |
| Rio Grande 63 West Mesa 49 | 1967-68 | T |
| Rio Grande 63 West Mesa 54 | 1967-68 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 55 West Mesa 48 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Rio Grande 61 | 1967-68 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 92 Rio Grande 57 | 1968-69 | H |
| West Mesa 84 Rio Grande 62 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 83 Rio Grande 43 | 1968-69 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 76 Rio Grande 60 | 1969-70 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Rio Grande 54 | 1969-70 | H |
| West Mesa 49 Rio Grande 38 | 1970-71 | H |
| West Mesa 49 Rio Grande 43 | 1970-71 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 70 Rio Grande 43 | 1970-71 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Rio Grande 53 | 1971-72 | T |
| West Mesa 58 Rio Grande 54 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 Rio Grande 36 | 1971-72 | H |
| West Mesa 51 Rio Grande 47 | 1972-73 | H |
| West Mesa 80 Rio Grande 63 | 1972-73 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Rio Grande 55 | 1973-74 | T |
| Rio Grande 58 West Mesa 55 | 1974-75 | H |
| West Mesa 82 Rio Grande 77 | 1975-76 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 62 Rio Grande 59 | 1975-76 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Rio Grande 57 | 1976-77 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Rio Grande 73 | 1977-78 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 81 Rio Grande 70 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 78 Rio Grande 64 | 1978-79 | Las Cruces |
| West Mesa 78 Rio Grande 69 | 1978-79 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Rio Grande 46 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Rio Grande 61 | 1980-81 | T |
| West Mesa 77 Rio Grande 61 | 1981-82 | H |
| West Mesa defeated Rio Grande | 1982-83 | H |
| West Mesa 54 Rio Grande 52 | 1983-84 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Rio Grande 49 | 1983-84 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 72 West Mesa 62 | 1983-84 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Rio Grande 64 | 1983-84 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 60 West Mesa 52 | 1984-85 | T |
| Rio Grande 63 West Mesa 61 | 1984-85 | H |
| Rio Grande 71 West Mesa 64 | 1984-85 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 46 Rio Grande 29 | 1985-86 | T |
| Rio Grande 53 West Mesa 47 | 1985-86 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Rio Grande 46 | 1985-86 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 54 Rio Grande 53 | 1986-87 | T |
| West Mesa 54 Rio Grande 50 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Rio Grande 60 | 1986-87 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 61 Rio Grande 53 | 1987-88 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Rio Grande 60 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 77 Rio Grande 70 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Rio Grande 48 | 1989-90 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Rio Grande 47 | 1990-91 | T |
| Rio Grande 67 West Mesa 53 | 1991-92 | H |
| West Mesa defeated Rio Grande FL | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Rio Grande 67 | 1993-94 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Rio Grande 64 | 1993-94 | S-Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 75 West Mesa 60 | 1994-95 | T |
| Rio Grande 68 West Mesa 46 | 1994-95 | H |
| Rio Grande 61 West Mesa 52 | 1995-96 | H |
| West Mesa 52 Rio Grande 47 | 1995-96 | T |
| Rio Grande 53 West Mesa 51 | 1995-96 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 70 Rio Grande 61 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Rio Grande 62 | 1998-99 | H |
| Rio Grande 58 West Mesa 48 | 99-2000 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 50 West Mesa 48 | 99-2000 | H |
| West Mesa 75 Rio Grande 70 | 2000-01 | H |
| Rio Grande 55 West Mesa 46 | 2001-02 | H |
| Rio Grande 58 West Mesa 43 | 2001-02 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 54 West Mesa 51 | 2002-03 | H |
| Rio Grande 72 West Mesa 60 | 2002-03 | T |
| Rio Grande 75 West Mesa 54 | 2003-04 | T |
| Rio Grande 65 West Mesa 49 | 2003-04 | H |
| Rio Grande 71 West Mesa 37 | 2003-04 | DT-H |
| Rio Grande 69 West Mesa 46 | 2004-05 | H |
| Rio Grande 73 West Mesa 27 | 2004-05 | T |
| Rio Grande 55 West Mesa 46 | 2005-06 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Rio Grande 71 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Grande 76 West Mesa 60 | 2006-07 | T |
| Rio Grande 71 West Mesa 70 | 2007-08 | H |
| Rio Grande 79 West Mesa 40 | 2008-09 | H |
| Rio Grande 62 West Mesa 56 | 2009-10 | T |
| West Mesa 85 Rio Grande 44 | 2010-11 | T |
| West Mesa 88 Rio Grande 53 | 2010-11 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Rio Grande 51 | 2011-12 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 67 Rio Grande 57 | 2011-12 | H |
| Rio Grande 54 West Mesa 52 | 2011-12 | T |
| Rio Grande 45 West Mesa 41 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 48 Rio Grande 40 | 2012-13 | H |
| Rio Grande 65 West Mesa 46 | 2013-14 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 76 Rio Grande 68 | 2013-14 | H |
| West Mesa 81 Rio Grande 68 | 2013-14 | T |
| West Mesa 70 Rio Grande 60 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Rio Grande 64 | 2014-15 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Rio Grande 60 | 2014-15 | DT-H |
| Rio Grande 54 West Mesa 37 | 2015-16 | H |
| Rio Grande 54 West Mesa 44 | 2015-16 | T |
| Rio Grande 68 West Mesa 59 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 52 Rio Grande 45 | 2016-17 | T |
| Rio Grande 38 West Mesa 36 | 2016-17 | H |
| West Mesa 46 Rio Grande 45 | 2016-17 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 57 Rio Grande 44 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 57 Rio Grande 52 | 2017-18 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Rio Grande 48 | 2017-18 | T |
| West Mesa 51 Rio Grande 47 | 2018-19 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Rio Grande 62 | 2019-20 | T |
| West Mesa 64 Rio Grande 48 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 68 Rio Grande 34 | 2021-22 | H |
| West Mesa 44 Rio Grande 38 | 2021-22 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Rio Grande 61 | 2022-23 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Rio Grande 58 | 2023-24 | H |
| Albuquerque Sandia | 28-53 | |
| Sandia 94 West Mesa 30 | 1966-67 | H |
| Sandia 78 West Mesa 46 | 1967-68 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Sandia 63 | 1968-69 | T |
| Sandia 41 West Mesa 39 | 1968-69 | H |
| West Mesa 51 Sandia 50 | 1969-70 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Sandia 55 | 1969-70 | T |
| West Mesa 64 Sandia 47 | 1969-70 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Sandia 71 West Mesa 46 | 1970-71 | T |
| Sandia 66 West Mesa 55 | 1970-71 | H |
| Sandia 67 West Mesa 58 | 1971-72 | H |
| Sandia 70 West Mesa 63 | 1971-72 | T |
| West Mesa 53 Sandia 47 | 1971-72 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 85 Sandia 70 | 1972-73 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Sandia 50 | 1972-73 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Sandia 48 | 1972-73 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Sandia 59 West Mesa 46 | 1973-74 | T |
| West Mesa 61 Sandia 59 | 1974-75 | H |
| West Mesa 79 Sandia 65 | 1975-76 | T |
| Sandia 71 West Mesa 68 | 1976-77 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 79 Sandia 69 | 1976-77 | H |
| Sandia 70 West Mesa 62 | 1982-83 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 71 West Mesa 62 | 1983-84 | H |
| Sandia 61 West Mesa 55 | 1983-84 | T |
| Sandia 69 West Mesa 66 | 1983-84 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Sandia 71 West Mesa 53 | 1984-85 | H |
| Sandia 89 West Mesa 49 | 1984-85 | Santa Fe |
| Sandia 75 West Mesa 51 | 1984-85 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Sandia 57 | 1985-86 | H |
| Sandia 85 West Mesa 76 | 1985-86 | H |
| Sandia 51 West Mesa 50 | 1985-86 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 68 Sandia 59 | 1986-87 | H |
| Sandia 71 West Mesa 55 | 1986-87 | T |
| Sandia 67 West Mesa 58 | 1986-87 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Sandia 57 West Mesa 55 | 1987-88 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 75 Sandia 65 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Sandia 61 | 1987-88 | H |
| Sandia 68 West Mesa 55 | 1988-89 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 82 West Mesa 65 | 1988-89 | H |
| Sandia 73 West Mesa 65 | 1989-90 | T |
| Sandia 65 West Mesa 57 | 1990-91 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 57 West Mesa 49 | 1990-91 | H |
| Sandia 89 West Mesa 72 | 1991-92 | T |
| Sandia 100 West Mesa 65 | 1992-93 | T |
| West Mesa 93 Sandia 70 | 1993-94 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 89 Sandia 63 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 50 Sandia 46 | 1994-95 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 69 Sandia 59 | 1994-95 | T |
| Sandia 74 West Mesa 72 | 1995-96 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 68 West Mesa 63 | 1995-96 | H |
| Sandia 69 West Mesa 58 | 1996-97 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 61 West Mesa 59 | 1996-97 | T |
| Sandia 71 West Mesa 69 | 1997-98 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 77 West Mesa 64 | 1997-98 | H |
| Sandia 101 West Mesa 55 | 2000-01 | T |
| Sandia 68 West Mesa 64 | 2001-02 | H |
| Sandia 73 West Mesa 55 | 2002-03 | T |
| Sandia 67 West Mesa 49 | 2003-04 | H |
| Sandia 75 West Mesa 52 | 2003-04 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 63 West Mesa 58 | 2004-05 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 49 Sandia 43 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 68 West Mesa 47 | 2007-08 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 64 West Mesa 54 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 52 Sandia 45 | 2009-10 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 43 Sandia 37 | 2009-10 | H |
| Sandia 53 West Mesa 50 | 2012-13 | H |
| West Mesa 51 Sandia 37 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 55 Sandia 46 | 2015-16 | H |
| Sandia 59 West Mesa 49 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 66 West Mesa 48 | 2018-19 | T |
| West Mesa 66 Sandia 62 | 2019-20 | T |
| Sandia 58 West Mesa 56 | 2019-20 | Albuquerque |
| Sandia 62 West Mesa 54 | 2020-21 | H |
| Sandia 64 West Mesa 34 | 2020-21 | T |
| Sandia 50 West Mesa 40 | 2021-22 | H |
| Sandia 60 West Mesa 52 | 2021-22 | T |
| Sandia 63 West Mesa 51 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Sandia 65 | 2022-23 | T |
| Sandia 64 West Mesa 60 | 2022-23 | TB-Albuquerque |
| Sandia 65 West Mesa 44 | 2022-23 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 87 Sandia 66 | 2023-24 | T |
| Sandia 53 West Mesa 52 | 2023-24 | H |
| Albuquerque Sandia Prep | 5-0 | |
| West Mesa 55 Sandia Prep 49 | 2008-09 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 46 Sandia Prep 43 | 2010-11 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 78 Sandia Prep 53 | 2011-12 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 68 Sandia Prep 45 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 48 Sandia Prep 40 | 2015-16 | H |
| Albuquerque St Mary | 0-1 | |
| St Mary 60 West Mesa 53 | 1966-67 | T |
| Albuquerque St Pius X | 8-11 | |
| St Pius X 67 West Mesa 56 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 62 St Pius X 46 | 1968-69 | Albuquerque |
| St Pius X 49 West Mesa 42 | 1969-70 | Albuquerque |
| St Pius X 60 West Mesa 50 | 1970-71 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 72 St Pius X 50 | 1973-74 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 56 St Pius X 39 | 1985-86 | H |
| St Pius X 62 West Mesa 52 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 63 St Pius X 48 | 1989-90 | Albuquerque |
| St Pius X 67 West Mesa 37 | 2000-01 | H |
| West Mesa 50 St Pius X 48 | 2001-02 | T |
| West Mesa 45 St Pius X 42 | 2002-03 | H |
| St Pius X 53 West Mesa 48 | 2003-04 | T |
| West Mesa 47 St Pius X 40 | 2004-05 | H |
| St Pius X 52 West Mesa 49 | 2005-06 | T |
| St Pius X 53 West Mesa 48 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| St Pius X 57 West Mesa 51 | 2007-08 | H |
| West Mesa 58 St Pius X 51 | 2010-11 | Las Vegas |
| St Pius X 48 West Mesa 38 | 2014-15 | H |
| St Pius X 57 West Mesa 46 | 2015-16 | Las Vegas |
| Albuquerque Valley | 40-53 | |
| Valley 68 West Mesa 38 | 1966-67 | T |
| Valley 64 West Mesa 52 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Valley 53 | 1968-69 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Valley 56 | 1968-69 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 70 Valley 49 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 50 Valley 44 | 1969-70 | T |
| West Mesa 58 Valley 44 | 1969-70 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 67 Valley 61 | 1969-70 | H |
| Valley 59 West Mesa 53 | 1970-71 | H |
| Valley 56 West Mesa 49 | 1970-71 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 45 Valley 37 | 1970-71 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Valley 50 | 1970-71 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 46 Valley 44 | 1971-72 | T |
| Valley 62 West Mesa 61 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 54 Valley 53 | 1971-72 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Valley 50 | 1972-73 | H |
| West Mesa 85 Valley 57 | 1972-73 | T |
| Valley 72 West Mesa 70 | 1972-73 | DT-Albuquerque |
| Valley 70 West Mesa 49 | 1973-74 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Valley 64 | 1974-75 | H |
| Valley 55 West Mesa 49 | 1975-76 | T |
| Valley 89 West Mesa 57 | 1976-77 | H |
| Valley 69 West Mesa 65 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 90 Valley 76 | 1978-79 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Valley 47 | 1979-80 | T |
| Valley 81 West Mesa 77 | 1979-80 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 75 Valley 63 | 1980-81 | Albuquerque |
| Valley 68 West Mesa 67 | 1980-81 | H |
| Valley 76 West Mesa 57 | 1981-82 | T |
| Valley 66 West Mesa 63 | 1982-83 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Valley 63 | 1982-83 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Valley 60 | 1983-84 | H |
| Valley 61 West Mesa 60 | 1983-84 | T |
| Valley 45 West Mesa 41 | 1984-85 | T |
| West Mesa 61 Valley 53 | 1984-85 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Valley 47 | 1984-85 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 54 Valley 53 | 1985-86 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Valley 58 | 1985-86 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Valley 65 | 1986-87 | H |
| West Mesa 78 Valley 77 | 1986-87 | T |
| West Mesa 86 Valley 70 | 1987-88 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Valley 53 | 1987-88 | T |
| West Mesa 82 Valley 64 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Valley 54 | 1989-90 | H |
| Valley 86 West Mesa 72 | 1990-91 | H |
| Valley 94 West Mesa 64 | 1991-92 | H |
| West Mesa 49 Valley 46 | 1992-93 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 89 Valley 72 FL | 1992-93 | T |
| Valley 60 West Mesa 57 | 1993-94 | H |
| Valley 80 West Mesa 72 | 1994-95 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Valley 56 | 1995-96 | H |
| Valley 78 West Mesa 66 | 1996-97 | H |
| West Mesa 78 Valley 60 | 1997-98 | Albuquerque |
| Valley 65 West Mesa 63 | 2000-01 | Albuquerque |
| Valley 59 West Mesa 48 | 2000-01 | T |
| Valley 59 West Mesa 31 | 2000-01 | H |
| Valley 55 West Mesa 53 | 2001-02 | H |
| West Mesa 49 Valley 44 | 2001-02 | T |
| Valley 63 West Mesa 47 | 2002-03 | T |
| Valley 64 West Mesa 50 | 2002-03 | H |
| Valley 52 West Mesa 49 | 2003-04 | H |
| Valley 79 West Mesa 67 | 2003-04 | T |
| Valley 55 West Mesa 45 | 2004-05 | T |
| Valley 62 West Mesa 56 | 2004-05 | H |
| Valley 63 West Mesa 45 | 2005-06 | T |
| Valley 50 West Mesa 49 | 2006-07 | H |
| Valley 63 West Mesa 56 | 2008-09 | Albuquerque |
| Valley 60 West Mesa 39 | 2008-09 | T |
| Valley 66 West Mesa 35 | 2009-10 | H |
| Valley 54 West Mesa 53 | 2010-11 | T |
| West Mesa 54 Valley 53 | 2010-11 | H |
| West Mesa 46 Valley 44 | 2010-11 | TB-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 50 Valley 47 | 2010-11 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 48 Valley 44 | 2011-12 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Valley 73 | 2011-12 | H |
| Valley 48 West Mesa 47 | 2011-12 | DT-T |
| Valley 52 West Mesa 48 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 60 Valley 50 | 2012-13 | H |
| Valley 58 West Mesa 51 | 2013-14 | H |
| Valley 71 West Mesa 55 | 2013-14 | T |
| Valley 48 West Mesa 46 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| Valley 62 West Mesa 56 | 2014-15 | H |
| Valley 52 West Mesa 47 | 2014-15 | T |
| Valley 37 West Mesa 23 | 2015-16 | T |
| Valley 43 West Mesa 39 | 2015-16 | H |
| West Mesa 42 Valley 37 | 2016-17 | H |
| Valley 59 West Mesa 46 | 2016-17 | T |
| Valley 56 West Mesa 52 | 2017-18 | T |
| Valley 56 West Mesa 46 | 2017-18 | H |
| Valley 59 West Mesa 41 | 2017-18 | DT-T |
| Valley 57 West Mesa 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Valley 75 West Mesa 69 | 2019-20 | H |
| Valley 48 West Mesa 41 | 2021-22 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Valley 42 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Albuquerque Volcano Vista | 2-8 | |
| Volcano Vista 62 West Mesa 49 | 2011-12 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 75 West Mesa 66 | 2013-14 | H |
| Volcano Vista 62 West Mesa 37 | 2013-14 | S-T |
| West Mesa 58 Volcano Vista 46 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Volcano Vista 58 | 2017-18 | T |
| Volcano Vista 85 West Mesa 28 | 2018-19 | Albuquerque |
| Volcano Vista 62 West Mesa 53 | 2018-19 | H |
| Volcano Vista 76 West Mesa 46 | 2019-20 | T |
| Volcano Vista 71 West Mesa 49 | 2021-22 | T |
| Volcano Vista 62 West Mesa 42 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Amarillo Tascosa (TX) | 1-1 | |
| Tascosa 67 West Mesa 60 | 2004-05 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 Tascosa 60 | 2005-06 | Albuquerque |
| Anthony Gadsden | 4-0 | |
| West Mesa 76 Gadsden 64 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 79 Gadsden 73 | 1992-93 | T |
| West Mesa 70 Gadsden 60 | 1992-93 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 109 Gadsden 41 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 80 Gadsden 49 | 1993-94 | H |
| Belen | 12-4 | |
| West Mesa 68 Belen 66 | 2000-01 | H |
| West Mesa defeated Belen | 2001-02 | T |
| Belen 57 West Mesa 53 | 2002-03 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Belen 62 | 2003-04 | H |
| West Mesa 45 Belen 37 | 2004-05 | T |
| West Mesa 61 Belen 36 | 2005-06 | H |
| Belen 58 West Mesa 50 | 2006-07 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Belen 47 | 2007-08 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Belen 52 | 2008-09 | T |
| Belen 65 West Mesa 56 | 2009-10 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Belen 29 | 2010-11 | H |
| West Mesa 83 Belen 69 | 2011-12 | H |
| Belen 56 West Mesa 49 | 2012-13 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Belen 59 | 2013-14 | H |
| West Mesa 48 Belen 46 | 2017-18 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Belen 25 | 2022-23 | T |
| Bernalillo | 4-6 | |
| Bernalillo 55 West Mesa 33 | 1966-67 | H |
| Bernalillo 45 West Mesa 39 | 1966-67 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 50 Bernalillo 49 | 1969-70 | Albuquerque |
| Bernalillo 70 West Mesa 49 | 1973-74 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 67 Bernalillo 61 | 1974-75 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 66 Bernalillo 45 | 2006-07 | H |
| West Mesa 77 Bernalillo 64 | 2007-08 | T |
| Bernalillo 65 West Mesa 57 | 2012-13 | Las Vegas |
| Bernalillo 65 West Mesa 38 | 2015-16 | Las Vegas |
| Bernalillo 50 West Mesa 48 | 2019-20 | H |
| Blanding (UT) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 62 Blanding 56 | 1972-73 | Durango |
| Carlsbad | 3-3 | |
| Carlsbad 65 West Mesa 57 | 1969-70 | S-Las Cruces |
| West Mesa 70 Carlsbad 65 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 66 Carlsbad 54 | 2017-18 | H |
| Carlsbad 62 West Mesa 54 | 2018-19 | T |
| Carlsbad 48 West Mesa 43 | 2019-20 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Carlsbad 54 | 2022-23 | Rio Rancho |
| Clovis | 0-3 | |
| Clovis 66 West Mesa 50 | 2002-03 | Santa Fe |
| Clovis 66 West Mesa 53 | 2011-12 | S-T |
| Clovis 75 West Mesa 56 | 2012-13 | S-T |
| Cuba | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 34 Cuba 28 | 1966-67 | Albuquerque |
| Denver Mullen (CO) | 0-1 | |
| Mullen 64 West Mesa 45 | 2005-06 | Albuquerque |
| Durango (CO) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 63 Durango 43 | 1972-73 | Durango |
| El Paso Andress (TX) | 1-2 | |
| Andress 67 West Mesa 60 | 1978-79 | Las Cruces |
| Andress 61 West Mesa 60 | 2013-14 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Andress 47 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| El Paso Bowie (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Bowie 59 West Mesa 58 | 1974-75 | Albuquerque |
| El Paso Burges (TX) | 0-2 | |
| Burges 60 West Mesa 57 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| Burges 65 West Mesa 63 | 1972-73 | Albuquerque |
| El Paso Cathedral (TX) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 55 Cathedral 52 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| El Paso Irvin (TX) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 58 Irvin 49 | 2016-17 | Rio Rancho |
| El Paso Jefferson (TX) | 1-1 | |
| Jefferson 73 West Mesa 67 | 1991-92 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 46 Jefferson 33 | 2008-09 | Alamogordo |
| El Paso Riverside (TX) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 67 Riverside 40 | 2023-24 | Belen |
| El Paso Ysleta (TX) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 69 Ysleta 51 | 2007-08 | Silver City |
| Espanola | 24-12 | |
| Espanola 67 West Mesa 54 | 1966-67 | H |
| West Mesa 89 Espanola 70 | 1974-75 | H |
| Espanola 81 West Mesa 79 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Espanola 63 | 1975-76 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Espanola 58 | 1975-76 | H |
| West Mesa 48 Espanola 37 | 1975-76 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 73 Espanola 61 | 1976-77 | H |
| West Mesa 79 Espanola 67 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 97 Espanola 60 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Espanola 60 | 1977-78 | H |
| West Mesa 92 Espanola 69 | 1977-78 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 81 Espanola 54 | 1978-79 | H |
| Espanola 61 West Mesa 49 | 1978-79 | T |
| Espanola 92 West Mesa 69 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Espanola 49 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Espanola 59 | 1980-81 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Espanola 53 | 1980-81 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Espanola 65 | 1981-82 | T |
| West Mesa 82 Espanola 64 | 1981-82 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Espanola 42 | 1981-82 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 70 Espanola 69 | 1982-83 | H |
| Espanola 79 West Mesa 72 | 1982-83 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Espanola 57 | 1984-85 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 73 Espanola 54 | 1987-88 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Espanola 47 | 1994-95 | H |
| Espanola 57 West Mesa 49 | 1995-96 | T |
| Espanola 55 West Mesa 44 | 1996-97 | T |
| Espanola 58 West Mesa 53 | 1996-97 | H |
| Espanola 50 West Mesa 47 | 1996-97 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 68 Espanola 63 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 78 Espanola 74 | 1997-98 | T |
| Espanola 78 West Mesa 63 | 1998-99 | T |
| West Mesa 54 Espanola 52 | 1998-99 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Espanola 54 | 99-2000 | H |
| Espanola 52 West Mesa 47 | 99-2000 | T |
| Espanola 54 West Mesa 51 | 99-2000 | DT-T |
| Farmington | 23-25 | |
| Farmington 59 West Mesa 54 | 1966-67 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Farmington 55 | 1967-68 | T |
| West Mesa 101 Farmington 80 | 1968-69 | H |
| Farmington 79 West Mesa 69 | 1969-70 | T |
| Farmington 69 West Mesa 68 | 1970-71 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Farmington 65 | 1971-72 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Farmington 57 | 1972-73 | H |
| Farmington 72 West Mesa 66 | 1973-74 | H |
| Farmington 81 West Mesa 79 | 1973-74 | T |
| Farmington 63 West Mesa 58 | 1974-75 | T |
| Farmington 53 West Mesa 46 | 1974-75 | H |
| West Mesa 81 Farmington 61 | 1975-76 | H |
| Farmington 69 West Mesa 63 | 1975-76 | T |
| Farmington 59 West Mesa 52 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 62 Farmington 57 | 1976-77 | H |
| Farmington 64 West Mesa 59 | 1976-77 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 69 Farmington 66 | 1977-78 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Farmington 54 | 1977-78 | T |
| Farmington 69 West Mesa 64 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 85 Farmington 71 | 1978-79 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Farmington 63 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Farmington 46 | 1979-80 | T |
| Farmington 54 West Mesa 53 | 1979-80 | DT-H |
| Farmington 64 West Mesa 53 | 1980-81 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Farmington 63 | 1980-81 | H |
| West Mesa 86 Farmington 75 | 1981-82 | H |
| Farmington 119 West Mesa 57 | 1981-82 | T |
| Farmington 51 West Mesa 48 | 1982-83 | T |
| Farmington 49 West Mesa 47 | 1982-83 | H |
| Farmington 67 West Mesa 56 | 1983-84 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Farmington 54 | 1984-85 | T |
| Farmington 70 West Mesa 52 | 1987-88 | S-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 55 Farmington 48 | 1996-97 | H |
| Farmington 77 West Mesa 55 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Farmington 48 | 2018-19 | H |
| Farmington 46 West Mesa 38 | 2018-19 | T |
| West Mesa 64 Farmington 42 | 2019-20 | T |
| West Mesa 55 Farmington 49 | 2019-20 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Farmington 51 | 2019-20 | DT-H |
| Farmington 41 West Mesa 38 | 2020-21 | T |
| West Mesa 53 Farmington 51 | 2020-21 | H |
| Farmington 47 West Mesa 45 | 2021-22 | T |
| West Mesa 45 Farmington 44 | 2021-22 | H |
| Farmington 56 West Mesa 53 | 2021-22 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 55 Farmington 54 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 61 Farmington 48 | 2022-23 | T |
| West Mesa 51 Farmington 47 | 2023-24 | T |
| Farmington 78 West Mesa 67 | 2023-24 | H |
| Farmington Piedra Vista | 11-2 | |
| West Mesa 59 Piedra Vista 55 | 2004-05 | H |
| Piedra Vista 52 West Mesa 51 | 2018-19 | H |
| Piedra Vista 60 West Mesa 59 | 2018-19 | T |
| West Mesa 81 Piedra Vista 58 | 2019-20 | T |
| West Mesa 77 Piedra Vista 49 | 2019-20 | H |
| West Mesa 53 Piedra Vista 39 | 2020-21 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Piedra Vista 41 | 2020-21 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Piedra Vista 38 | 2021-22 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Piedra Vista 28 | 2021-22 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Piedra Vista 17 | 2022-23 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Piedra Vista 15 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 75 Piedra Vista 39 | 2023-24 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Piedra Vista 52 | 2023-24 | T |
| Fruita (CO) | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 81 Fruita 41 | 1972-73 | Durango |
| Gallup | 36-25 | |
| West Mesa 51 Gallup 46 | 1966-67 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Gallup 51 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 61 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 38 | 1969-70 | H |
| Gallup 54 West Mesa 53 | 1973-74 | H |
| Gallup 67 West Mesa 62 | 1973-74 | T |
| Gallup 70 West Mesa 68 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Gallup 72 | 1974-75 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 46 | 1974-75 | DT-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 78 Gallup 66 | 1975-76 | H |
| Gallup 59 West Mesa 58 | 1975-76 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Gallup 40 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Gallup 58 | 1976-77 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Gallup 68 | 1977-78 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Gallup 61 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Gallup 57 | 1977-78 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 77 Gallup 61 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 70 Gallup 57 | 1978-79 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Gallup 58 | 1978-79 | DT-H |
| West Mesa 79 Gallup 71 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 72 Gallup 58 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Gallup 64 | 1980-81 | T |
| Gallup 55 West Mesa 53 | 1980-81 | H |
| West Mesa 60 Gallup 54 | 1981-82 | H |
| West Mesa 63 Gallup 57 | 1981-82 | T |
| Gallup 70 West Mesa 66 | 1982-83 | T |
| Gallup 63 West Mesa 57 | 1982-83 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Gallup 35 | 1983-84 | H |
| West Mesa 74 Gallup 43 | 1984-85 | H |
| Gallup 51 West Mesa 48 | 1996-97 | T |
| West Mesa 82 Gallup 48 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 76 Gallup 55 | 1998-99 | H |
| Gallup 68 West Mesa 63 | 99-2000 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Gallup 31 | 2000-01 | H |
| Gallup 33 West Mesa 32 | 2000-01 | T |
| West Mesa 54 Gallup 45 | 2001-02 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Gallup 46 | 2001-02 | H |
| Gallup 50 West Mesa 45 | 2002-03 | H |
| Gallup 55 West Mesa 50 | 2002-03 | T |
| West Mesa 53 Gallup 44 | 2002-03 | DT-T |
| Gallup 71 West Mesa 65 | 2003-04 | T |
| Gallup 55 West Mesa 51 | 2003-04 | H |
| West Mesa 63 Gallup 59 | 2004-05 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Gallup 56 | 2004-05 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Gallup 64 | 2005-06 | T |
| West Mesa 61 Gallup 59 | 2005-06 | H |
| Gallup 81 West Mesa 57 | 2005-06 | T |
| Gallup 72 West Mesa 62 | 2005-06 | DT-T |
| Gallup 70 West Mesa 67 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gallup 78 West Mesa 54 | 2006-07 | T |
| Gallup 58 West Mesa 53 | 2006-07 | H |
| Gallup 72 West Mesa 61 | 2006-07 | DT-T |
| Gallup 81 West Mesa 67 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 84 Gallup 76 | 2007-08 | H |
| West Mesa 71 Gallup 61 | 2007-08 | T |
| Gallup 90 West Mesa 73 | 2007-08 | DT-T |
| Gallup 67 West Mesa 54 | 2008-09 | H |
| Gallup 66 West Mesa 61 | 2008-09 | T |
| Gallup 66 West Mesa 61 | 2008-09 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Gallup 61 | 2009-10 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Gallup 53 | 2009-10 | T |
| Gallup Miyamura | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 62 Miyamura 36 | 2014-15 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Miyamura 30 | 2015-16 | H |
| Grants | 8-4 | |
| West Mesa defeated Grants | 1977-78 | T |
| Grants 59 West Mesa 58 | 1977-78 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Grants 46 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Grants 46 | 1978-79 | H |
| West Mesa 82 Grants 69 | 1979-80 | H |
| West Mesa 93 Grants 85 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 64 Grants 63 | 1980-81 | H |
| Grants 57 West Mesa 55 | 1980-81 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Grants 55 | 1981-82 | T |
| West Mesa 75 Grants 66 | 1981-82 | H |
| Grants 81 West Mesa 67 | 1982-83 | H |
| Grants 66 West Mesa 60 | 1982-83 | T |
| Hobbs | 2-4 | |
| Hobbs 98 West Mesa 63 | 1969-70 | S-Las Cruces |
| Hobbs 72 West Mesa 47 | 2014-15 | S-Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 75 Hobbs 70 | 2018-19 | T |
| Hobbs 80 West Mesa 50 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Hobbs 61 West Mesa 50 | 2019-20 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Hobbs 55 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Kirtland Central | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 73 Central 67 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 63 Central 43 | 2015-16 | Las Vegas |
| Laredo Nixon (TX) | 0-1 | |
| Nixon 85 Nixon 84 | 1991-92 | Santa Fe |
| Las Cruces | 4-8 | |
| Las Cruces 71 West Mesa 58 | 1978-79 | Las Cruces |
| Las Cruces 71 West Mesa 62 | 1992-93 | T |
| Las Cruces 51 West Mesa 48 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 63 Las Cruces 54 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 60 Las Cruces 45 | 1993-94 | T |
| Las Cruces 102 West Mesa 98 | 1998-99 | T |
| West Mesa 73 Las Cruces 66 | 99-2000 | H |
| Las Cruces 68 West Mesa 63 | 2004-05 | Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces 76 West Mesa 57 | 2004-05 | T |
| Las Cruces 73 West Mesa 57 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| West Mesa 52 Las Cruces 49 | 2014-15 | S-T |
| Las Cruces 84 West Mesa 59 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Las Cruces Centennial | 2-1 | |
| West Mesa 60 Centennial 59 | 2014-15 | H |
| Centennial 70 West Mesa 49 | 2015-16 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Centennial 56 | 2023-24 | Belen |
| Las Cruces Mayfield | 5-5 | |
| Mayfield 60 West Mesa 58 | 1992-93 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Mayfield 50 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 51 Mayfield 50 | 1992-93 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 63 Mayfield 51 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 52 Mayfield 51 | 1993-94 | T |
| Mayfield 64 West Mesa 55 | 2006-07 | Albuquerque |
| Mayfield 60 West Mesa 53 | 2008-09 | H |
| Mayfield 62 West Mesa 51 | 2009-10 | T |
| Mayfield 59 West Mesa 48 | 2015-16 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Mayfield 59 | 2021-22 | H |
| Las Cruces Organ Mountain | 4-4 | |
| Onate 44 West Mesa 42 | 2008-09 | H |
| West Mesa 42 Onate 34 | 2009-10 | T |
| Onate 60 West Mesa 46 | 2010-11 | T |
| West Mesa 45 Onate 43 | 2011-12 | H |
| West Mesa 73 Onate 70 | 2014-15 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 43 Onate 32 | 2014-15 | H |
| Onate 62 West Mesa 31 | 2015-16 | T |
| Organ Mountain 59 West Mesa 55 | 2022-23 | S-Albuquerque |
| Las Vegas Robertson | 4-0 | |
| West Mesa 79 Robertson 48 | 1967-68 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 95 Robertson 65 | 1998-99 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 85 Robertson 65 | 2010-11 | Las Vegas |
| West Mesa 68 Robertson 56 | 2012-13 | Las Vegas |
| West Las Vegas | 3-0 | |
| West Mesa 61 West 58 | 1970-71 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 64 West 47 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 98 West 69 | 2010-11 | Las Vegas |
| Lordsburg | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 68 Lordsburg 54 | 2007-08 | Silver City |
| Los Alamos | 14-27 | |
| Los Alamos 63 West Mesa 39 | 1966-67 | T |
| Los Alamos 63 West Mesa 60 | 1967-68 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Los Alamos 51 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 58 Los Alamos 51 | 1969-70 | H |
| Los Alamos 59 West Mesa 51 | 1970-71 | T |
| Los Alamos 69 West Mesa 52 | 1970-71 | Albuquerque |
| Los Alamos 97 West Mesa 73 | 1971-72 | H |
| West Mesa 91 Los Alamos 67 | 1972-73 | T |
| Los Alamos 70 West Mesa 59 | 1973-74 | T |
| Los Alamos 82 West Mesa 76 | 1973-74 | H |
| Los Alamos 73 West Mesa 67 | 1973-74 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 75 Los Alamos 68 | 1974-75 | H |
| Los Alamos 65 West Mesa 62 | 1974-75 | T |
| Los Alamos 77 West Mesa 60 | 1975-76 | T |
| Los Alamos 71 West Mesa 62 | 1975-76 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Los Alamos 60 | 1976-77 | H |
| Los Alamos 69 West Mesa 63 | 1976-77 | T |
| Los Alamos 75 West Mesa 71 | 1977-78 | T |
| West Mesa 85 Los Alamos 71 | 1977-78 | H |
| Los Alamos 58 West Mesa 56 | 1978-79 | H |
| Los Alamos 57 West Mesa 55 | 1978-79 | T |
| Los Alamos 69 West Mesa 63 | 1978-79 | DT-T |
| Los Alamos 57 West Mesa 56 | 1979-80 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Los Alamos 65 | 1979-80 | H |
| Los Alamos 80 West Mesa 79 | 1980-81 | H |
| Los Alamos 53 West Mesa 48 | 1980-81 | T |
| Los Alamos 68 West Mesa 51 | 1981-82 | T |
| Los Alamos 76 West Mesa 65 | 1981-82 | H |
| Los Alamos 62 West Mesa 52 | 1981-82 | DT-T |
| Los Alamos 68 West Mesa 52 | 1982-83 | T |
| Los Alamos 65 West Mesa 47 | 1982-83 | T |
| Los Alamos 76 West Mesa 47 | 1983-84 | H |
| West Mesa 54 Los Alamos 53 | 1984-85 | T |
| West Mesa 53 Los Alamos 43 | 1985-86 | H |
| West Mesa 44 Los Alamos 42 | 1986-87 | T |
| West Mesa 71 Los Alamos 48 | 1987-88 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Los Alamos 59 | 1988-89 | T |
| West Mesa 80 Los Alamos 51 | 1989-90 | H |
| West Mesa 43 Los Alamos 42 | 1990-91 | T |
| Los Alamos 63 West Mesa 55 | 1991-92 | H |
| Los Alamos 61 West Mesa 51 | 1998-99 | Albuquerque |
| Los Lunas | 14-4 | |
| West Mesa 101 Los Lunas 71 | 1992-93 | H |
| West Mesa 114 Los Lunas 46 | 1992-93 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Los Lunas 44 | 1993-94 | T |
| West Mesa 72 Los Lunas 55 | 1993-94 | H |
| West Mesa 83 Los Lunas 57 | 1994-95 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Los Lunas 43 | 1995-96 | H |
| West Mesa 90 Los Lunas 79 | 1996-97 | T |
| West Mesa 83 Los Lunas 65 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 70 Los Lunas 55 | 1998-99 | T |
| West Mesa 65 Los Lunas 57 | 99-2000 | T |
| West Mesa 68 Los Lunas 60 | 2005-06 | H |
| Los Lunas 55 West Mesa 53 | 2006-07 | T |
| Los Lunas 69 West Mesa 61 | 2007-08 | H |
| West Mesa 58 Los Lunas 50 | 2008-09 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Los Lunas 46 | 2009-10 | Santa Fe |
| Los Lunas 77 West Mesa 73 | 2009-10 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Los Lunas 33 | 2010-11 | T |
| Los Lunas 45 West Mesa 35 | 2016-17 | Rio Rancho |
| Los Lunas Valencia | 4-1 | |
| West Mesa 64 Valencia 35 | 2008-09 | H |
| West Mesa 45 Valencia 39 | 2009-10 | T |
| West Mesa 79 Valencia 65 | 2010-11 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Valencia 51 | 2011-12 | T |
| Valencia 57 West Mesa 52 | 2017-18 | T |
| Moriarty | 3-0 | |
| West Mesa 70 Moriarty 40 | 1989-90 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 67 Moriarty 36 | 2007-08 | T |
| West Mesa 83 Moriarty 46 | 2010-11 | T |
| Pojoaque | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 64 Pojoaque 61 | 2005-06 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 64 Pojoaque 47 | 2023-24 | H |
| Portales | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 73 Portales 53 | 1995-96 | Albuquerque |
| Pueblo South (CO) | 0-1 | |
| South 67 West Mesa 42 | 2002-03 | Santa Fe |
| Rio Rancho | 9-31 | |
| West Mesa 87 Rio Rancho 64 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 57 Rio Rancho 54 | 1998-99 | T |
| Rio Rancho 69 West Mesa 62 | 99-2000 | H |
| Rio Rancho 53 West Mesa 46 | 2000-01 | T |
| Rio Rancho 54 West Mesa 47 | 2000-01 | H |
| Rio Rancho 58 West Mesa 51 | 2000-01 | DT-T |
| Rio Rancho 72 West Mesa 59 | 2001-02 | H |
| Rio Rancho 53 West Mesa 50 | 2001-02 | T |
| Rio Rancho 68 West Mesa 57 | 2002-03 | T |
| West Mesa 58 Rio Rancho 51 | 2002-03 | H |
| Rio Rancho 60 West Mesa 58 | 2002-03 | DT-H |
| Rio Rancho 69 West Mesa 55 | 2003-04 | H |
| Rio Rancho 78 West Mesa 51 | 2003-04 | T |
| Rio Rancho 58 West Mesa 54 | 2004-05 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Rancho 58 West Mesa 50 | 2004-05 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Rio Rancho 55 | 2004-05 | H |
| Rio Rancho 60 West Mesa 54 | 2004-05 | DT-T |
| Rio Rancho 68 West Mesa 62 | 2005-06 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Rancho 63 West Mesa 53 | 2005-06 | H |
| Rio Rancho 63 West Mesa 54 | 2005-06 | T |
| Rio Rancho 51 West Mesa 50 | 2005-06 | H |
| Rio Rancho 87 West Mesa 55 | 2006-07 | T |
| Rio Rancho 91 West Mesa 58 | 2006-07 | H |
| Rio Rancho 64 West Mesa 25 | 2006-07 | T |
| Rio Rancho 70 West Mesa 65 | 2007-08 | H |
| Rio Rancho 70 West Mesa 61 | 2007-08 | T |
| Rio Rancho 93 West Mesa 84 | 2007-08 | H |
| Rio Rancho 63 West Mesa 52 | 2008-09 | T |
| Rio Rancho 79 West Mesa 73 | 2008-09 | H |
| Rio Rancho 91 West Mesa 88 | 2008-09 | T |
| Rio Rancho 67 West Mesa 64 | 2009-10 | T |
| Rio Rancho 82 West Mesa 73 | 2009-10 | H |
| West Mesa 73 Rio Rancho 68 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| West Mesa 65 Rio Rancho 54 | 2012-13 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 73 Rio Rancho 58 | 2012-13 | T |
| Rio Rancho 49 West Mesa 44 | 2013-14 | H |
| Rio Rancho 70 West Mesa 50 | 2015-16 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 91 Rio Rancho 69 | 2017-18 | Albuquerque |
| Rio Rancho 88 West Mesa 61 | 2018-19 | H |
| West Mesa 67 Rio Rancho 64 | 2019-20 | T |
| Rio Rancho Cleveland | 2-6 | |
| Cleveland 59 West Mesa 56 | 2009-10 | T |
| Cleveland 52 West Mesa 43 | 2009-10 | H |
| Cleveland 74 West Mesa 60 | 2009-10 | DT-H |
| Cleveland 67 West Mesa 59 | 2010-11 | S-T |
| Cleveland 83 West Mesa 54 | 2016-17 | Rio Rancho |
| Cleveland 80 West Mesa 51 | 2016-17 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 66 Cleveland 63 | 2022-23 | Rio Rancho |
| West Mesa 76 Cleveland 43 | 2022-23 | Albuquerque |
| Roswell | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 99 Roswell 67 | 1994-95 | H |
| West Mesa 80 Roswell 52 | 1995-96 | T |
| Roswell Goddard | 4-0 | |
| West Mesa 61 Goddard 48 | 1971-72 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 87 Goddard 63 | 1994-95 | H |
| West Mesa 68 Goddard 60 | 1995-96 | T |
| West Mesa 80 Goddard 45 | 2021-22 | Albuquerque |
| Roswell NMMI | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 55 NMMI 53 | 1967-68 | T |
| Santa Rosa | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 63 Santa Rosa 41 | 1972-73 | Albuquerque |
| Santa Fe | 29-31 | |
| Santa Fe 69 West Mesa 48 | 1966-67 | T |
| West Mesa 76 Santa Fe 67 | 1968-69 | T |
| West Mesa 67 Santa Fe 60 | 1969-70 | H |
| West Mesa 69 Santa Fe 52 | 1969-70 | S-Las Cruces |
| Santa Fe 52 West Mesa 46 | 1970-71 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Santa Fe 53 | 1973-74 | H |
| Santa Fe 58 West Mesa 39 | 1973-74 | Santa Fe |
| Santa Fe 52 West Mesa 46 | 1973-74 | T |
| West Mesa 50 Santa Fe 40 | 1973-74 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 74 Santa Fe 54 | 1974-75 | T |
| West Mesa 87 Santa Fe 59 | 1974-75 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Santa Fe 36 | 1975-76 | H |
| West Mesa 65 Santa Fe 50 | 1975-76 | T |
| Santa Fe 54 West Mesa 49 | 1976-77 | T |
| West Mesa 81 Santa Fe 69 | 1976-77 | H |
| Santa Fe 69 West Mesa 57 | 1977-78 | H |
| Santa Fe 72 West Mesa 66 | 1977-78 | T |
| Santa Fe 59 West Mesa 54 | 1978-79 | T |
| West Mesa 48 Santa Fe 45 | 1978-79 | H |
| Santa Fe 70 West Mesa 56 | 1979-80 | H |
| Santa Fe 72 West Mesa 59 | 1979-80 | T |
| Santa Fe 56 West Mesa 55 | 1980-81 | T |
| West Mesa 59 Santa Fe 51 | 1980-81 | H |
| Santa Fe 67 West Mesa 51 | 1980-81 | DT-T |
| West Mesa 64 Santa Fe 62 | 1981-82 | H |
| Santa Fe 59 West Mesa 56 | 1981-82 | T |
| Santa Fe 51 West Mesa 46 | 1982-83 | T |
| Santa Fe 53 West Mesa 52 | 1982-83 | H |
| Santa Fe 45 West Mesa 33 | 1982-83 | DT-T |
| Santa Fe 67 West Mesa 60 | 1983-84 | T |
| West Mesa 57 Santa Fe 52 | 1984-85 | H |
| Santa Fe 61 West Mesa 51 | 1984-85 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 57 Santa Fe 50 | 1985-86 | T |
| West Mesa 78 Santa Fe 68 | 1986-87 | H |
| Santa Fe 71 West Mesa 62 | 1987-88 | T |
| Santa Fe 81 West Mesa 71 | 1988-89 | H |
| Santa Fe 74 West Mesa 71 | 1989-90 | T |
| West Mesa 58 Santa Fe 41 | 1990-91 | H |
| Santa Fe 68 West Mesa 65 | 1991-92 | T |
| Santa Fe 48 West Mesa 41 | 1996-97 | H |
| Santa Fe defeated West Mesa | 1996-97 | T |
| West Mesa 63 Santa Fe 56 | 1997-98 | H |
| West Mesa 66 Santa Fe 62 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 77 Santa Fe 56 | 1998-99 | H |
| Santa Fe 74 West Mesa 69 | 1998-99 | T |
| West Mesa 82 Santa Fe 76 | 1998-99 | DT-T |
| Santa Fe 62 West Mesa 60 | 99-2000 | T |
| Santa Fe 59 West Mesa 57 | 99-2000 | H |
| Santa Fe 53 West Mesa 49 | 2000-01 | T |
| West Mesa 48 Santa Fe 46 | 2001-02 | H |
| West Mesa 53 Santa Fe 47 | 2002-03 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 71 Santa Fe 64 | 2002-03 | T |
| West Mesa 51 Santa Fe 50 | 2003-04 | H |
| West Mesa 60 Santa Fe 43 | 2004-05 | T |
| Santa Fe 52 West Mesa 47 | 2009-10 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 64 Santa Fe 55 | 2010-11 | T |
| West Mesa 69 Santa Fe 43 | 2011-12 | H |
| Santa Fe 59 West Mesa 52 | 2016-17 | T |
| West Mesa 52 Santa Fe 49 | 2017-18 | H |
| West Mesa 56 Santa Fe 41 | 2022-23 | S-H |
| Santa Fe 66 West Mesa 53 | 2023-24 | S-T |
| Santa Fe ATATC | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 61 ATATC 56 | 2023-24 | Belen |
| Santa Fe Capital | 5-9 | |
| Capital 66 West Mesa 63 | 1996-97 | T |
| Capital 68 West Mesa 61 | 1996-97 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Capital 60 | 1997-98 | H |
| Capital 73 West Mesa 61 | 1997-98 | T |
| West Mesa 74 Capital 56 | 1998-99 | T |
| West Mesa 80 Capital 62 | 1998-99 | H |
| West Mesa 64 Capital 57 | 1998-99 | DT-T |
| Capital 72 West Mesa 66 | 99-2000 | H |
| Capital 73 West Mesa 64 | 99-2000 | T |
| Capital 57 West Mesa 41 | 2005-06 | Santa Fe |
| Capital 61 West Mesa 59 | 2009-10 | Santa Fe |
| Capital 53 West Mesa 47 | 2012-13 | Las Vegas |
| Capital 59 West Mesa 49 | 2022-23 | H |
| West Mesa 62 Capital 32 | 2023-24 | T |
| Santa Fe St Michael | 1-1 | |
| St Michael 76 West Mesa 67 | 1991-92 | Santa Fe |
| West Mesa 47 St Michael 44 | 2005-06 | Santa Fe |
| Santa Teresa | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 37 Santa Teresa 34 | 2008-09 | Alamogordo |
| West Mesa 67 Santa Teresa 60 | 2011-12 | Rio Rancho |
| Shiprock | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 76 Shiprock 40 | 2018-19 | Hobbs |
| Silver City | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 57 Silver City 49 | 2007-08 | Silver City |
| Socorro | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 88 Socorro 42 | 2022-23 | H |
| Taos | 2-0 | |
| West Mesa 69 Taos 49 | 1967-68 | Albuquerque |
| West Mesa 57 Taos 53 | 1973-74 | Santa Fe |
| Truth or Consequences Hot Springs | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 80 Hot Springs 57 | 1998-99 | Albuquerque |
| Wagon Mound | 1-0 | |
| West Mesa 42 Wagon Mound 41 | 1966-67 | Albuquerque |
| unknown | ||
| unknown loss | 1996-97 |